Skip to content

Which is Faster?

Featured Replies

even if the GTI is quicker than a G40, it wouldn't be by much, and i reckon a G would be a much funner car to have, got more character ;)

  • Replies 53
  • Views 3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Its tricky getting fair info,as it has to be from the same source - VW add the driver to the kerbweight and third party testers usually get a quicker track time than VW.

Anyway,this is how it is as far as i know..

GTi

0-62: 8.7 seconds

Max speed: 127mph

Weight: 985kgs exc driver

Power: 123bhp/112 lbft

Power2weight: 125bhp/ton

G40

0-62: 8.1 seconds

Max speed: 122mph

Weight: 770kgs exc driver

Power: 113bhp/111 lbft

Power/weight: 146bhp/ton

There will always be differences between individual cars,conditions and drivers.

Remember - the GTi will get round the track approx 1,024 laps before the gearbox breaks,and the G40 will already be in the pits having a charger re-build when the GTi is towed in.

  • Author

thanks man! thats what i was after! it wasnt about which is better in opinion, more which would be the actual winner if the two cars as standard were thave a race!

Cheers :)

Lol regardless of which car wouls win in a race the G40 would but a bigger smaile on your face for sure ..

G40 FTW!

more fun and you actually have to have some driving skill to be able to control it. and hundreds more g-smiles to be had :)

Agreed!! G-40 FTW!

The thing is Jumping Jack Ash, if your asking this question you have obviously never driven or even been in a G40.

Once you get your first G smile you'll be hooked and a Mk5 GTI wont even cross your mind.

until he just wants to go to work...just waft along in a GTi with no sense of speed...scary really! lol

reckon the G40 would have it, GTI's arnt slow. But are pretty heavy.

am i right in saying they both need 3rd to hit 60?

Think a standard G40 stops at 55 in 2nd. So would need 3rd for 60

sure my GTi runs out in 2nd at about the same.

driver could pay a crucial part too!

G40 all day long :lol:

The thing is Jumping Jack Ash, if your asking this question you have obviously never driven or even been in a G40.

Once you get your first G smile you'll be hooked and a Mk5 GTI wont even cross your mind.

He has been in one mate! :)

a heavy car pulled buy a 1.6 16v

or light car pulled by a supercharged 1.3 ?

my mates gti mk5 goes like a fookin rocket so none off you can say there slow and i haven't been in a g40 and yes id say they proberly are faster but i think itl be a good race but still 2 top cars id rather the mk5 as for there a sweet motor but for what they price at you could bye a g40 and tune it slightly have a sweet car and rape the mk5 gti :-D

you can get mk5 gti's for less than a g40 now :o

if you want a fast car why would you buy a polo gti for what, £3800?

Get a half decent one for £2.5k now

There are a few sub £2k examples needing a bit of work, and for less than a grand you could get one that needs a gearbox.

Cheap cars now, considering the kit they come with standard.

if you want a fast car why would you buy a polo gti for what, £3800?

there pretty well spec'd and dont pull too bad

i paid 3600 for one with full vwsh coilovers bmc, various other bits and loads of spares

not a bad price to pay imo.

whats the spec then? i bet the only difference between it and my cordy is xenons and climate? i payed £1200 with mods and its got 30bhp more!

yeah, but a cordy's fugly! lol

aint that bad! and it doesnt eat gearbox's (it prefers pedal box's)

lol..GTI's like both!

touch wood tho av had 9 thousand miles faultless driving

I've driven std versions of both and would have to say there is no noticeable difference in acceleration between them up to 70, the power delivery is very different between the 2. I would still say the gti is the quicker car overall, the handling is superior, brakes better and i cant see that many people will notice the 0.6 sec difference in the 0-60 times (not that 0-60 is a very good test of a cars performance, 30-70 is a much better test).

before anyone claims my car must be knackered then, its putting out 120 bhp and 130 lb/ft torque, so is in pretty good health for a std car with a sports exhaust system and the gti i drove was stock bar a supersprint exhaust.

a g40 is more fun, and probably more tuneable, but if you just want a quick, comfortable and reasonably safe car the gti makes more sense

I'm still sticking with the GTI only because I'm planning on getting one in the next 2 years :lol:

whats the spec then? i bet the only difference between it and my cordy is xenons and climate? i payed £1200 with mods and its got 30bhp more!

I had a Seat Ibiza 1.8 16v GTi last year and left it parked up so long the tyres and battery went flat.

Not too slow once it got going,but christ is was dull to drive.

Always had the choice of driving other vehicles and they didn't have to be as quick to get the vote.

Soup-stirring gear shift,numb power steering - it did slide about a little,with some fish-tail action when provoked,and yet it still didn't entertain.

Hardly a G40-level driving experience,more akin to an early Vectra.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.