Skip to content

6n or mk3?

Featured Replies

Ok so I now have a mk3 and miss my 6n

  • Replies 57
  • Views 3.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Ok so I now have a mk3 and miss my 6n

Cos you bought the inferior model :p 6n FTW :D

Ok so I now have a mk3 and miss my 6n

You really are odd.

:-D

Was a pretty sorted 6n, once you've sorted the new one to get anywhere near it, maybe you won't miss it so much?

If it's still a step in the wrong direction, i can only suggest an S3.

Surely the question should be....

Piece of crap or OMG BEST CAR EVERRR

I love how majority of the people who slate 6ns have never even owned one haha.

Mine was fun, nippy, looked good, comfortable, warm, smooth, modern etc.

Depends what YOU want from a car, a mk3 is "technically" shit compared to a 6n.

But depends how you drive, what it's for, what you prefer etc

Why is it technically shit compared to a 6n?

I think your saying it for attention :smirk:

Features and stuff.

Hmmmm right...

I bought the other half one for the sole reason there more comfy than the earlier models, and thats pretty much all she cared about.

Standard vs standard (which is the only fair way of comparing) the early chassis is way more fun.

I had to endure the ownership of this mint '99 16v for nearly a year, averaging over 200 miles a week, and it was a waste of my motoring life.

24032011307.jpg

They represent a bad era for VW, being introduced around the same time as all the other dull household appliance vehicles to replace previously enjoyable cars. Opinion? Explanation on driver enjoyment?

Driver involvement. And for a start, that's a safety issue which has proven to me that the 6n is a more dangerous car.

The lifeless steering doesn't communicate well, resulting in my first accident since the 1990s, when having the misfortune to be driving the 6n on ice. Previous years in cars with more communicative steering has given me more control in such bad road conditions - ditto with the feel through the pedals.

Winter is carnage these days, and i think gritters get too much of the blame..

Having owned three MK2's, and being in MK2 ownership for the last nine years solid, i can categorically say the 6n was never more comfortable. The heater is as good in the MK2. It was no different when scraping ice off the windscreen, the only difference in winter is the MK2 is easier to control on snow, as stated above. Air con on some models makes for comfort on the hottest days, most 6n's didn't have it anyway.

The heater is as good in the MK2, visibility is better, the gear change is better, it's got a more reclined driving position, it's just a better car to live with and the facelifted version is the same in all cases . So i really don't get how a 6n is better for 'comfort' exactly..?

Electric mirrors (in some models) you adjust how often? Electric windows which are slow compared to the wind-up ones - stick-thin lazy women and the disabled need only argue against sheer lazyness there. And even they'd moan about the terribly positioned switches.

Headroom and a slide sunroof, both in the same car, that's something us taller folk can say about the 6n. And a lower boot floor. That's honestly all i can think of to say about the 6n over the older model.

I agree here. I spent years doing long motorway trips in mine, both as a GT and a G40, and always found it very comfortable. The old GT seats never gave me back ache, the heaters are warmer than just about any new car I've driven (air con would be nice on the hottest days, but the cold air blowers give some air movement, the rest you can get by opening the windows a crack) and I'm not tall enough to need the extra head room. It's a bit of an effort to manoeuvre in tight spaces because of the lack of power steering, but that's fine once you're moving properly.

With the Scirocco seats and G40's long gearing I've covered huge distances in complete comfort and without my ears ringing. I've dropped the rear seats to carry large loads (can't do that now I've got a strut brace though) and had rear seat passengers without them struggling for headroom or too much for legroom either (the roof is flat to the point where rear passengers sit).

Power steering, electric windows and air conditioning (in some cases) do not a luxurious car make. Of those it's only the air conditioning I miss on mine, and that's only on really cold days. :lol:

Disagree with this though:

The lifeless steering doesn't communicate well, resulting in my first accident since the 1990s, when having the misfortune to be driving the 6n on ice.

My Passat had utterly lifeless steering, but I was always aware of that while driving, particularly on snow, and factored it into the way I was driving. Short of it being a mechanical fault, it's a little unfair to say that lifeless steering 'caused' your crash. Doubtless it didn't help, but neither does not winding your speed down on icy roads.

You're a few years older than me and doubtless don't need that lecture though. I'm not trying to preach, just saying it's unfair to assign blame to the car, otherwise every Polo 6N going down that road would've crashed.

Just saying...

Edited by Alex

the heaters are easily as good as a 6n, untill you do the heater mod. then they are just rediculous!!

handling wise with a few mods i think the early shapes would easily whoop a 6n round a track or something!

also power steering is completely unnecessary, i can do a 3 point turn with one hand in my mk2. if you think the steering is heavy you really should go to the gym.

i wouldnt mind a 6n though for a daily, if it was low and wide. do kinda like them its just that there so common!

I didn't mean to blame the crash on the car, i was the driver, and would like to emphasize that there was no mechanical fault with the car and i failed to keep control of it.

But i do believe that the accident would not have happened in a car without power steering, because i couldn't judge how much grip i had, and then i just could not find where the wheels were pointing once they'd gone.

A 6n is a mk3 isnt it :-p

Why would the 6n get 2nd place at the European car of the year awards and the mk3 didn't even get a look in.

But what would the European car of the year judges know about cars, besides everything.

Boom!! Served!! Burn!! :D

European car of the year list

Cool story bro....

6n's are so dull though, I've driven both and I can say my MK3 is a much better drive, much more involed and feel miles quicker.

I have a mate who's a 6n nut and he even says the MK3's are a better drive but, he reckons 6n's look better..... I think he must have shit in his eyes to be honest. But thats a personal taste.

haven't posted on here for long time, maybe because i dont know anything but still

I've had a 6n for a year now as my first car and its been great, its gone wrong a couple of times but with the aid of a haynes manual I've been able to fix it,

but what i like about the mk3 is that it looks good almost standard, granted it looks better lowered but you dont have to do much cosmetically, but with a 6n to get it to look 'good' whatever your interpretation of good is you have to do more to it. The reason i think this is good is because i think there's a lot to be said for a car that doesn't look too modified but is if you get me,

maybe i just like subtle styling

the heater mod

Tell me more...

Mine already gets hot enough to make my eyes dry out :lol:

also power steering is completely unnecessary, i can do a 3 point turn with one hand in my mk2. if you think the steering is heavy you really should go to the gym.

:lol:

Why would the 6n get 2nd place at the European car of the year awards and the mk3 didn't even get a look in.

But what would the European car of the year judges know about cars, besides everything.

Boom!! Served!! Burn!! :D

European car of the year list

Can I just stop you there, and point out that it got silver to the Fiat Punto's gold? So by your reckoning, your car is inferior to a Punto. Some victory... :lol:

Also, notice that the only generation of Golf to get COTY was the Mk3. Hardly the Golf's finest hour, eh?

Plus the Mk3 Polo is a facelift of the Mk2. Facelifts won't get a look-in at COTY because they're not new cars, they're facelifted old cars. The Mk2 came third in 1982 when it was first launched. The 6R got the top spot in 2010.

It's also completely dependent on which cars get released that year, and is decided based on rational factors. Either that or the Punto is HANDS DOWN the best car released in for MY95. Better than a Ferrari F355, which doesn't get a look-in that year.

I didn't mean to blame the crash on the car, i was the driver, and would like to emphasize that there was no mechanical fault with the car and i failed to keep control of it.

But i do believe that the accident would not have happened in a car without power steering, because i couldn't judge how much grip i had, and then i just could not find where the wheels were pointing once they'd gone.

OK I get that. Passat was impossible in the snow, Polo more predictable. Odd snowmobile. :lol:

and modded the heater, only pics i have

IMAG1121.jpg

IMAG1122.jpg

wasnt fussed about the rough edges because it will probably never be seen again anyway lol

the heater mod

Tell me more...

Mine already gets hot enough to make my eyes dry out :lol:

I'm still none the wiser :lol:

Like I said, it depends what you want.

Everyone's chatting about fun and involvement. Yet max mentions comfort etc, and it hard to compare modded to modded. In standard form I'd agree the mk3 would be more "fun" and "nippier" but after just driving 60 miles in a mk3, I'd have been happier in my 6n.

I'm still none the wiser :lol:

it basically a mod that means you get hot air through the side face vents..

I seeeee! Ah that's pretty cool, hmm...

The funnest car I've had was a '74 Beetle sat on it's arse with a straight through exhaust, highly tuned engine, seats welded to the floor, it handled like a go-kart had no heaters and broke down nearly ever time I took it out.

I had a '09 Fox the car was boring as fuck hardly shifted, sat too high and looked shit. The car run perfect, never broke down and never missed a beat.

If someone asked me which is the best car I'd have to be a Scenist Bitch to say the Beetle

also power steering is completely unnecessary, i can do a 3 point turn with one hand in my mk2. if you think the steering is heavy you really should go to the gym.

:thumbsup: Don't get people that hate on non PAS cars. Never had any more problem with my old polos than I did in my dads grande punto (and they have very light steering)

I'm gonna be biased, never even driven a mk4 but seeing what people say on here about them I don't really want to. My vote goes for the mk3.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.