Skip to content

Club Polo Calender 2013.... mods please read this

Featured Replies

I think there should be Atleast one picture of each model polo to make it fair to everyone and then a few different picture like mk1 and mk8 to show a where we started to where we are at that current year it gives abit of history but all picture for the calendar must be submitted in November so that it can be produced in time for December - January it gives more time, I am always happy to help out with the calendar to who ever is sorting it out at the time

  • Replies 51
  • Views 2.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Sounds interesting

Adam. :)

yeah you missed the point on this forum you have people that would vote for the 6n onward then you would have people vote for the mk3 and previous. more of which drive 6ns on then mk3 previous so the calender would be primeraly 6n and newer rather then mk3 and previous so less people would buy the calender hence club polo loose out on profit

The current calendar is voted for by the forum members anyway, the only difference would be that it would be voted over 12 months instead of a couple of weeks like it currently is.

I like the idea of polo of the month as long as its clearly pointed out that anyone getting their mates to sign up and vote for them will be banned from entering again. The polo of the month became a massive joke on the other polo forum it was on with some very suspicious voting patterns going on which totally devalued the whole point of it

Edited by Mclovin

but your only one person bud there are to many narrow minded people on this forum

You're being a little bit hypocritical there in all honesty. You're claiming everyone is 'narrow minded' yet you seem biased towards the 6n owners who're narrow minded, saying we/they will always vote 6n's or out number people. I think you need to calm down a little bit tbh.

Just because i own a 6n, it doesnt by any means say that i, or any other 6n owners would necessarily vote for a 6n or a newer car. In reality, you don't actually know what people are like untill it happens.

i never once claimed that everyone was narrow minded. you to seem to have missed the point of my arguement, there are narrow minded people on this forum, always have been, always will be, with veiws that 6n and newer are better or mk3 and older are better, ergo these people will more then likely vote for a car they associate with there own. its like me saying 6n2s are crap mk1s are loads better then you saying vice versa thats where the narrow mindedness comes from.

when i say unbiased individual i mean someone from another forum who has no veiws on polos but can tell where work and effort has been put in this way everyone who enters will have a 100% fair chance of having there car in the calender

But Matt its going to be the same 'narrow minded' people voting for polo of the month as it is voting for the calendar currently. Nothing will change other than the time scale its done over

Seems like a good idea to me tbh :thumbsup:

Matt your never going to get an unbiased opinion between newer/olders cars on here no matter how the voting is done, some people prefer newer some older - no matter how we vote for it people are going to vote for their personal favourite

Yep, if the majority prefer a certain shape then you can't force them to vote for another sort just to please the minorities. Maybe it should be open to paying members only tho? At least this would stop randomer mates joining up to vote for their boy

The argument for biased voting doesnt make sense, as McLovin points out, its already a voting system. In fact the current system could be even more bias as you have a massive range of cars to choose from and could possibly chose 12 of any one model etc. Also, that shortlist is compiled by the mods (correct?). If people uploaded their own pictures it would be truly democratic and as mikey says, may encourage people to take some time and some effort into making their car looking good. Additionally, if you dont get in one month, its possible to put a bit more work in and try again the next month

polo3 is a smaller forum, and as such less likely to be moderated as strongly as here. If dodgy voting patterns appear, I trust the team here to eliminate the problem, much in the same way as mikey suggested.

TBH, I didnt vote this year as it was a massive effort to load and look through all the pictures. My computer wouldn't even load them all up. I doubt I'm the only one that couldnt be bothered either. A monthly one would be much better and more manageable. Also, if you happen to miss the december vote (as it stands atm) you still have 11 more to vote on.

I'm all for it

Maybe it should be open to paying members only tho?

I'd agree with that...Membership should have it's privillages and this should be one of them.

guy has a good solution there

Maybe it should be open to paying members only tho?

I'd agree with that...Membership should have it's privillages and this should be one of them.

thats a good shout, more privillages for members woop!

best get my wallet out....

It's only the cost of 5 liters of cider olly :lol:

not for long the moron in charge pm is putting tax on beer again to make more money/stop binge drinking

Can't see that effecting the price of the shit he drink too much Matt :lol:

but your only one person bud there are to many narrow minded people on this forum

You're being a little bit hypocritical there in all honesty. You're claiming everyone is 'narrow minded' yet you seem biased towards the 6n owners who're narrow minded, saying we/they will always vote 6n's or out number people. I think you need to calm down a little bit tbh.

Just because i own a 6n, it doesnt by any means say that i, or any other 6n owners would necessarily vote for a 6n or a newer car. In reality, you don't actually know what people are like untill it happens.

i never once claimed that everyone was narrow minded. you to seem to have missed the point of my arguement, there are narrow minded people on this forum, always have been, always will be, with veiws that 6n and newer are better or mk3 and older are better, ergo these people will more then likely vote for a car they associate with there own. its like me saying 6n2s are crap mk1s are loads better then you saying vice versa thats where the narrow mindedness comes from.

when i say unbiased individual i mean someone from another forum who has no veiws on polos but can tell where work and effort has been put in this way everyone who enters will have a 100% fair chance of having there car in the calender

Yeah you might be right, i was a little tired last night so only scanned everything.

You get narrow minded people wherever you go, you have to put up with it tbf. If a voting system was arranged where only paying memebers, or members with a certain amount of posts could vote etc that'd be brilliant - well done to whichever man suggested it!

If not, then you can't, shit happens. Would people really get their mates to sign up to vote though, are they actually that sad? Ha.

Yes they are that sad mate, seen it happen on other sites, plus how often do you see threads like 'vote for my girlfriend' or 'vote for my car' with links inside leading to other sites competitions?

Edited by Mclovin

Ha, such a good point, i didn't even think about the 'vote for my' threads. Sadfucks, should just let it run its course!

Yes they are that sad mate, seen it happen on other sites, plus how often do you see threads like 'vote for my girlfriend' or 'vote for my car' with links inside leading to other sites competitions?

That can backfire, the only times i've done that at such a request, i've looked through and voted for a different car!

It is a problem though.

I think polo of the month is a great idea, but the number of entries you would get on here would be huge, so there would have to be a limit, on a first come first served basis perhaps? Polo of the month has always worked well on polo3 All except the month mattyf cheated by getting randoms from facebook to vote. And then threw a hissy fit when other members/mods took a dislike to the practice, and owned him :lol: . Then is still bitching about it on here months later. Get over it. Polo of the month is a good idea and would work even better on here as there is more variety and bigger numbers to both enter and vote. :-)

I think polo of the month is a great idea, but the number of entries you would get on here would be huge, so there would have to be a limit, on a first come first served basis perhaps? Polo of the month has always worked well on polo3 All except the month mattyf cheated by getting randoms from facebook to vote. And then threw a hissy fit when other members/mods took a dislike to the practice, and owned him :lol: . Then is still bitching about it on here months later. Get over it. Polo of the month is a good idea and would work even better on here as there is more variety and bigger numbers to both enter and vote. :-)

is matt can so called cheat then what stops other from doing the same thing its a stupid idea simple as just have a few fandom picture and atleast one picture of each model polo from mk1 to mk8 simple as

i cant believe people are arguing about a calender

I think polo of the month is a great idea, but the number of entries you would get on here would be huge, so there would have to be a limit, on a first come first served basis perhaps? Polo of the month has always worked well on polo3 All except the month mattyf cheated by getting randoms from facebook to vote. And then threw a hissy fit when other members/mods took a dislike to the practice, and owned him :lol: . Then is still bitching about it on here months later. Get over it. Polo of the month is a good idea and would work even better on here as there is more variety and bigger numbers to both enter and vote. :-)

Matt only did what the mods on there said was ok to do, they said it was fine when it was suggested that some one else was doing it as it got more people to visit the forum then bitched when Matt did it after that. I don't agree with it but if mods are gonna imply that its ok then what chance do you have? Also there's been more than just that one occasion, a couple of months back a photo that mostly consisted of a bonnet and wing as it had been taken from so close up got more votes in the first two days then the winner of the month before had got in a full month :lol:

But that's up to them over there to deal with as they choose, here I think if its going to happen it needs to be done in a way that trys to restrict the chances of that happening as much as possible. I do agree with the limited number tho just to try and make it a little easier for whoever has to deal with it, although if that's the case then obviously only the owner of the car should be able to enter it to make it fairer, but I'd imagine that would go without saying

Can't see that effecting the price of the shit he drink too much Matt :lol:

8-)

Think monthly voting is a good idea, just have submissions for the month, then vote for each months entry into the calender, no car of the month stuff as that causes far too much aggrevation

Will look at implementing this then, as it'll give me less to do come December, will make the time to do a bulk order next year and post it myself as not sure how well its worked this year

Tbf Jon this year will work in my favour as I can't order until mid way through Jan when they probably would of gone before and I would of missed the polo in It's big print debut

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.