Skip to content

Can't Decide!

Featured Replies

As the gti and g40 are so similar in terms of standard peformance its a bit of a no brainer with all the extra kit a gti has to offer..... no doubt a few people will pipe up saying g40's are much faster but according to the on paper figures apparantly not.

G40

Top speed, mph 122

Acceleration, secs 0-60 mph 8.1

GTI

Top Speed 127

Acceleration 0-60 mph 8.4

People buy cars for different reasons but if you want a good 'all round' car i.e comfortable, plenty of features, practical, decent peformance etc the gti is the better of the two and the g40 is more of a raw drivers car

Standard you're right there not much difference but are a lot easier to get more out of

my 150bhp G keeps up with a mates ibiza cupra r and an astra gsi which makes it's 0-60 around mid to late 6 seconds.

  • Replies 29
  • Views 3.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Standard you're right there not much difference but are a lot easier to get more out of

my 150bhp G keeps up with a mates ibiza cupra r and an astra gsi which makes it's 0-60 around mid to late 6 seconds.

yes there is no doubt the g40 is more tuneable, its very difficult to get any more than 10bhp more out of a gti without spending shed loads

if your wanting a gti i would just keep your current car to be fair

  • Author

after seeing a G40 in the flesh and the VW i just instantly thought, MINE!!!!!

but as good as i can get at the mo is a MK3 GT :) Will do!! :)

but would DEFO take up that G40 ride offer! :):):):)

  • 3 weeks later...
As the gti and g40 are so similar in terms of standard peformance its a bit of a no brainer with all the extra kit a gti has to offer..... no doubt a few people will pipe up saying g40's are much faster but according to the on paper figures apparantly not.

G40

Top speed, mph 122

Acceleration, secs 0-60 mph 8.1

GTI

Top Speed 127

Acceleration 0-60 mph 8.4

People buy cars for different reasons but if you want a good 'all round' car i.e comfortable, plenty of features, practical, decent peformance etc the gti is the better of the two and the g40 is more of a raw drivers car

On paper figures, particularly 0-60 times, mean near enough jack shit tbh. I've been out in fast cars that don't feel it (Golf R) and considerably slower cars which are a lot more fun (Ibiza Cupra). On paper the Golf nails the Ibiza to the wall, but the Ibiza has a rawness and a willingness to be driven hard that's really addictive.

And that's between cars with massive differences in performance. Look at these two on paper and the difference is a third of a second. They'll feel totally different to drive. The G40 will nail a GTI for in gear acceleration and the way it delivers the power will make it feel considerably faster too, regardless of the on paper figures. But the flip side is the Mk5 is a much better chassis, so standard against standard the G40 will struggle to get away in the corners.

Basically, regardless of what the figures say on paper you'll have more fun behind the wheel of a G40. Polo fanboys aside, the GTI is kind of seen as a bit of a weaksauce hot hatch as far as I know. It's by far the prettiest Polo out of the box and I know it's not shy, but it won't come near the thrill factor of being in a tin can at warp speed.

Just my 2p.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.