Skip to content

How safe are mk3's?

Featured Replies

I bought my skyline under the threat of being kicked out of my house if i got one, i have managed to hide it from them atm but the time will come soon when i park it on the drive and see what happens!

That is brilliant :lol: Good luck when you do park it at home :D

we want pics :ninja:

  • Replies 80
  • Views 8.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

maybe of video reaction would be good too...

id rather not have an airbag in a result of a crash... i like the shape of my nose the way it is !

instead fit some harness and a cage

job done

lol @ the skyline, i am thinking of getting an gsxr6 my mum said she would kick me out the house ! " no race bikes allowed in this house"

Edited by polokid

haha cheers

they haven't noticed that i keep getting car parts being sent to my house although they think i dont have a car!

(for instance two turbos and a carbon fibre spoiler!lol) it does make it easier atm as the car is getting a honed block and forged bits in it atm. My friend is gutted though, she loves having it on her drive!haha

I have told my sister that i had found one i like but haven't told her i bought it, my mum knows i will get one but it is my dad that is going nuts about me even looking!

saf - of what? my parents reaction? if i can i will, ill have my phone recording in my pocket or something. haha

oh yeah the airbag in the skyline has been binned in favour of a small steering wheel, its a sturdy car so should be ok (i hope! haha)

not that I'm planning on crashing it of course!

Edited by sooped_up_g

maybe of video reaction would be good too...

anyone else think 2 girls 1 cup

I've had a run in with a german lorry in my mk3. I was doing about 20 he was doing 40ish. New wing and bonnet. I think my mk3 is pretty safe.

Modern cars are safer but in some cases can cause more injury in saving the driver than the actuall crash would.

Airbags - broken nose's

SRS seatbelts - Broken Collar Bones or severe bruising as the cartridge fires to pull your seat belt tight. (Both of my parents have suffred bad injuries due to these as passenger and driver)

And the worst invention ever but writes off the car while saving the driver The Crumple Zone - The damage to your vehicle is now 10X as bad when these just collapse at the lightest of impacts or minor crash.

Give me an old car any day or ill get a Saab 9000, takes on toyota pick up causing heavy damage to pick up and a new headlamp for the saab. My mum loves her 9000.

If the air bag doesn't catch you what's next? Oh yeah the steering wheel...wonder what mess that'd make of your nose?

Anyone who thinks a Mk3 Polo is remotely safe needs to re-asses their take on safety. I justify it by saying it's better than a bike or a Caterham...

Tav is right. The mk3 Polo is hardly "sturdy" as someone stated.

How many times have people posted about having clipped a kerb and bent the chassis leg and suspension?

Given a firm shunt the early Polos fold up like cardboard, see how many have creased the roof at the A pillar and B post even with modest frontal impacts. Same at the rear, the rear wings flare out and crease above the wheel arches - again with fairly minor impacts. However, they are probably structurally no worse than the majority of small cars built at around that time.

I know there are gonna be people on here who reckon they've had a 70mph head on with a lorry and got out unscathed blah blah blah etc, but its all VW biased bullshit IMO.

AIRBAGS, fucking hell theres a lot of bollocks been spoken about them so far. Who was it that mentioned suffocation? Surely they must be joking, or thick! FFS, if they posed a serious threat to driver/passengers in the event of a crash do you think that every mainstream manufacturer would be fitting them? Of course there are going to be the odd incidents where someone suffers a burn or whatever. However these are extremely rare occurences. Its just like when wearing seat belts was enforced, there was always someone who reckoned they were far better off without them.

Modern cars are FAR FAR safer than old ones. Did anyone see the 5th Gear test where they staged a head on collision

between a Volvo 740 "tank" estate and a modern "plastic" Renault Modus? 'Twas fucking frightening I'll tell you!

Its on You tube for those that are bothered. Renault 1- Volvo very deffinately 0!

And lets just think about the parents of the bloke who initiated this thread. Personally I think its nice to hear that his parents are concerned with his wellbeing and safety. They may be unsure of all the safety facts relating to cars, but they do know that airbags save lives. Who can blame them from wanting their son to have a car so equipped?

Edited by breadman

Tav is right. The mk3 Polo is hardly "sturdy" as someone stated.

How many times have people posted about having clipped a kerb and bent the chassis leg and suspension?

Given a firm shunt the early Polos fold up like cardboard, see how many have creased the roof at the A pillar and B post even with modest frontal impacts. Same at the rear, the rear wings flare out and crease above the wheel arches - again with fairly minor impacts. However, they are probably structurally no worse than the majority of small cars built at around that time.

I know there are gonna be people on here who reckon they've had a 70mph head on with a lorry and got out unscathed blah blah blah etc, but its all VW biased bullshit IMO.

AIRBAGS, fucking hell theres a lot of bollocks been spoken about them so far. Who was it that mentioned suffocation? Surely they must be joking, or thick! FFS, if they posed a serious threat to driver/passengers in the event of a crash do you think that every mainstream manufacturer would be fitting them? Of course there are going to be the odd incidents where someone suffers a burn or whatever. However these are extremely rare occurences. Its just like when wearing seat belts was enforced, there was always someone who reckoned they were far better off without them.

Modern cars are FAR FAR safer than old ones. Did anyone see the 5th Gear test where they staged a head on collision

between a Volvo 740 "tank" estate and a modern "plastic" Renault Modus? 'Twas fucking frightening I'll tell you!

Its on You tube for those that are bothered. Renault 1- Volvo very deffinately 0!

And lets just think about the parents of the bloke who initiated this thread. Personally I think its nice to hear that his parents are concerned with his wellbeing and safety. They may be unsure of all the safety facts relating to cars, but they do know that airbags save lives. Who can blame them from wanting their son to have a car so equipped?

I mentioned suffocation obviously you read it so you know it was me! but I now relise i got it mixed up with children in front of one.

No need to be over the top, the guy wanted to convince his parents so he could have a mk3 not have a lecture on airbags. show some respect for others on club polo!

  • Author
Tav is right. The mk3 Polo is hardly "sturdy" as someone stated.

How many times have people posted about having clipped a kerb and bent the chassis leg and suspension?

Given a firm shunt the early Polos fold up like cardboard, see how many have creased the roof at the A pillar and B post even with modest frontal impacts. Same at the rear, the rear wings flare out and crease above the wheel arches - again with fairly minor impacts. However, they are probably structurally no worse than the majority of small cars built at around that time.

I know there are gonna be people on here who reckon they've had a 70mph head on with a lorry and got out unscathed blah blah blah etc, but its all VW biased bullshit IMO.

AIRBAGS, fucking hell theres a lot of bollocks been spoken about them so far. Who was it that mentioned suffocation? Surely they must be joking, or thick! FFS, if they posed a serious threat to driver/passengers in the event of a crash do you think that every mainstream manufacturer would be fitting them? Of course there are going to be the odd incidents where someone suffers a burn or whatever. However these are extremely rare occurences. Its just like when wearing seat belts was enforced, there was always someone who reckoned they were far better off without them.

Modern cars are FAR FAR safer than old ones. Did anyone see the 5th Gear test where they staged a head on collision

between a Volvo 740 "tank" estate and a modern "plastic" Renault Modus? 'Twas fucking frightening I'll tell you!

Its on You tube for those that are bothered. Renault 1- Volvo very deffinately 0!

And lets just think about the parents of the bloke who initiated this thread. Personally I think its nice to hear that his parents are concerned with his wellbeing and safety. They may be unsure of all the safety facts relating to cars, but they do know that airbags save lives. Who can blame them from wanting their son to have a car so equipped?

I think thats about as truthful as anything (though i dont want to say it) I saw the topgear test, it was frightening! But at the end of the day its the risk that you choose to take by driving an old car :p

  • Author
:shock: Shit!

@ scrobert, I was merely talking facts as opposed to bullshit. It wasn't meant to be a lecture, just plain common sense.

What I said doesn't have anything to do with a lack of "respect" for others on Club Polo either.

Its not nice to think that mk1/2/3 polo's are lethal

What breadman has said is 100% correct

Its not nice to think that mk1/2/3 polo's are lethal

What breadman has said is 100% correct

Hence why I am keen to fit a roll cage and keep mine as strictly track orientated car. That way everyone is driving the same way and there are less 'knobs.'

Edited by Tav

Airbag = Nappy.

---

I've just seen a video of a man tripping over a paving slab and cracking his head open. So from now on,I'm gonna walk everywhere with a crash helmet on.

defo couldnt be assed being involved in an accident in a mk3 tbh lol

Stick a whoopee cushion on the horn button = job done.

Plus, in an accident, it'll disguise the noise when you shit yourself! :thumbsup:

less 'knobs.'

i would'nt say that

- 1:19 is were the funny stuff happens
less 'knobs.'

i would'nt say that

- 1:19 is were the funny stuff happens

Notice how he goes straight on without bothering anyone else...

...plus I said less knobs, not zero knobs.

I'm not too worried about not having an airbag, it's not like I ever use them when I'm in a car with one anyway.

Jesus, was reading this in awe at some peoples attitude towards airbags, what Breadman's said I really agree with :thumbsup: I saw that 5th gear on TV, really made me think.

Being a sensible driver also helps a bit, if you're one to drive at full pelt everywhere, well...

I realise my mk2 isn't the safest place to be, think my mum felt the same after she was a passenger and commented it was like a 'tin can', especially compared to my old Ncap-friendly Mk4 Ibiza.

From what i have seen mk2/mk3 polos just bend at the slightest bump.

SP_A0058.jpg

Says it all really.

I wouldnt like to have a crash in one, hence why I'm spending money in where its needed, brakes and tyres. Might give me a slightly better chance if the reaper decided to have a go.

That's pretty much what Charlie's looked like. Look at it in analysis though, the front seat are is intact, the driver and front passenger seats haven't moved, headrests are in place. Whether a modern small car would be in any better shape is something I'm not too sure about.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.