Skip to content

whos is this polo coupe

Featured Replies

I agree with most of those bits mike, but motoring journo's aren't salesmen, they all appreciate a good old car!

That's not true at all, many many of them are just trying to sell some thing and its blatantly apparent by reading their work. It seems to be at its worse in local type papers where they are too afraid of not being given another free car for a week from whichever local dealer to give a honest write up of a car. So much so that every article ends up reading like a press release straight from the manufacturer :lol:

A lot probably don't even have any interest in car's other than a means of making a crust

A little harsh - actually a lot of the writers for local papers are retired thoroughbred petrolheads who have been writing about them for years.

  • Replies 65
  • Views 4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Obviously i haven't read every article ever written but the ones I have in the local rags are more like an advert for the car than an honest write up about it. If they are petrolheads then they seem to have sold their soles so that their newspaper can carry on getting car's to test drive.

Is it sponsored by a local garage?

I've seen some that are - in which case yes it's a thinly veiled advert

I read motoring mags rather than local papers plugging the ssangyyong rexton. Auto Express (terrible for poorly photoshopped cars) Autocar (A little better) and Top Gear Mag (in no way like the TV show and as a result, much better) theose are the ones I read and I'd say they are all into cars.

And you'd be right.

I'd love to be a motoring journo, there is so much I can say about cars and I know how the oily bits work too, but unfortunately I can't write for shit. so as a result of my shattered dream i am learning to design them (well parts of them) instead.

Is it sponsored by a local garage?

I've seen some that are - in which case yes it's a thinly veiled advert

Can't say that I've noticed, I only flick through them when having a dump and haven't got my sun with me

It works across the board. Top gear not salesmen? Rose tinted glasses much..? (they're not the test drivers either actually, they're merely presenters, but anyway).

Come on, they destroy classic cars and promote new ones. Why? Because that's their job.

Scene magazines like 'Fast Power' are virtually catalogues full of accesories - they earn good money from these. So they promote their sponsor's goods and even coax as many impressionable young customers with easily affordable perks, from stickers to topless young girls..

Yeah, the Milton Keynes Citizen is terrible, the bloke is highly impressed with every car he test drives! Well of course he is, it's his job to be, and the local dealerships are not gonna keep giving if they aint receiving.

The NHS needs the pharmaecutical industry, and the pharmaecutical industry needs the NHS. Together they have a nice little system going. The NHS are effectively salesmen, educated and discretionary none the less.

Same with the press. From celebs to cars, telly to mags, the press are there to promote the spoon that feeds.

Only difference with Top Gear is that it's the premiere with it's wide audience, everyone wants their car on there, they can afford to be a bit hard/honest now and then and get away with it.

That ken Gibson who writes for the sun is another one, he couldn't of sucked the scrapage schemes cock any more if he tried, constantly trying to tell us that scraping a perfectly good car so you can get into shit loads of debt is a good idea and actively trying to get it extended. I've got no idea if he's any good at writing about car's mind, I can't seem to get past the fact that he has a face I just want to punch, so much so that I now just chuck the motoring section in the bin before his face makes me angry.

It works across the board. Top gear not salesmen? Rose tinted glasses much..? (they're not the test drivers either actually, they're merely presenters, but anyway).

Come on, they destroy classic cars and promote new ones. Why? Because that's their job.

I guess you never read the magazine then? the one were the three tv presenters write a column, not review.s the reviewing done by road testers and the annual awards that are completely different from the telly ones? for example last years Car of the year was the DS3, a perfectly valid choice as its a good car. and they often write about classics too.

Cack

It works across the board. Top gear not salesmen? Rose tinted glasses much..? (they're not the test drivers either actually, they're merely presenters, but anyway).

Come on, they destroy classic cars and promote new ones. Why? Because that's their job.

Top Gear is a programme about new cars. So yes, it's their job to feature new cars. There are plenty of programmes about old cars, and actually Top Gear runs fairly regular features about classics. Top Gear also regularly slates new cars, and a lot of car magazines do the same. The difference is the way you present the information.

What you'll find is that there are a lot of new car magazines out there because it's an aspirational purchase. Very few people actually purchase new cars. So you'll get your glossy magazines like Evo, Car, etc, that'll go off on a fancy road trip and big up what they're driving because it's an event. Then you'll get mags like What Car? that'll pick a car to bits because it's a title that's actually aimed at people buying a new car. I work for a fleet mag and all I test is new cars, but that's because most businesses will only buy new cars.

The common factor - none of the above should or will be selling positive editorial copy because they're not allowed to do so.

Scene magazines like 'Fast Power' are virtually catalogues full of accesories - they earn good money from these. So they promote their sponsor's goods and even coax as many impressionable young customers with easily affordable perks, from stickers to topless young girls..

Magazines DO NOT EARN MONEY FROM EDITORIAL. Far from it, in fact. That's what the ASA is for - if you run 'advertorial' copy, you MUST label it as an advert.

Yes, you'll get advertisers taking out a promotion because they want to appear near the editorial they've generated, but this neither guarantees good or prominent coverage. At least, it didn't at Max Power.

How do I know this? Because for two and a half years, I ran the products section in Max Power. I've also contributed to products sections in several other "scene" titles. Once you nosh off your advertisers you instantly lose credibility with your readers because quite often it's not the companies with the biggest ad budget that release the coolest new products.

What you will find is that the products in such sections are selected by a journalist based on their taste and what they think their readers will like. So, by definition, they'll be positive. Where you'll find a more balanced view is in product tests. You know, those features where someone spends hours testing the features of said products to find out which one is the best, then reports on it fairly.

Yeah, the Milton Keynes Citizen is terrible, the bloke is highly impressed with every car he test drives! Well of course he is, it's his job to be, and the local dealerships are not gonna keep giving if they aint receiving.

If it's a sponsored section, yes this is true, but that's because it's a sponsored section and not conventional editorial copy. I'm not saying journalists aren't open to bribes sometimes, or that this guy isn't, but it's not "his job" to be impressed with every car he drives. It's his job to give an impartial view. If he isn't doing this, he's a blagger, not a journalist.

Same with the press. From celebs to cars, telly to mags, the press are there to promote the spoon that feeds.

Yes. Readers being the spoon that feeds. Cater for your readers, become a respected title, bring in adverts. Become a useless rag, people don't buy your magazine. Lose your influence, lose your advertisers, lose your money.

Journalists are not slaves to advertisers. At least not the majority of them. See above for those who are (under "blaggers")

Only difference with Top Gear is that it's the premiere with it's wide audience, everyone wants their car on there, they can afford to be a bit hard/honest now and then and get away with it.

So can most magazines. I don't know where you get this idea that all road tests are positive, because it's wholly inaccurate.

Naturally a magazine is a business, and therefore is dependent on an influx of money through advertising and the cover price. So yes, any magazine (particularly free papers) are dependent on gleaning money from advertisers. But what you'll find is most manufacturers are quite happy to advertise alongside a fairly written, but negative, review if it's in a big magazine. Any magazine that allows advertisers to buy positive copy through large scale advertising deals is playing a risky game, and you'll find next to nobody is prepared to do so.

But hey, what do I know? It's not like I do this for a living or anything.

Guy, if i saw u and didnt know you, I'd assume u were a chav :lol:;)

he isnt? :?

LOL :lol:

I was wondering when alex would appear.......

Alex - For one, i didn't say Top Gear were in a unique position. I said they were in a premium position.

For seconds, i believe i was talking about local rags and accessory mags in that context, but still i didn't say they were slaves to manufacturers. I stated their position in the market, yes. And acknowledged some behave differently to that than others.

And for thirds, you have an agenda to protect your profession, so whilst you're more knowledgable than me on how your particular field runs, i'll reserve the right to take from it what i choose.

Alex - For one, i didn't say Top Gear were in a unique position. I said they were in a premium position.

Only difference with Top Gear is that it's the premiere with it's wide audience

For seconds, i believe i was talking about local rags and accessory mags in that context,

Were you?

Scene magazines like 'Fast Power' are virtually catalogues full of accesories

You've amalgamated Fast Car and Max Power. Those aren't (or weren't, in MP's case) local rags, and neither are the other "scene" mags.

but still i didn't say they were slaves to manufacturers. I stated their position in the market, yes. And acknowledged some behave differently to that than others.

No, you said:

From celebs to cars, telly to mags, the press are there to promote the spoon that feeds.

And went on to liken the press to salesmen for the car industry, in the same way that the NHS is selling pharmaceutical goods.

And for thirds, you have an agenda to protect your profession, so whilst you're more knowledgable than me on how your particular field runs, i'll reserve the right to take from it what i choose.

Your choice.

And I reserve the right to present a fair, structured argument to the unfounded rubbish you're posting.

Before you attack my career for being a glove puppet for the automotive industry why not call a few press offices and advertising agencies and ask them how much control they have over the editorial content of magazines. I guarantee you'll get the same answer - they'd probably love to control what we say as it'd make their lives a WHOLE lot easier, but they don't.

Suggest also calling the ASA and asking them what an advertorial is, as from what I can tell it's not something you know about.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.