Skip to content

'I'd rather drive a slower MK4 than a faster MK3'

Featured Replies

Mk1 and Early Mk2, cause anything else is a SEAT. :lol:

  • Replies 84
  • Views 5.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

All I hear on here now is how Mk4's are the shit, and how they are better than Mk5's etc etc

Mk5s FTW

if i was to be getting another polo its would be mk1,2,3 nothing higher end off !!!!

How long is a piece of string?

Twice as long as half a piece of string? :-p :-D

mk4s from behind look like a old punto *waits to be shot* but they do lol. Altho wen modded right they can be nice, wher as good condition mk3 can be really nice aswell. mk2 i used to love but not so sure no more and mk1 i love

mk4's look better from the back than they do the front imo.

especially if they have rolled arches etc

WOLFSBURG EDITION is what its all about really!

LOL @ this thread.

Prefer MK5 over MK4

Id rather have a MK5 than i would my MK3

but then id rather have a G40 over a MK5

If you want something that handles well, (EXTREMELY well) and goes fast and is as light as a feather you dont buy a polo, simple as!

you get a PROPPER mini (not the BMW crap) and mod that ;)

Yeah because 1960's chassis and engine design aimed at saving people money during an oil crisis really are the way forward...

id have a 205 GTI over any mini if were talking non-vag....

Yeah because 1960's chassis and engine design aimed at saving people money during an oil crisis really are the way forward...

lol, it is!

All watercooled cars are shit. Radiators are for losers! :-p:D

All watercooled cars are shit. Radiators are for losers! :-p:D

I secound this :thumbsup:

prob just because my beetle engine doesnt miss a beat and is far older than my previous cars which all had problems often.

You'd have been right Tav,had the prototypes not suffered from fatigue at the suspension mounts. Later in the developement of the mini,only then was it decided to fit expensive subframes to combat this. The subframes stayed,and they made no money. Ford bought one,stripped it,and said they'd make a loss of 13 percent on every car if they built it. Thanks to subsidy,it was very well invested in.

To answer the opening post,the 6n is more civilised,easier to plod about in,smoother and quieter,and feels safer. With its big-car feel,it was probably the best small car,

at doing all this,for its time.

Which is great,if you like that sort of thing..

Well this sure was an interesting read! lol! i own a mk.2 a mk.3 AND and a mk.4! and to be honest..

here goes...

Mk.2 looks best

Mk.3. fastest

mk.4. handles best...

but this is all based on the mods i have, so i think the answer is, theres no right answer..

The point is, we can round and round in circles... but i love em all!!! peace guys! :)

Nova lookalike's FTL

If I could get the same power out of a mk4 as I have in my G40 for the same money id buy a mk4 but I cant so thats why its a shame VW didnt make a "fast" mk4 from stock.

Ideal Polo (using standard Polo parts) = Mk7 GTI chassis, G40 engine, Mk5 GTI interior/exterior

Edited by Mouse_GTI

Ideal Polo (using standard Polo parts) = Mk7 GTI chassis, G40 engine, Mk5 GTI interior/exterior

That does sound like a good combination!

113 hp isnt really enough to move a heavy mk7 chassis

German made mk2 in my book but i am biased like most of the people on here.

:nod:

Yeah,thats a bit confusing given that the MK5 (ckaMK7) 1.8 turbo GTi starts at 150bhp without mods,and can be tuned to over 300. But the MK2F (ckaMK3) 1.3 G40 engine needs major tune to get 150bhp.

I've never driven a 9n/2/3 but i dont see how such a heavy,upright car can be so nimble anyway.

It would be completely pointless putting a G40 engine into a Mk7 chassis, the chassis is far too heavy for the engine, it wouldn't go very fast at all, you'd be best off sticking with the original engine and spenging the money you would've spent on the conversion getting more power out of the 1.8T which lets be honest isn't really that difficult at all.

G40's don't need major mods to get them to 150bhp at all, it's easy to achieve this sort of power with very few mods at all. Ported charger, induction kit, toothies and chip will see you there, not a massive amount to spend considering the fun you will get out of it.

The Mk7 GTi that I drove (which was a standard car) really didn't impress me at all, I didn't feel that it had any more get up and go than the mk5 GTi and it certainly wasn't as nimble around the corners etc.

I really can't see this thread going anywhere because at the end of the day everybody is different and is looking for something different in a polo. I can see why Mk4's are so popular as they really do handle well, mine had a lot of issues with rot though which put a bit of a damper on it for me. I think the Mk5 is a beautiful car and I loved driving my GTi around, it had enough power to have some fun and get you out of trouble when needed but also had the luxury of air con with leather mmmmmmm 8-)

But neither of them gave me the thrills and smiles that driving my Mk3 G40 around does however going on a long journey in this car seriously tires you out, it's uncomfortable and loud and it takes effort to drive it unlike any of the other types of polo I have driven where you can just plonk yourself behind the wheel and sit back and relax, although the power under the foot does make up for this most of the time :-D

It's horses for courses guys, we will never all agree and that is the beauty of life :-D

Sal. x

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.