Skip to content

Mk5 advice please

Featured Replies

right, i've had a few polo's over the years, but mainly been into the mk1 clio scene, been an owner of a williams for nearly five years, but as much as i love it i've always wanted a vw, but i'm looking for something that i can not worry about rust every day and whether or not it's going to blow up whilst overtaking someone. i'm looking mainly at mk5 polo's preferably gti's i know they're not going to be anywhere near the pace of my old stripped out williams, but i want something with as much pace as i can which isn't going to cost the earth, i'm going to start breaking my williams next month so with that cash i aim to buy a polo, i just want something i can drop low on a set of split rims and thats it, what would you all recommend? is a gti worth the extra money or is a diesel a better bet? how much would i be looking to be spending for a nice lowish mileage example? and any pics to persuade me? :D cheers!

Edited by trueXbeliever

  • Replies 21
  • Views 2.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

A quick look on autotrader for 3dr gti's with less than 80k reveals about 12 genuine examples ranging from about £3000 all the way up to £4800

Average to high mileage examples go for between 2-3k

The gti's are pretty fast mate, I dont know the peformance figures of the williams but a standard gti gets to 60 in a shade over 8 seconds and goes on to about 130 mph

It will feel a lot better put together and much more modern than the williams, the gti comes with standard bbs split rims anyway :)

The gti has a number of extra features over the tdi so if you can pick one up at decent price I think its certainly worth the extra cost, I'm not taking anything away from the tdi's though as I'm sure there a good car

Just seen this low mileage example at a very reasonable price looks decent to me:

http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/sales/1503915.htm

Edited by mboyle4

  • Author

cool, thanks alot mate for your reply, reliability wise, should i be worried? or looking for anything in particular before buying one? also what sort of width wheels can you fit on them comfortably with a big drop?

Just seen this low mileage example at a very reasonable price looks decent to me:

http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/sales/1503915.htm

I am afraid you'll be a little late on this one. It's now sat outside my house 8-)

Just seen this low mileage example at a very reasonable price looks decent to me:

http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/sales/1503915.htm

I am afraid you'll be a little late on this one. It's now sat outside my house 8-)

lol don't blame you mate looks like a right gem for the money

Ask about gearbox history as they can be a weakspot on the gti's

Try and get one thats had its cambelt done as again its sometimes a weakspot

In terms of lowering and width of rims, haven't a clue m8, theres a few on here that are scraping the floor mind

  • Author

whats the score with gearbox problems? i heard they can suffer badly, why's this?

I will let someone else go in to specific detail but they can be weak and many people have had to replace/recondition their gti gearbox, however many haven't aswell, mines been fine never had any problems and touch wood I won't. Every car has its faults mate, I wouldnt let the gearbox problem put u off them!

Heres a very useful thread courtesy of uk-polos.net (everything you need to know about the gti) Again don't let it put you off:

This thread was created to give more advice for people looking at buying a GTi.

The Mk5 GTI has a 1.6 16v 125bhp Engine, with VVT. It came in either 3 door or 5 door hatchback versions. There were originally, for UK use, produced 500 cars in each colour/door variation, i.e. 500 Red 3 doors, 500 Red 5 doors. The statistics show:

In 2000, there were 1335 produced of the three door and 685 of the five door.

In 2001, there were 904 of the three door and 445 of the five door.

In 2002, there were only 19 of the three door and only 9 of the five door!

Specification:

A base model GTI came with the following:

Xenon Discharge Headlights with automated washer jets

Red Stitched GTi Steering Wheel

GTi Gearknob

GTi “1” Seats

15mm Lowered Suspension

6CD Changer in the boot

Heated Rear Window/Heater Electric Mirrors

Electric Windows

Early 2000 models came with manual air-conditioning, supplemented with a sunroof. At a certain stage, Climate Control (digital control over the cabin temperature) became standard.

All red rear "GTI" badge on pre-alignment models. Red seat belts too.

As an accessory some GTis were equipped with heated leather interior, which came in either black or beige colour. It’s estimated to raise the car value by about 500 pounds. (As an optional extra was about 1200 pounds at time of purchase)

If the GTi came with leather interior, the steering wheel/gear knob/seatbelts are different from normal GTi interior, as they are all black, with no red.

In Europe, GTis had an optional extra of ESP, however it wasn’t available in the UK.

GTi has a Thatcham Approved Category 2 Manufacturers fitted alarm.

The car has 16.5cm front and back speakers. Some GTis came with optional Satellite Navigation, which is worth quite a significant amount of money.

Vehicle Weight

Unladen weight - 2390lbs/ 1084kg

Gross vehicle weight - 3285lbs / 1490kg

Buyer’s Guide

Common Problems

Check the Faults Thread, if you haven’t already.

Gearboxes & Clutches

Tend to be the weakest point of the GTi. These are prone for going wrong, especially if driven very harshly. Expect the higher the number of owners to mean the car has had problems, often leading to it being passed down.

Typical mileage for gearbox going wrong is about 60,000 miles. Some last less, some last longer, it all depends upon how the car’s been treated.

The best way to look out for a dodgy gearbox, is to feel the transmission, to see if there are any difficulties selecting gears. If when driving, there’s a strong whining noise, it needs to be looked at. The most common problem is the 5th gear bearing.

Again, a car running significantly more power than standard is more likely to give the gearbox more trouble. If you see a car with no performance modifications or one with, go for the one without, as it would mean the gearbox would have been placed under less strain.

Expect a gearbox rebuild to cost around 600 pounds. If it does need to be carried out, replacing the clutch is strongly recommended.

Clutches tend to have similar lifetime, i.e. 60,000 miles.

Replacement options are either Valeo, LUK or Sachs Clutch Kits. Valeo are the OEM option, however they also offer an aftermarket version. A clutch kit generally costs 100 pounds, if you are given the option of “refurbing” the clutch or a new one, go for the new one.

Engine

Tends to be the most crucial element of the car. GTi, by the owners manual, should be serviced every 6 months, 5000 miles (for an oil change) or 12 months, 10000 miles (for an inspection service).

Typical cost of small service is 100-140 pounds. The inspection costs roughly 200 pounds.

The cambelt is a known weak point in the engine, and needs to be replaced every 40,000 miles or 4 years. If it’s not attended, it could result in bent valves, requiring an engine rebuild.

Another small weakness in the AVY engine, is at about 70-80,000 miles, the oil stem seal valves have been known to go. This is a rare occurrence, and could cost around 300 pounds. Check for white smoke upon start up from cold.

Pedal Box

Due to poor welding at production, VW have made a recall of all GTi pedal boxes. You can ring up your local dealership and they would be able to find out for you if yours has been dealt with.

Other Faults

Just as any MK5, the GTi tends to suffer similar electric faults. The window motors are prone to breaking, so check all windows work, before purchase. A new motor is about 100 pounds.

The central locking pump can also be likely to fail, if it has been exposed to unnecessary moisture. It’s located behind the First Aid kit in the boot, check for any signs of water. A new pump is 160 pounds, however can be picked up from scrapyard for about half that.

Air-Conditioning needs to be regassed on average every 2 years. Make sure it’s working, as a regas generally costs around 100 pounds with purging of the system.

A new compressor from VW is 300 pounds, so is a hefty expense, it would also need to be installed, expect labour charge of 100 pounds. Therefore it’s important to check that air-conditioning works.

Faulty ABS sensors/Dirty ABS sensors can lead to the ABS light up on the dashboard. This could either be the sensor, or the actual “system”. A new sensor is about 20 pounds + fitment.

Ignition management light – could be up on the dashboard, as the GTi is meant to be run on Supreme Unleaded. Putting 95 RON would lead to lambda sensor giving erroneous readings.

Corroding Alloy Wheels – Due to water getting under the lacquer. GTi has Split Alloy Wheels, so refurb is more expensive than that of 1 piece alloys. Expect to pay 60 pounds a wheel, or you can do it yourself. There’s a guide in the DIY Section.

Leaks in the boot/washers – hoses are common for breaking, cheap to repair just need to identify it.

Grab Handles Peeling – These can be bought new from VW, 30 pounds for inside and outside grab handles for both sides. If buying from a dealer, make sure they replace them. The same could be applied to the aerial base and the chrome door catch.

Rear Spoiler Bubbles – Common VW fault, not just on the GTi, would need to be resprayed. Typical cost of 100 pounds.

Corroding Roof Rails, Corroding Boot Handle, Corroding Under Rear Lights – Typical problems, can be sorted out at a bodyshop for a small price.

Other Information

The GTi is group 12 insurance, so relatively high compared to other cars. Do not expect insurance to look kindly on you, especially if you are a very young driver.

Performance modifications can and will lead to gearbox problems. The GTi engine is also not very tune-able, so gains are scarce from Induction Kit/Exhaust/Remap/Manifold. Do not expect more than 150bhp from a tune N/A engine.

If the GTi doesn’t have Xenon Headlights, it’s guaranteed to have been in a head on collision, walk away.

Look at the panels in the sun, you will be easily able to see if any have been resprayed, if the car has suffered any accident damage. Also make sure with a VIN/HPI check.

As mentioned before, check the number of previous owners. The more there have been, the more likely that the car has been passed down with ongoing problems.

In terms of speed, the GTi will never be considered a “hot” hatch, but rather a warm hatch. It will be quicker than a VTR, but not a VTS. The curb weight is 1070kg, which puts the car at 116 bhp/tone.

The GTi tends to be very thirsty on fuel, if using it for town driving, expect MPG of around 32. If taken on motorway it can achieve 42-45MPG driving very sensibly. If you stick it at 75-80mph, your whole tank (37 litres, without going in the RED) will last you around 280-320 miles.

The car needs to be serviced with 10w40 oil, preferably Quantum Synta Silver, which is available from your local VW dealership.

Edited by mboyle4

  • Author

thanks matey, thats a great help, i see this gearbox thing is a pretty big deal, may look at buying something else from previously having a car that has suffered at the hands of the gearbox, do all mk5's suffer from this problem then?

  • Author

Any more guys?

  • Author

Can anyone shed any light on the gearbox problems? Is there anyway to prevent them from dying?

Not alot some go, some dont. Mines thundering on and has been for the 1 year and 20k I've covered in the last year with no issues.

its the final drive gear thats riveted on and the bad quality bearings. Keep on top of oil changes and make sure any leaks are sorted and it'll be fine.

Fuel economy - i get 380-400 miles to a tank pretty much everytime with average driving (some playing lol)

dont let the gearbox put you off. Mines been a fantastic car. Fairly fast, sounds well looks good and comfortable

Edited by neil_dubgt

  • Author

awesome, thanks alot mate, i'm stuck on which colour to go for now, haha.

red stands out the best ;)

  • Author

red looks pretty awersome mind, that or maybe silver, not too sure about black

red looks pretty awersome mind, that or maybe silver, not too sure about black

Don't worry about the gearbox problem as has already been said some do and some don't have problems - mines never had a problem from new.

Blacks obviously the best aswell as is proved here:

http://www.clubpolo.co.uk/forum/index.php?showtopic=187467

Edited by mboyle4

  • Author

cool beans, definately need help on colour choice, wheel wise, i really want a set of th mono's :D

cool beans, definately need help on colour choice, wheel wise, i really want a set of th mono's :D

Well you haven't got much of a choice in colour as its red black or silver: red ones I think are probably the rarest and always look bright which is a bonus, black ones look mint when clean but after one journey there no longer clean and silver ones are probably the most common (despite an equal number of all 3 colours being made supposedly).

Standard they will come with 15" split rim bbs - however it is very common for these to be corroded and people having to refurb or change them

A quick look on autotrader shows these 3 nice examples:

Black:

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/adv.../1500?logcode=p

silver:

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/adv...757ss?logcode=p

RED:

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/adv.../1500?logcode=p

Edited by mboyle4

There are more silver ones around because if you drive a silver GTi, it is proven that you are a far superior driver. The multitude of red and black GTi's whilst having impressively shiny paintwork usually end their lives upside down in a farmer's field due to the owner's ineptness. Maybe.

There are more silver ones around because if you drive a silver GTi, it is proven that you are a far superior driver. The multitude of red and black GTi's whilst having impressively shiny paintwork usually end their lives upside down in a farmer's field due to the owner's ineptness. Maybe.

lol seriously though there does seem to be over twice as many silver ones than black/red when looking for one for sale

  • Author

so when people get the new gearboxes fitted, are they uprated in any form or way?

  • Author

anyone?

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.