Skip to content

MK5 Polo GTI Gearbox horror stories!

Featured Replies

Right guys as some of you know i sold my polo couple of weeks back and after searching for ages i may have come to a conclusion that a polo gti

would be a nice upgrade! nice nippy car that comes with alot of equipment as standard and they are going for sensible money!

only prob that is doubting me in getting one is the gearbox on them! I've heard some horror stories of how fragile they are and they can go anytime,

plus they are costly to replace, could anyone be kindly to shed some light on this matter?

also if they have been replaced are the reconditioned ones as better as the original one, I've heard that the 5th gear bearing is the culprit of the failure

and is the new bearing an improved one that is put in or is it just the same one?

cheers

Parin

  • Replies 28
  • Views 6.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

the reason they go is because that bearing is plastic, not metal like the others. iirc the reconned boxes are fitted with a metal bearing.

the reason they go is the final drive gear is riveted on. These rivets shear. Bearings in the diff are poor quality.

Dont let the gearbox put you off.

I had my doubts. But my GTi's on 80k now. Done 20k since i got it and its been the best car I've owned so far. Theres plenty of GTi's ploding into the 100k mileage on standard box's

You dont hear about the good ones. Just the bad ones.....

  • Author
the reason they go is the final drive gear is riveted on. These rivets shear. Bearings in the diff are poor quality.

Dont let the gearbox put you off.

I had my doubts. But my GTi's on 80k now. Done 20k since i got it and its been the best car I've owned so far. Theres plenty of GTi's ploding into the 100k mileage on standard box's

You dont hear about the good ones. Just the bad ones.....

cheers for that neil, as the gearbox is the main concern of the gti if i do go see one, what should i look out? how should the gear change feel ?

Take it for a test drive.

The gearbox is a little stiff when the oil's cold. Not much, but you notice it more when you drive it from warm as its nice and smooth! Nothing to worry about they all do it!

It should slot into everygear fine, Make sure it doesnt crunch (will do sometimes in reverse)

Any whines from the gearbox be wary of. Clicks or anything. The engine whines a little anyway. Just make sure its not the gearbox.

Regular oil changes in my opinion help. Stick your head under behind the front wheel. Look at the selector shaft. It should be dry. If its wet and the owner doesnt know anything about it. The damage of low oil might have already been done.

Same looking around the driveshaft cups. Sometimes the seals go and weep abit. Its hardly anything and they dont loose much oil. But if you want to sort it its pretty expensive!.

If you find a for sale add. Fire it my way, al take a look :)

  • Author

ok coool dude I'm pref after a black 3 door with relative decnt millage, which year did the climatronic come into place in the gtis? pref after one with

leather aswell not to keen

on the standard interior! if u do see one for sale with said spec please let me know

Thanks Parin!

the early ones didnt have climatronic. 2000 i think. Not sure.

How can you not want leather! :lol:

Find one with leather, and i will trade you my interior lol

Hi sorry to hijack your thread but i have a black 3 door gti on 85 k with climatronic :-D for sale i just pmd u mate let me know

  • Author
the early ones didnt have climatronic. 2000 i think. Not sure.

How can you not want leather! :lol:

Find one with leather, and i will trade you my interior lol

LOL if u read my post again i do want leather! how can anyone say no to leather !

is there anythin else i need to look out for?

Yeah don't let the gearbox issue put you off, they really are great cars! I'm lucky though that when I bought mine it had just had a new gearbox so I shouldn't have any problems

Mine's also had the pedal box done too, which might be something to check. Although as far as i'm aware they were recalled for this problem so most of them should have been done?

I'm not an expert though, i'm still learning lol

about the only other problem apart from the gearbox is a squeaky seat which alot of polo gti owners have said.

I wouldn't let the Gearbox put you off as everyone else has said.Alot of simular power cars have the same problem like Saxo VTR/VTS & Peugeot 106 not to mention all their other faults.Climatronic came on the later 2000 models about May and after i beleive.Not sure about the sqeaky seat problem I've never heard that but then a squeaky seat could take all of 10minutes to sort out.This guide helped me alot so i'll share it with you.

http://www.tigerstyle.co.uk/phpBB3/viewtop...f=7&t=35521

Brad

most have allready had the new gearbox by now tho 8-) mines had the renconed box and runs at 139.6 bhp

  • Author

so guys once its had the reconditioned box put in there shouldnt be any failures?

mostly depends on how good a job the gearbox rebuild was.

VW do a repair kit to replace the rivets. So if this has been done and also better bearings!

  • Author

ah ok so its worth checking reciepts etc! cheers neil uve been most helpfull, I'm geared up for getting one now just cant find a decent one!

Yeah! dont think because a reciept says "brand new gearbox at vw" means its a good one. in most cases it is a new one. which carrys the same defects as the one thats broken!

  • Author

ah ok dude but the likely case that the gearbox has been upgraded with the repair kit is highly likely to happen? as would the gearbox rebuilder use the oem items from Vw?

couldnt honestly tell you. If thats the part of the gearbox thats gone, then yes it will have been replaced!

ah ok so its worth checking reciepts etc! cheers neil uve been most helpfull, I'm geared up for getting one now just cant find a decent one!

Be patient dude,took me 3 1/2 months to find one i was happy with.I'm quite particular with condition & mileage but it's well worth.You'll know when you really want one you've viewed because you'll get the feeling.Good luck with the hunt and please don't worry too much about the gearbox "issue".They are bloody lovely little cars.

  • Author
ah ok so its worth checking reciepts etc! cheers neil uve been most helpfull, I'm geared up for getting one now just cant find a decent one!

Be patient dude,took me 3 1/2 months to find one i was happy with.I'm quite particular with condition & mileage but it's well worth.You'll know when you really want one you've viewed because you'll get the feeling.Good luck with the hunt and please don't worry too much about the gearbox "issue".They are bloody lovely little cars.

ok cool cheers man! with it being just after xmas there hardly any cars up for sale ! ill have to be patient!

sorry don't want to hijack the thread, but i am looking for a Polo GTI or Polo 1.4,1.6 and don't know to much about the polo side of things, as i have had a stream of mk2 20vts,charged vr's etc.

Is there anything else that is a common problem or something look out for on the Polos? the gearbox is a little worrying but will have to have a good look at the paper work etc. (lets hope they haven't put saw dust in the box ;)) lol

is it normal for a polo gti 2001 to have 8 previous owners :?

Edited by shazz

The other thing about the Polo GTi is how has it been treated!!!!

When I had mine it was a one owner car that had genuinely never been raced or rallied!!!

If you find one that you think has been on the traffic light drag strip & you potentially may have trouble. Just check your history when you find the one!!!

yeh, reason being is i am finding one for a very good friend of mine, and i don't want it to be a worry pot lol..if it was my car, i would rip it out and smack a 20vt or something lol.

well i'll be viewing some this week, hopefully it all goes well :)

Edited by shazz

Eight owners is quite high i would say.The more owners it's had typically can indicate on going problems so rather than repair it it's been handed down to the next person as their problem and so on.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.