Skip to content

mk3 gt/g40 other options

Featured Replies

My sisters stock 6n 16V couldn't keep up with my mildly tuned breadvan GT on a motorway run. 4 branch/decat/8k chip and a K+N panel filter.

  • Replies 46
  • Views 2.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Author

I really want a mk3 and i know the gt and g40 are completely different but i didnt want to get the gt if it would be slower than my car atmo so ill just save up and get the g40 :p in white when the time is right :D

cheers

Id say go gt first, a tuned gt will almost keep up with a mk4 16v - which is rapid in comparison to your 8v :lol:

Only go for a g40 if you know its the right one.....

Mate a standard gt will keep up with 6n 1.4 16v

no it won't :lol:

They have the exact same 0-60 tines if you look :badgrin:

Id say go gt first, a tuned gt will almost keep up with a mk4 16v - which is rapid in comparison to your 8v :lol:

Only go for a g40 if you know its the right one.....

Mate a standard gt will keep up with 6n 1.4 16v

no it won't :lol:

They have the exact same 0-60 tines if you look :badgrin:

0-60 times should always be taken with a pinch of salt, put them up against each other in real world conditions and see what happens. The mk3 is a lighter car but not so light that it can make up for having 25bhp less than the 16v.

Martin we're talking stock against stock, trying to compare any thing else is pointless.

0-60 times should always be taken with a pinch of salt, put them up against each other in real world conditions and see what happens. The mk3 is a lighter car but not so light that it can make up for having 25bhp less than the 16v.

Martin we're talking stock against stock, trying to compare any thing else is pointless.

Dam you have a serious distrust of anything written down... :-) (Joke!)

According to the internet.. (which might be totally wrong) the 16v has a kerb wight of 1025kg and a GT 800-815kg?

so thats 92bhp/per ton and the 16v has 99bhp per ton so the 16v should be quicker but not by much and but you do have to consider the gearbox ratios, tyre sizes, weight of driver, etc....

solutions put the 16v on carbs in a mk1/2/3.. :nod:

its cheaper than a G40, and maybe a GT, it will sound better than a GT and maybe a g40 (never been in one so can't comment) it will be more powerful than a GT and a stock G40 and the conversion is easy to do!

The GT is about 3/4 of the weight, and 3/4 of the power, with about the same power:weight ratio as a result. Maybe just under,with its shorter gearing being the offset,and it'll be near enough anywhere but the autobahn.

The probability that the 6n holds tighter grip, combines with the probability that the GT is more entertaining to drive - i personally doubt speed is the key issue when considering which one of these cars would be preferable to any particular individual, and i do think this latter point is relevant to the topic because many mistake performance for a measurement of entertainment,and performance figures for a measurement of point-to-point ability. A mistake usually learnt only given time.

  • Author

Just got an insurance quote for 1800 on the gt considering I'm paying 3k now for my 6n thats almost half the price :p

0-60 times should always be taken with a pinch of salt, put them up against each other in real world conditions and see what happens. The mk3 is a lighter car but not so light that it can make up for having 25bhp less than the 16v.

Martin we're talking stock against stock, trying to compare any thing else is pointless.

Dam you have a serious distrust of anything written down... :-) (Joke!)

it's common sense really mate, 0-60 times are done under test conditions, when in real world driving would you be under the same conditions as the test? every thing from the weather to the how much fuel is in the car or the weight of the driver can effect your 0-60 time.

also it has been known for car makers to embellish the 0-60 times of car's to try and sell them, after all it is nothing more than a tool for selling a car, what other purpose does it have? it's not like people tend to race to 60 :lol:

You have to bear in mind even though people go on and on about G40s on here, if you actually expect a standard one to be quick, you'll be sorely disappointed. Obviously it will feel mental compared to a 1.4 8v 6n though.

What they do have going for, in standard form, is bulletproof reliability provided they've been properly serviced, extremely good fuel economy for the performance on offer, and they are pretty good to drive, despite not going round corners, not stopping, and barely creeping into "warm hatch" performance territory.

I would ignore the usual stupid comments like this from people who have never owned a g40 and yet seem to think they are some kind of expert on them and test drive a standard one as long as you've worked out if you can afford insurance etc... Before hand.

Only just seen this, come on now, I never said I was some kind of expert. Surely you've seen posts on here where people think their virtually standard G40s are the be all and end all! I've driven 3 or 4 G40s, true I've never owned one, but I'm sorry if I can't get excited about a standard one but they just aren't all that great, sure they feel quick but they aren't! Modded ones on the other hand can be rather good and brilliant fun, but that's not standard.

it's common sense really mate, 0-60 times are done under test conditions, when in real world driving would you be under the same conditions as the test? every thing from the weather to the how much fuel is in the car or the weight of the driver can effect your 0-60 time.

also it has been known for car makers to embellish the 0-60 times of car's to try and sell them, after all it is nothing more than a tool for selling a car, what other purpose does it have? it's not like people tend to race to 60 :lol:

yeah I agree.. its have been known for magazines not to get anywhere near that stated by the manufacture. And even a law suit or 2 for not being able to achieve the printed top speed.

0-60 times should always be taken with a pinch of salt, put them up against each other in real world conditions and see what happens. The mk3 is a lighter car but not so light that it can make up for having 25bhp less than the 16v.

Martin we're talking stock against stock, trying to compare any thing else is pointless.

Dam you have a serious distrust of anything written down... :-) (Joke!)

it's common sense really mate, 0-60 times are done under test conditions, when in real world driving would you be under the same conditions as the test? every thing from the weather to the how much fuel is in the car or the weight of the driver can effect your 0-60 time.

also it has been known for car makers to embellish the 0-60 times of car's to try and sell them, after all it is nothing more than a tool for selling a car, what other purpose does it have? it's not like people tend to race to 60 :lol:

Sometimes you can better factory figures if you try hard enough though haha, Mk2 16v officially 7.9s to 60 if I remember rightly? 143,000 miles later I had a performance meter recording mid to high 6s, which is about as fast as any other standard front drive hatch.

Dunno what my g40 is 0-60 bloody quick tho FACT

0-60 is a good way to compare cars to a degree, if a car does 0-60 in 4 secs then it's deffo fast.

I was looking at you tube the other day at corsa vxr's 0-60 in those is just under 7seconds, when watching on you tube you can see they have to use 3 gears to get to 60 as opposed to a car that uses 2 to get to 60, it's shows the time In between those gears is very fast and has sharp power to still hit a good 0-60 whilst having to nock time off for 3 gear changes

As for a standard G40 being rather slow.....utter shit, the car is a old car now and back in the day for a 1.3 polo to do 60 in 8! That's far from slow

some body needs to learn the difference between fast and quick.

0-60 times only exist so people that can't drive their quick cars properly have some thing to brag about on forums or down the pub. As i said before when have you ever known any one to race to 60?

a car that is quicker to 60 could still easily get it ass handed to it by a car that was slower to 60 on a drag strip, which is a much better way of judging which car is quickest. As with any test tho it is neglegable because it still relys on the driver to get it right, but its at least in real world coditions rather than test conditions, and lots of people race to a qurter mile making it much more comparable and better pub/forum fodder.

some body needs to learn the difference between fast and quick.

0-60 times only exist so people that can't drive their quick cars properly have some thing to brag about on forums or down the pub. As i said before when have you ever known any one to race to 60?

a car that is quicker to 60 could still easily get it ass handed to it by a car that was slower to 60 on a drag strip, which is a much better way of judging which car is quickest. As with any test tho it is neglegable because it still relys on the driver to get it right, but its at least in real world coditions rather than test conditions, and lots of people race to a qurter mile making it much more comparable and better pub/forum fodder.

this has been seen and done many of times, i had a play with a leon cupra r,i pulled away under 100, when we got to about 115-120 he started creeping on me (private road :thumbsup: )

gear ratios etc have a big play in it too

guy - at springfest last year my stock mk3 GT was beating mk4 16v's on the 1/4mile doing mid 16s, everything was stock.

I've had 5 cars with GT engines now, all of them have performed differently, some are just a freak of enginering and some produce around 80bhp.

Where as i had a worn out mk2 polo with a 3f, dumping oil somewhere, but it used to rev like no other GT i had.

guy - at springfest last year my stock mk3 GT was beating mk4 16v's on the 1/4mile doing mid 16s, everything was stock.

I've had 5 cars with GT engines now, all of them have performed differently, some are just a freak of enginering and some produce around 80bhp.

Where as i had a worn out mk2 polo with a 3f, dumping oil somewhere, but it used to rev like no other GT i had.

That old mk2 was a beast 8-)

whaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!

"oh shit speed camera" :lol:

That beast is mine and I haven't had chance to have any fun in it yet! :(

When the 0-60 sprint was first being used for such a measurement,many cars couldn't get from 0-60. It was quite a challenge,typically taking 20-30 seconds and made for quite a reflection on the performance of the car.

Nowadays,speed limits are typically lower,yet the cars are twice as fast. An equivalent run would be about 0-110 but gearing is very broad being dictated more by economy,and its pointless in a country where the highest speed limit is the 70mph imposed a few decades ago when a non-driver MP acted as a result of an AC Cobra enjoying a legal 180mph on the M1 before it was limited.

Different cars perform on different levels,and the heavy big power cars of today are quite poorly shaped for our roads - from 0-30 i know that not much can hold a Fiat Punto Sporting,even i struggle,but then i can do 10-50 quicker.

I've out-sprinted a late shape Civic typeR, Megane Sport 225 and an M3 V8 has failed to out run me (proof blah take it or leave it). Which makes mine some sort of supercar? Not quite. Just like a Caterham or small Lotus with the same nippy ethos,if the limit was dropped and the road big enough,they'd have left me for toast.

So a test is needed to reflect better the capability of the car. It'll never happen. Some would argue the quarter mile does it,but i cant see it when i get to 100mph in fourth and have to throw away a few seconds getting another 5-10mph in a very long 5th gear. Or hold 4th stable and take the loss that way.

The 0-60 has the same problem - the Saxo VTR was given a long 2nd ratio to get a good time,yet some cars with a lower 0-60 figure can piss on it in the real world.

Then there's the driver. I can get a car from 0-60 quicker than most people,tend to burn the clutch badly,but it works. Which brings us to tracks - we need a trackday. I favour a small track over a baby M25,but that again reflects the nature of the car in question,and it reflects again how difficult it is to devise a test fair to all.

Some would argue the quarter mile does it,but i cant see it when i get to 100mph in fourth and have to throw away a few seconds getting another 5-10mph in a very long 5th gear. Or hold 4th stable and take the loss that way.

Mikey, even with ~140bhp you won't be hitting 100mph by the end of the quarter so give it a go!!

Quicker, more powerful cars will rarely drive at ten tenths on the road - the risks are too high and the roads not wide or empty enough. That's where a Polo GT is immense fun at lower speeds, you can give it utter death everywhere without getting into much trouble. Drive the same in a tuned G40 and you'll soon run out of talent (and road) if you're not careful.

Talking of 0-30mph, I am currently driving one of the engineering development cars from work - although it's limited to 70mph it develops peak torque at 0rpm and only has a single gear. Makes for a great traffic light grand prix contender!

^^ Electric? I read about an electric plastic roadster several years ago that weighed very little,0-60 took like two-three seconds in silence apparently. Didn't go much faster though,or much further..

I might give the quarter a try. Third is a bit too long for rage starts but i can get away cleanly in second if I'm immensely careful,and if a ton is enough then that's two shifts in an optimum range which isn't too bad,gives me a chance.

I'll look into it for my own entertainment,but that doesn't answer the quarter mile being flawed as a test for all cars. Especially as i expect the time of year has more of a factor on it than the 60 run too?

Yeah, electric. You'll get over 100 miles on a charge for a standard Euro emissions drivecycle, or more if you take it steady, or as few as 60 if you drive it flat out. Won its class in the RAC Brighton-London future car challenge the other day. Most of the current generation of EVs could be economically viable if you live in Central London, but battery technology (energy density and cost) needs to improve before we'll see lots of people buying them.

The quarter mile has its place in performance tests, but tends to favour a blend of power-to-weight and traction. Vmax runs, or standing mile or kilometre tend to favour outright power and aerodynamics. 0-60mph sprints are similar to 1/4 mile, but place a lot more emphasis on gearing. 50-80mph is always an interesting one - a torque-less rev monster that'll nail 0-60mph impressively might not fair so well here, a bit fat and flat torque curve reigns supreme.

Guess what I'm trying to say is that there are a million and one ways of measuring the performance of a car, and all of them have their limitations!

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.