Skip to content

engine size

Featured Replies

I think I'm with carver on this one.

  • Replies 116
  • Views 10.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

why buy a g40 if you love hondas?

I dont like the look of honda's generally but i like the engines :D

There's no need to tell me to fuck cause i think the vtec engines are good.

why buy a g40 if you love hondas?

I got a g40 engine for my mk1 polo as it fits in very easily and i will produce a shed load of power, it should make for a fun car that looks great.

Edited by juanv6@hotmail.com

vtec engines are good.

however, if they were the perfect engine, wouldn't everyone use VVT systems?

they cost ALOT to manufacture compared to an 8 or 16 or 20v head...

plus there's more going on so there is more to go wrong... and the lumps dont like it when you slap a vtec controller on and tell it to change cam lobes at 2k rather than 5.5!

8v. simple, but effective.

just to mention, honda have never had a vtec engined returned as faulty or under warranty (its one of there selling points, they make things well)

Umm obviously if an engine is designed to have the vtec changeover point at 5.5k then turning it down to 2k its no wonder you'l get problems (i dont think you could get high lift cams to work at 2k, which in simple terms is what the secondary aggresive lobes are.)

Also the audi/vw 20v engines do use a varition of the vtec system, its just that it isnt really noticable as it not aggresive like the honda vtec, and yes 8v's may be cheap to manufacture but how many new cars have 8v engines, especially hot hatches and sportier variants. i think you'l find that lots of manufacturers are running some sort of vvt/vtec/mi-vec etc its just that honda are the best at this as there the ones that concieved it plus the honda vtec that is in they're type r models, very pronouced and noticable.

Edited by juanv6@hotmail.com

Who gives a shit, really

Edited by carver

Who gives a shit, really

Carver, its just a discussion so i dont know why you have to say things like that as they're not adding anything except creating a bad atmosphere.

There's no need for it carver and its as if you're just trying to create an argument when other people are replying with valid points and contributing to a discussion.

And no i dont hate vw's but i really like mk1 polo's in perticular. you dont need to tell me to "fuck off to honda" and "who gives a shit" as people can have interests out side vw's.

I think you would change your tune if there was a 2.0 polo/golf gti that had 240bhp naturally aspirated 16v engine from factory! and that could still do 30mpg+

I think that an old light vw combined with a agressive vtec engine would be great :D :D

Edited by juanv6@hotmail.com

vw never were performance orientated unlike jap stuff so what do you expect tbh

umm vw's have a great heritage in racing and motrsport, g40, g60, rallye golf, r32, things like the berg cup etc etc.

I dont have a dislike for vw's i think they're great :D just honda do peaky n/a engines the best.

Also honda didn't start off performance orientated (have you ever seen a mk1 civic lol) and they're not very good in f1

Edited by juanv6@hotmail.com

I'm not creating a bad atmosphere if anything you are, this is club polo and i dont see what hondas have got to do with the origional question the fella asked.

I havn't got anything against hondas i'll probably get one in a few years but this is just dragging on and there isn't any answer to it. The guy only wanted some info about his 1.6, then you come along and tell him his engine isn't that good and start blabbing on about how "hondas own"..

There's no need for it carver and its as if you're just trying to create an argument when other people are replying with valid points and contributing to a discussion.

I'm not arguing, i could fully understand if this thread title was '1.6 8v vs Honda vtecs' then fair enough but its not. So stop hi-jacking the thread.

Get an ek9 civic, its got 185bhp from a n/a 1.6......and it looks better than a mk4 polo...... ninja.gif

Just get a honda and be done with it.

Very constructive.

Edited by carver

i know what, "who gives shit, really", yes it wasnt completely on topic but then again lots of threads go off topic i was simply disscusing it with people as they had replied to what i had said, furthermore your the only negative person in this thread, everyone else was having a healthy disscusion even if it had gone off topic slightly

Lots of threads go off topic which alot of people would agree is the downfall of club polo. People were only discussing it because you started talking Honda love for some reason.

I'm being negative because i couldnt give a shit about reading about why Hondas are better then Vdubs and your opinion on engines you dont know about.

Umm obviously if an engine is designed to have the vtec changeover point at 5.5k then turning it down to 2k its no wonder you'l get problems (i dont think you could get high lift cams to work at 2k, which in simple terms is what the secondary aggresive lobes are.)

err, you can get high-lift cams to work to work that low, how else do "non vvt" cars run mad cams? might be no power there, but they run fine.

my point witht this is, maybe you dont want to be constantly ragging it into the 2nd lobes, but wnat instant power from the second you plant it, hence why people run vtec controllers.

Also the audi/vw 20v engines do use a varition of the vtec system, its just that it isnt really noticable as it not aggresive like the honda vtec, and yes 8v's may be cheap to manufacture but how many new cars have 8v engines, especially hot hatches and sportier variants. i think you'l find that lots of manufacturers are running some sort of vvt/vtec/mi-vec etc its just that honda are the best at this as there the ones that concieved it plus the honda vtec that is in they're type r models, very pronouced and noticable.

actually alot of manufacturers are sticking with 16v lumps, only a few run vvt, after all, who buys a fast car for economy?

and as for reliability, VW hold the record, as a mk2 golf broke the million miles without a rebuild marker quite a few years back...

don't get me wrong, vvt lumps ain't half bad, but not everyone like the way a vvt responds or the way you have to drive it hard, constantly to get the performance you've paid for...

just to mention, honda have never had a vtec engined returned as faulty or under warranty (its one of there selling points, they make things well)

It's also not true, I knew the man at Honda who's job it was to deal with failed engines and fined an excuse for the failure.

Also the audi/vw 20v engines do use a varition of the vtec system,

No VW use a smiler VVT system to Toyota's VVTi or BMW's Vanos system, very different in operation to Vtec. The very nature of Vtec's twin lobe design makes it on/off.

Edited by Depresion

A lot of miss information in this thread...

Variable Valve Timing might increase economy but it also allows the engine to be more flexible by producing more torque and more power. So people who say things like...

who buys a fast car for economy?

...are waaaay off the mark. Especially in our current financial climate.

Toyota's VVTL-i is similar to VTEC in that it also uses a high lift lobe. Lotus have advanced the technology slightly by allowing the ECU to decide the cross-over point. If you are really pressing on from low RPM it'll switch to the high lift cam at around 4800rpm, if you are taking life easier it'll old off till somewhere near 7000rpm I believe. Contributes to more performance being available over a wider RPM range when you want it and also improves economy when you want to take it easy. It's the reason the new Lotus SC Elise is so fast and will still return high MPG. See video:

vw never were performance orientated unlike jap stuff so what do you expect tbh

The original hot hatch manufacturer... VW Motorsport...supercharged cars...3.2 litre V6 Golfs with the 'R' for racing prefix...various race series on circuit and in rallying... ...so errr...quite performance orientated?

If you have reaaaaally high lift cams on a 'normal' engine it has to idle much higher. It'll also have a much higher power band and no go before you get to it. The VTEC low lift cam helps you get to the high lift cam in good time. Moving the VTEC cross over point is stupid unless you've changed cam shafts. Honda chose the point to work with the cam shafts profile and the air flow characteristics of the engine. Trying to lower it is just silly...you could actually reduce performance. Also the majority of 'normal' engine haven't been to designed to rev well beyond 8000rpm...

...and what's that shit about Supras and Skylines...do you people have a clue?

Edited by Tav

Thank you, finally some sence :D

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.