Skip to content

polo GTI or TDI help

Featured Replies

  • Author
my GTi was great on fuel. 380 miles on average out of a tank. up to 400 on long journeys.

Previous owner used it to do just what your doing...going to RAF camp and back.

I used it to do a 50 mile daily round trip to work.

Dont disregard it completley.

4k would get you a tidy low mileage GTi with leather probably!

How much to fill the tank on a gti what size are they see i love they way the polo looks when low and on deepdish rims, then i lok at vrs and just looks like a box howe u think i could pick up a vrs for?

  • Replies 61
  • Views 5.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

my GTi was great on fuel. 380 miles on average out of a tank. up to 400 on long journeys.

Previous owner used it to do just what your doing...going to RAF camp and back.

I used it to do a 50 mile daily round trip to work.

Dont disregard it completley.

4k would get you a tidy low mileage GTi with leather probably!

I agree..

I love my GTi...

If you have 4k to play with look at the 9N 1.9TDi (2002-2009) it has a reasonable amount of power as standard and good ones can be got under 4k. I'm picking one up next weekend which i got for £3895. its a 2002 with 60k miles on it which isnt much for these engines and these engones have loads of tuning potential if you want more power. The guy selling it to me is even throwing in a new cambelt and waterpump which he is fitting this week with genuine vw parts.

Edited by wildman_33

my lass has a 6n2 GTI and it's a good little car, has all the comforts you could want, drives nicely, it's quick for what it is too... probably one of the most under-rated cars out there in its class as they're 10x the car of the fiesta zetec S, corsa SRi, Saxo VTS.

It's a good all rounder. But my Bro's TDI will do double the MPG and feels a completely different car as they deliver their power differently to the GTI.

my GTi was great on fuel. 380 miles on average out of a tank. up to 400 on long journeys.

Previous owner used it to do just what your doing...going to RAF camp and back.

I used it to do a 50 mile daily round trip to work.

Dont disregard it completley.

4k would get you a tidy low mileage GTi with leather probably!

How much to fill the tank on a gti what size are they see i love they way the polo looks when low and on deepdish rims, then i lok at vrs and just looks like a box howe u think i could pick up a vrs for?

used to be about 45-50 quid. think its a 47 litre tank.

VRS's arnt bad, i wouldnt knock them. i'd own one as i'm after a boring car next with buying a house. Got a mk2 golf G60 planned as a weekend toy so dont really need a rapid daily when i can blow my socks off at weekend.

You'd be looking closer to 6k though to get a diecent mid mileage VRS.

I'd own another GTi though. Just I've been there and my policy is never to own a car I've already had :lol:

If you have 4k to play with look at the 9N 1.9TDi (2002-2009) it has a reasonable amount of power as standard and good ones can be got under 4k. I'm picking one up next weekend which i got for £3895. its a 2002 with 60k miles on it which isnt much for these engines and these engones have loads of tuning potential if you want more power. The guy selling it to me is even throwing in a new cambelt and waterpump which he is fitting this week with genuine vw parts.

if its the PD 130 engine. anything over 170bhp, which is a remap and you need to be looking at a uprated turbo as standard ones bend the vanes and the clutch wont last much longer :lol:

There fast, if you throw money at them.

In terms of the extremes, as a daily I'd prefer a mapped TDi, just for low end grunt, easy overtaking and better MPG for the work jaunt.

But for a driver's car it needs to be a high revving petrol, being able to keep the needle right by the redline :)

4k would easily get you a tidy GTI with leather.

4k would get you a GTI which would have no worries about a pedal box, no worries aout a gearbox and six gears.

You simply can't beat that one. :)

4k would easily get you a tidy GTI with leather.

4k would get you a GTI which would have no worries about a pedal box, no worries aout a gearbox and six gears.

You simply can't beat that one. :)

I respectfully disagree. :)

Yes, 4k will get you one with leather

But, no, 4k won't guarantee you one which is fault free;

The pedal box is a VW recall and should have been done on all GTi's by now, if not, it's no worry as VW should still honour this recall - Give them a phone call with the reg number to check the car has had it done.

Gearboxes are all hit and miss, it's all down to whether the gearbox has ever had low fluid and regular changes and how it's driven. The gearboxes fail from 30k+ some never fail, mine and a few other are on and around the 120k mark with original boxes. Even repaired ones have known to fail after a few thousand miles due to a poor refurbishment.

And how do you propose one with a 6 speed gearbox? I don't think I've ever seen a Polo GTi 6 speed due to the different bell housing and subframe design from the Lupo Gti; from where I am assuming you're getting the 6 speed gearbox from. It's more work than it's worth, plus the 6 speed is no stronger than the 5 speed. :roll:

Edited by MrP

Well that went straight over your head didn't it Mr P? We aren't talking Polos here :lol:

Well that went straight over your head didn't it Mr P? We aren't talking Polos here :lol:

I fail. Next time I will read before I post. My brain engages a lot without thinking what I'm going to do first. I do say some pretty inappropriate things to people in person sometimes.

I too had to make this decision. Head said TDi (fuel econ, lower tax, remap power etc) but heart said GTi (powaa, xenons and the badge).

Good luck in your decision and be safe out there, with 4K I would be looking at Lupo GTi's ;)

I ran a golf gti mk2, polo gt and then g40 for about 5 years, i sold the g40 wanting something quick but modern so went for the Lupo GTI over the Polo gti as i think the Lupo is much better looking.

The Lupo gti has the same engine and they weigh about the same however the 1.6 16v engine was just to slow especially compared to my g40 (handled much better though!).

My borther was running a 1.4 tdi Lupo Sport and was raving about how good it was so i wnet and bought a 6n2 1.4 tdi in SE spec.

The SE spec isn't that far behind the GTI spec (minus lights and climate) and the 1.4 tdi engine was in every sense better than the GTI. Cheap to run, cheap to insure, cheap to tax.

Best of all was that the enigne was so practical i.e low down revs which for most drivers is what they want plus good overtaking speed.

The further benefit of TDI over GTI (polo) is that the tdi actually has a gear box that works as opposed to a gear box out of an allegro!!!

How many GTIs are there that have not had any problems with box!!

If you want cheap to run, excellent low down pull and an engine that if looked after will do 200k esy then tdi.

theres actually quite a few solid gti's out there. Just they dont come out the woodwork. All you hear about is the bad ones.

Mine was on original box for the 27k i covered. In total 87k without a problem.

no power band.

ahhh man comments like this remind me as to why I stuck to club g40.

The one thing that always stands out above all else on this forum is how young the majority of people are, some of the replies you people make are cringeworthy..

I have a TDi and have no interest whatsoever in speed and racing around like a cock. The speed limit in this country is 70mph, my TDi will do this nicely so why would I be interested in a speed above this, I don`t know. I bought my TDi for cheap motoring, 64mpg and £35 a year road tax. I can`t fault it..

With diesel only 2p a litre more than unleaded its a no brainer. I`m off to sign up to a nova forum and post a photo of an Audi R8 in my signature

sorry gramps

4k would easily get you a tidy GTI with leather.

4k would get you a GTI which would have no worries about a pedal box, no worries aout a gearbox and six gears.

You simply can't beat that one. :)

I respectfully disagree. :)

Yes, 4k will get you one with leather

But, no, 4k won't guarantee you one which is fault free;

The pedal box is a VW recall and should have been done on all GTi's by now, if not, it's no worry as VW should still honour this recall - Give them a phone call with the reg number to check the car has had it done.

Gearboxes are all hit and miss, it's all down to whether the gearbox has ever had low fluid and regular changes and how it's driven. The gearboxes fail from 30k+ some never fail, mine and a few other are on and around the 120k mark with original boxes. Even repaired ones have known to fail after a few thousand miles due to a poor refurbishment.

And how do you propose one with a 6 speed gearbox? I don't think I've ever seen a Polo GTi 6 speed due to the different bell housing and subframe design from the Lupo Gti; from where I am assuming you're getting the 6 speed gearbox from. It's more work than it's worth, plus the 6 speed is no stronger than the 5 speed. :roll:

I really disagree, the six speed 02T box is a lot stronger than the polo gti 085, it's very rarely that you hear about an 02t dying, they tend to kick the bucket from being killed in action driven by idiots rather than daily usage, there's a lot of VERY high mileage lupo GTI's kicking about on the original box.

I used to have a loop GTI and the box, shift and clutch was a shit load better than that in a polo.

The polo uses a cable clutch and a primitive cable shift mech on the gearing.

The lupo uses a proper cable change mech and a hydro clutch, the hydro pedal boxes never snap as there's no tension on it.

Yes, the six speed box doesn't mate up to a polo block, that's why to do the swap you need the entire lupo GTI engine swap.

Wiring, ecu, pedal box, subframe, shifter mech, it's a lot of work. But the gains are well worth it, also the individuality of having one.

It'll take about two days to complete all the necessary work and it is a dash out job which is always an arse ache unless you know what you're doing and then it's just a matter of patience, tightening everything, putting everything back in and zip tying everything back where it originally went.

Two weeks ago I stripped a lupo GTI of all the necessary parts and I'd have probably done the swap by now except it's cold and I built a VR6 3.5 cabriolet this week instead which is semi pointless as it's too icy to enjoy it properly.

The one thing that always stands out above all else on this forum is how young the majority of people are, some of the replies you people make are cringeworthy..

I have a TDi and have no interest whatsoever in speed and racing around like a cock. The speed limit in this country is 70mph, my TDi will do this nicely so why would I be interested in a speed above this, I don`t know. I bought my TDi for cheap motoring, 64mpg and £35 a year road tax. I can`t fault it..

With diesel only 2p a litre more than unleaded its a no brainer. I`m off to sign up to a nova forum and post a photo of an Audi R8 in my signature

i'm not a young un and i enjoy ragging the nuts off my tuned TD :thumbsup:

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

VOTE WAGNOR!

Edited by McLOVIN

The one thing that always stands out above all else on this forum is how young the majority of people are, some of the replies you people make are cringeworthy..

I have a TDi and have no interest whatsoever in speed and racing around like a cock. The speed limit in this country is 70mph, my TDi will do this nicely so why would I be interested in a speed above this, I don`t know. I bought my TDi for cheap motoring, 64mpg and £35 a year road tax. I can`t fault it..

With diesel only 2p a litre more than unleaded its a no brainer. I`m off to sign up to a nova forum and post a photo of an Audi R8 in my signature

waaa

GTi over TDi,

I'm looking at getting a new BMW E46 M3 so I'm on a few forums etc and one thing that has been mention alot is the 335D twin turbo, it will keep up with the M3 and when mapped will beat the M3, pepole have had the 335D and the M3 but went back to M3 because the 335 has a very "NUMB" feeling to them as with all diesels because they don't screem! I know were talking olops but my point is that if you want a performance car or any kind of nippy car then you must like the sound! Diesells have a numb and boring feel to them although they do shift the 4k redline isnt great, I'd love to wind the windows Down and hear a petrol noice and see a nice rev range as opposed to not really hearing a engine and changing gear at 4k.

My old gti polo was mapped to 139hp and a friend has an Audi a3 sline TDI 170 my polo would sit on his ass all day, he could sit on mine too but we couldnt over take and couldnt pull away from each other, I work for VW and drive various amounts of cars and yes some of the modern diesells are impressive but there not a nice sounding screaming petrol!

Ps sorry for spelling fails, iPhone talk!

Vote wagner

The one thing that always stands out above all else on this forum is how young the majority of people are, some of the replies you people make are cringeworthy..

I have a TDi and have no interest whatsoever in speed and racing around like a cock. The speed limit in this country is 70mph, my TDi will do this nicely so why would I be interested in a speed above this, I don`t know. I bought my TDi for cheap motoring, 64mpg and £35 a year road tax. I can`t fault it..

With diesel only 2p a litre more than unleaded its a no brainer. I`m off to sign up to a nova forum and post a photo of an Audi R8 in my signature

Grow down

I'm with him ^^^

Half of the experience of driving a nice sporty car is the aural pleasure and knowing that the effort you put in, you get back again. With a diesel that just doesn't happen, you are encouraged to change up early, and certainly don't get any nice noises to reward you with driving it properly. The worst part for me is the lack of mid corner throttle adjustability you get with a sweet n/a petrol motor due to the numb throttle response.

I'm thinking about getting a Mk3 TDI for a daily as I would be likely to double my mpg and half my insurance costs, but considering even the 2.0 CR TDIs I've driven have been poor I'm not really committing until I'm totally skint.

Regarding BMW diesels, I don't mind them as much as some, but that's because BMW have put a lot of effort into making them drive in a similar manner to a petrol, and the 6 pots even get an acceptable sounding exhaust note, but still have diesel clatter!

GTi over TDi,

I'm looking at getting a new BMW E46 M3 so I'm on a few forums etc and one thing that has been mention alot is the 335D twin turbo, it will keep up with the M3 and when mapped will beat the M3, pepole have had the 335D and the M3 but went back to M3 because the 335 has a very "NUMB" feeling to them as with all diesels because they don't screem! I know were talking olops but my point is that if you want a performance car or any kind of nippy car then you must like the sound! Diesells have a numb and boring feel to them although they do shift the 4k redline isnt great, I'd love to wind the windows Down and hear a petrol noice and see a nice rev range as opposed to not really hearing a engine and changing gear at 4k.

if you lived closer i'd take you out in my jetta and then see if you think td's feel numb :lol: . it's far from the most powerful tuned td out there but combine the way it pull's, plus the noise it makes coupled with the fact it's in a good chassis and it actually makes for a really fun experience. when it comes on boost it sounds like a jumbo jet taking off :lol:

i agree about tuned modern tdi's to a certain extent but i think that's more to do with the fact they are modern car's, they all feel a bit dull to drive when compared with well set up older car's.

and why should the fact that diesels only rev to 4.5k make any difference? type R's rev to double that, but when my work mate tried to show me what his could do the other week i was totally under whelmed. more rev's don't mean better, it's the way the power is delivered that is the important bit.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

VOTE WAGNOR

Edited by McLOVIN

I simply hate the way a diesel delivers power. Could be faster than any petrol car in the world, I'd still hate them, what's exciting about all your torque coming in at once and not being able to hold on to revs? Just the way I'm programmed I guess!

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.