Skip to content

6n is a mk3 isn't it.

Featured Replies

I agree with the not merging thing.. I wanted to see if the mk2 and mk2f, mk4 & mk4f owners would argue about being paired together... :-D

I just find it really interesting that the club could be the cause for the reclassification of the polo range and that everyone one in the UK Polo enthusiast market calls a 6n a Mk4 because of us! :?

  • Replies 114
  • Views 5.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I disagree. Leave it as it is - I've heard other journalists refer to the latest Polo as the Mk8 or the eighth-generation car.

I think traditionally it's been done to bring the Polo in line with the Golf, and that makes sense.

Before you ready an argument, consider this.

Mk1-5 Golfs, fine, they're all different. But the Mk6 is a heavy facelift of the Mk5, and Volkswagen refers to this as the Mk6 even though it's not a new car.

It tends to be the case that Polos get facelifted once in their lifetime, whereas Golfs don't. There have been five all-new Golf versions of the Golf, and there have been five all-new generations of the Polo (unless you count the Mk1-3 under one group). So from that point of view it makes sense to have the Polos classified as Mk1, Mk2, Mk2f, Mk3, Mk3f, Mk4, Mk4f and Mk5. Or lump each mark together.

But then in Passat land people group the B5 and the facelifted one into one group. But while Volkswagen groups those two, it separates the B6 and B7 (the outgoing model and its predecessor) despite them sharing the same chassis. So there's no rhyme or logic on that front.

And the Mk1 Scirocco only ever refers to the first car, the Mk2 being the eighties version and the Mk3 being the new one. But the Mk1/2 both use a Mk1 Golf chassis, so technically that's a Mk1 and a Mk1F.

BASICALLY call your Polo whatever you want, because Volkswagen doesn't have a single system. :lol:

Vw does have a single system for what they call the polo's and it goes up to mk5, as do company's selling parts for them. Some jurno's may refer to the new polo as the mk8 but that doesn't make it any less wrong?

We're not talking about passats, or golfs we're on about polo's and vw are clear on what they call each model, I just think that as the largest source of information about polo's in the UK this site should be using the correct names for each type. It comes to some thing when you have people posting up on here talking about their mk3 (6n) and then being told that's its not a mk3 its a mk4. So some one that comes on here with the correct information is leaving with the wrong. It's hardly the fault of the users tho as the site is giving them bogus information in the first place, just look at how many users weren't aware of this until this thread for example

The Golf MK6, VW were quick to stress, is an entirely new car from the ground up. Of course, you only have to park them side-by-side to get your own opinion on that.. Until you look at the last Cavalier and First Vectra (UK badging), where the passenger compartments were kept looking the same deliberately.

VW claim the same, though i agree you have a point in there.

The Passat i've never understood, i'm not even going there.

The Scirocco, yeah i can see that, but it wasn't a facelift. In fact. it wasn't even a re-skin unless you count on it being re-skinned inside and out. I mean, that's like saying a Daewoo Espero is a facelifted Cavalier. No, it's not. Yes, it's the same chassis but that's one element. Same with the original Sciroccos.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Daewoo_E...ar_20071227.jpg

In fact, the Daewoo Nexia was a Facelifted Astra, a mate of mine put the front end on an Astra estate tomake a unique Nexia estate in the '90s and it looked factory.

http://uk.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%A4%D0%B0%...Nexia_rear1.jpg

Then there's the Ford boys calling the first two shapes of Escort the 1&2 when they were the same thing underneath.. etc.. etc.

It's a can of worms across brands, and i agree it's not always simple to follow a brand, which is where common sense comes in. And i think we need to use some and make sense of the mess that is the current grading here with Polos. And it is a mess. Wiki is only a public wall but it makes sense, it's proof of being the most popular.

  • Author

Thanks , I knew I was right :)

Vw does have a single system for what they call the polo's and it goes up to mk5, as do company's selling parts for them. Some jurno's may refer to the new polo as the mk8 but that doesn't make it any less wrong?

I wasn't saying the journos were right - just that this forum isn't where the naming came from.

The Golf MK6, VW were quick to stress, is an entirely new car from the ground up. Of course, you only have to park them side-by-side to get your own opinion on that.. Until you look at the last Cavalier and First Vectra (UK badging), where the passenger compartments were kept looking the same deliberately.

VW claim the same, though i agree you have a point in there.

I was on the press launch of the Mk6 Golf. It's a heavy facelift based on the same platform (PQ35) as the Mk5. The only thing that's designed from the ground up is the bodywork - there are no visible panels shared between the two and I believe the safety structure is slightly different (more widespread use of ultra-high strength steel). The wheelbase is identical to the Mk5, as is the headroom and luggage space with and without the seats down.

Volkswagen certainly wasn't afraid to say so while I was there, either. This is the first Golf not to be introduced with a new platform, the Mk5 Golf was very expensive to make, the Mk6 was designed to be cheaper to build. I guess it made sense to overhaul the styling in line with new models while they were doing so.

Doesn't change the fact that the Mk5 was the most short-lived Golf yet at four years, compared to roughly seven or eight for each of the previous four models. The MQB platform, which will underpin most sizes of VW, is close to production ready so I'd put money on the Mk6 being replaced in the next couple of years. Total life of the Mk5's platform in a Golf will be about nine years.

So yeah the Mk6 Golf is actually the Mk5F.

Does seem the Golf MK6 should be the MK5f, but that's probably best left for VW to argue and for the MK6> Golf owners to ponder on..

I just call then by model, 6n, 9n, 9n3. Gave up on saying Mk's :)

And the gallerys should be renamed :)

Mikey although the mk1 and 2 escorts were the same car underneath once you move on the the later escorts the similarities become even more blindingly obvious. The mk4 was just a mk3 with the corners slightly rounded off and the mk6 was just a mk5 with more uglier lights. Like you say tho its up to the people that make the cars to choose what they call them

Besides even if we were going to class facelifts as a separate Mk then we still have it wrong as the mk1 had a facelift too so surely the new polo would be a mk9 if you were looking at it that way?

If we're being picky - stick the model number in the gallery name alongside what mark it is.

Mk1 to Mk8 is easier to understand than model numbers.

Mind you BMW owners and Civic peoPle don't have any issues with using model codes.

Besides even if we were going to class facelifts as a separate Mk then we still have it wrong as the mk1 had a facelift too so surely the new polo would be a mk9 if you were looking at it that way?

No body panels changed though. That's an update not a facelift.

Like when Mk2 Golfs got the single piece front windows, Mk1s got the bigger rear lights and so on.

You'd have to do a lot of work to a Mk3 to make it a Mk2. Guessing the same is true for a Mk5 and Mk7.

Admittedly updating a Mk1 Golf to late spec would be tough too but it's not that heavy a facelift.

Probably because they haven't been feed the wrong information for years :lol:

It's not even about being picky, this site is using made up info to describe the models of cars, would you use fabricated info in one of your articles? I very much doubt it. There isn't a mk8 polo, go to vw and ask them about a mk8 and they will tell you it doesn't exist, if vw don't recognise the mk8 polo then why is the largest polo forum in the UK?

There is far too much confusion over this subject and its really not being helped by this site in the slightest

Besides even if we were going to class facelifts as a separate Mk then we still have it wrong as the mk1 had a facelift too so surely the new polo would be a mk9 if you were looking at it that way?

No body panels changed though. That's an update not a facelift.

Like when Mk2 Golfs got the single piece front windows, Mk1s got the bigger rear lights and so on.

You'd have to do a lot of work to a Mk3 to make it a Mk2. Guessing the same is true for a Mk5 and Mk7.

Admittedly updating a Mk1 Golf to late spec would be tough too but it's not that heavy a facelift.

It's a face lift to vw tho, mk1 and mk1f, just like mk2 and mk2f. There maybe more differences between the later polo face lifts but its still a face lift in the eyes of vw

I may be wrong here but I thought that the wings were slightly different on early and late mk1's as well as the front valance having a different amount of vent holes in it?

It's not even about being picky, this site is using made up info to describe the models of cars, would you use fabricated info in one of your articles? I very much doubt it. There isn't a mk8 polo, go to vw and ask them about a mk8 and they will tell you it doesn't exist, if vw don't recognise the mk8 polo then why is the largest polo forum in the UK?

To be fair, I'd follow the manufacturer line. In this case, Volkswagen classes the Mk8 as the fifth generation Polo.

The fifth generation Polo made its public debut at the Geneva Motor Show in March 2009. Series production started later that month with European sales beginning in June. Volkswagen UK began taking orders for the new Polo on 7 August, with the first customer deliveries taking place on the ‘on-sale’ date of 16 October. Three-door models followed in December 2009.

However, they're obviously a tad confused themselves:

Penned under the control of the Volkswagen Group’s Head of Design, Walter de Silva, it’s little surprise and certainly no accident that the new Polo bears strong resemblance to the sixth generation Golf, with its face in line with the so-called ‘Volkswagen DNA’. It is larger yet considerably lighter than the model it replaced, contributing to improved fuel economy and emissions.

And when I wrote about the GTI for a road test recently I referred to them by model years, not by what mark they are, because it gets confusing otherwise.

But I don't get it. How come the sixth generation Golf is a new car, but the Mk3 Polo isn't? The Mk3 Polo has a different slam panel, wings, bonnet, a pillars (with a notch cut in for the wings), rear panel and tailgate. The Mk6 Golf is a redress of the Mk5, too. That said, it doesn't have any interchangeable panels. I'd hazard a guess you could fit a Mk6 door onto a Mk5, but the swage lines would be wrong. Mk2/3 Polo doors can be interchanged but you'd have to bugger about with the door card mounts at a guess.

I wonder what percentage of a car has to change before it becomes a 'new' car? The Mk6 Golf isn't a 'new' car as far as I'm concerned. Not that it matters what I think :lol:

It's a face lift to vw tho, mk1 and mk1f, just like mk2 and mk2f. There maybe more differences between the later polo face lifts but its still a face lift in the eyes of vw

I may be wrong here but I thought that the wings were slightly different on early and late mk1's as well as the front valance having a different amount of vent holes in it?

In which case I stand corrected. It's nowhere near as heavy a facelift as the later ones though.

And having used Honda as an example, they're actually calling the new Civic (which is a facelift) the 'ninth generation' model. It's an 8F. :crybaby:

I think use both our 'incorrect' one and the official names. But are we now going to separate 1 and 1F?

This really is a headache for 'Polo3' though, as they're technically a website for the Mk4/5 (which are told to keep out on their website banner)

It's a face lift to vw tho, mk1 and mk1f, just like mk2 and mk2f. There maybe more differences between the later polo face lifts but its still a face lift in the eyes of vw

I may be wrong here but I thought that the wings were slightly different on early and late mk1's as well as the front valance having a different amount of vent holes in it?

Nope, the only differences were the bumpers, grill and headlights.. the 2 extra holes on the fr.valance were just black stickers on some early models, the only real panel differences were the bonnet as it had 1 less crease/line between 1 and 1f, oh and the roof shape changed, but that was between 76/77 :)

I got the front valance info from higgo at gti fest when he was pointing out the early valance some one had fitted to their mk1 which had more holes in it, was I getting confused by that or some thing? (it certainly wouldn't be the first time). It did 100% have more holes in it than higgo's late mk1 tho because he was saying how he would like one for his to aid cooling.

Alex I don't think a company need any % to render some thing a face lift or a new model, it seems they can just pick and choose (see my point about the escorts in my post further up). Once they have chosen tho no matter how much people disagree with it it isn't going to change, so what is the point of this site continuing to use the incorrect terms?

I just can't understand why the fictional mk's would be used by this site, surely using the type (86c, 6n ect) and the official Mk (mk2, mk2f ect) would be more than enough and it would be 100% accurate rather than just some made up one that only seems to exist in peoples minds :lol:

I don't think the mk1 and mk1f would need to be separated, there are so few changes between them and there are so few of them on here anyway that it just wouldn't make any sense to have two separate sections for them. The point I made about the later being a face lift model wasn't because I thought they should be split up but because it just shows how little sense the incorrect system of classing a face lift verson as a new Mk is because if we did that with all of them we would be on number 9 now not 8 :lol:

People using the incorrect mk's probably isn't all to do with this site, but its not going to help any is it? My point is that this site is using mk's to categorize cars but these mk's don't even exist. There is no mk7 polo, it doesn't exist but anyone that comes on here will think there is because this site tells them there is. It just doesn't seem very professional imo

Edited by Mclovin

generally i think its just easier if we refer to the 3rd model of a polo as a mk3. this Mk2F business is bullshit, every car is similar throughout the generations and thats why they're put into a group (eg. the Polo)

this Mk2F business is bullshit

No it's not. Volkswagen call their third guise of the polo the Mk2f. The F stands for facelift. The mk3 is the third bodyshell/chassis, The mk3 is the 6n.

Fuck sake wise up!

Mikey although the mk1 and 2 escorts were the same car underneath once you move on the the later escorts the similarities become even more blindingly obvious. The mk4 was just a mk3 with the corners slightly rounded off and the mk6 was just a mk5 with more uglier lights. Like you say tho its up to the people that make the cars to choose what they call them

Besides even if we were going to class facelifts as a separate Mk then we still have it wrong as the mk1 had a facelift too so surely the new polo would be a mk9 if you were looking at it that way?

Precisely, the MK1 was a chrome front car and the MK2 then was the MK1F. So my '85 is therefore a MK3.

See you can't just pick and choose how to grade cars just because you've watched too much C-Beebies and read too much of the daily mirror. It's not about making it simple for stupid people, it's about making it correct.

VW think they're right and have the position to do so, millions of people over europe support them, including mediums such as wiki, so it's right to follow that pattern here however you argue it.

Alex I don't think a company need any % to render some thing a face lift or a new model, it seems they can just pick and choose (see my point about the escorts in my post further up). Once they have chosen tho no matter how much people disagree with it it isn't going to change, so what is the point of this site continuing to use the incorrect terms?

I wasn't saying it was scientific, I just wonder at what point someone at VW decides "yep, this one's a new model" or whether that's decided by the marketing bods.

And I agreed with you in the last post, so shhh :p

Just leave the gallery section as it is. Mine will still be MK3's in my eyes, and 6n's will still be MK4's. I dont care if its technically wrong, thats what i (and a good many others) like to call them and i wont change. I do clearly understand and recognise the correct model definitions (and use them when i want to get anorachy), but i prefer the way its laid out currently, with MK1-8. I like the clear divide between the models, especially as MK2's and MK3's(2f's) look so different to each other. Sometimes VW themselves appear to have messed up, as has been said further up, changes during the MK2's production were more significant than just the re-design when the MK3 (2f) came out. And the Mk1, surely that should be a 1 and 1f? But wait, again, as said already, that had revisions throughout its production run too! Why are we even arguing over this anyway? People are still going to call there car what they want, arent they? Even though we all know the technically correct answer.

Edited by malaga red

I'd imagine the gallery's would still be laid out in the same way, they just wouldn't have made up mk's that have no relevance to the cars at all (IE the polo mk7 doesn't even exist :lol: ). Call your car what you like but imo a site like this should be leading by example and using the correct terms rather than some imaginary numbers that hold no significance to what vw say at all

I got the front valance info from higgo at gti fest when he was pointing out the early valance some one had fitted to their mk1 which had more holes in it, was I getting confused by that or some thing? (it certainly wouldn't be the first time). It did 100% have more holes in it than higgo's late mk1 tho because he was saying how he would like one for his to aid cooling.

hmm, i know some people cut the two extra holes, or just one of them, but i didnt know any came out of factory like it, might have done though :)

Higgo could say more like I say it was him explaining to me. The story was some thing like it was an early panel with more holes in that the lad had bought new old stock or some thing, higgo was saying it was rare and normally go for good money. Like I say I may of gotten it wrong tho but it defo had more holes in than higgo's

Just leave the gallery section as it is. Mine will still be MK3's in my eyes, and 6n's will still be MK4's. I dont care if its technically wrong, thats what i (and a good many others) like to call them and i wont change. I do clearly understand and recognise the correct model definitions (and use them when i want to get anorachy), but i prefer the way its laid out currently, with MK1-8. I like the clear divide between the models, especially as MK2's and MK3's(2f's) look so different to each other. Sometimes VW themselves appear to have messed up, as has been said further up, changes during the MK2's production were more significant than just the re-design when the MK3 (2f) came out. And the Mk1, surely that should be a 1 and 1f? But wait, again, as said already, that had revisions throughout its production run too! Why are we even arguing over this anyway? People are still going to call there car what they want, arent they? Even though we all know the technically correct answer.

Well that's all your own personal reasons, and you're free to call your car whatever you like.

But that's not the subject - the subject is what this site/club, which claims remotely to have a clue what it's on about, calls the range. It should be professional enough to educate people with VW's (and the most popular publicly) version - instead of educating people wrongly like some rebellious underground version. And most people agree it's not the correct way, so why continue to do it?

Well I've updated them.... :) not that it makes a blind bit of difference as I get the majority of people with still call a 1992 Polo a mk3! :-D

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.