Skip to content

Buying a used, Mk8 GTI?

Featured Replies

I'm the same with Alex here. Drove the GTi Golf with the DSG and it felt the same. Even in sport it would change up before you wanted it to, or change down before you wanted it to.

Silly car. Still, lovely to drive!

  • Replies 34
  • Views 2.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

If you put it in Sport and change yourself, it gets bored eventually and switches back into Auto. Slow down for roundabouts and junctions and it downshifts for you even if it's in fully manual mode with the gearstick shunted over to the right. It's nothing like a proper manual.

Basically if you use Drive it's got to shift down two or sometimes three gears before it picks up. If you drive in Sport it sounds like you've forgotten to change gear. You spend most of the time driving it manually just to keep it keen.

That does sound pretty awful tbf. My beef with autos is I can change gear better myself so what's the point? On paper the DSG box seems like it shouldn't have this issue but lots of peeps hate em. Still want a go with one, don't knock it til you've tried it an' all that eh.

It can't be that bad :lol: Critics seems to absolutely love it...

Do they? I've yet to see one road test of the Polo GTI which has rated it for having no manual version. It really doesn't suit the car, especially when you can buy a selection of other hot hatches for less money which don't force you to lose the clutch pedal.

Don't get me wrong though, DSG is brilliant. It's an excellent gearbox, and there are some cars it suits (Passat R36 had DSG and that was fantastic, but the power band was wider with a 3.6-litre V6 under the bonnet). Small hot hatches work best when they're no-frills pocket rockets that you have to really drive, DSG doesn't help that.

But it's all down to personal taste and the market is steadily shifting away from manual gearboxes. The UK never switched onto the idea of having automatics before because they were lethargic and made the car use more fuel. DSG gearboxes change gear faster than it's humanly possible to do, and they can be set up to boost fuel economy. Most people see faster 0-62 times and think that makes the car better, some people prefer the convenience of not having to change gear.

The reality is though, you want the control over the gearbox and you wind up in manual mode if you're driving hard. In a seven-speed DSG gearbox you're blipping up and down through the gears a lot. I'd rather a short-shift six-speed manual, it'd be cheaper to buy. But it'd also be slower to 62mph, and considerably thirstier (on paper)

And here's the other thing. If you're pootling along in seventh gear on the motorway and suddenly need more power, it's got two economy gears to get through before it girdles its loins and picks up. If it had a manual gearbox you could knock it down from 7th to 5th in one hit instead of waiting for the car to fumble around for a couple of seconds.

Like I say, it's not an awful system by any means but regardless of factory figures you'll have more fun doing the hard work yourself. It's more involving.

Edited by Alex

I think the DSG vs manual debate is sometimes one of driver perception of speed/control rather than a genuinely scientific difference. Taking Alex's example of pootling on motorway to needing to nail it.

DSG:

1. Driver decides they need/want to nail it.

2. Driver nails it.

3. DSG shifts down a couple of cogs.

4. Shift done, full torque applied.

Manual:

1. Driver decides they need/want to nail it.

2. Clutch down.

3. Move gear selector from 7th to 5th (or equivalent downchange).

4. Clutch up.

5. Driver nails it = shift done, full torque applied.

I'd argue that clutch down, selecting a gear and clutch up again is going to be circa 1500ms - dependant on car ergonmics and powertrain, but it's a rough approximation we use in various safety analyses. Mashing the throttle and getting a response from the engine might add another 200ms to that time, making 1700ms total. Some might manage it quicker if they have little regard for component durability.

DSG normal shifts (not linear pre-selected up-shifts) are circa 600ms on average. Add 200ms for the detection of the driver nailing the throttle to request the shift, and another 200ms for re-application of torque after the shift, and it's all done within 1000ms - quicker than doing it manually.

What's the difference in perception? The DSG shift is instigated by mashing the throttle so it's the start of the process and you've got 1000ms to wait before acceleration, whereas in the manual transmission example it's the last action in the chain of events.

This doesn't excuse compromised calibrations though, and they tend to be the main issue with these sort of systems. Generally speaking the calibration isn't compromised by lack of effort/capability on the engineering side - usually it tends to be compromises of component wear; emissions legislation and cabin comfort that lead to annoying/odd shifting scenarios. Obviously in a manual transmission vehicle the driver has choice over how to control the gearbox, and thus can alter the balance in the wear/economy/comfort trade-off.

My friend loves the gearbox in his Ibiza lol. Weird, guess its personally opinion.

I'm not pro-DSG or auto by the way, but they do require an adjustment in driving style to get the most out of them. If you try to drive it like a manual then you're doing it wrong.

None of this gives VW an excuse for not sticking a manual on the 6R GTI though!

But that's what I mean, it's not a natural feel. People expect them to be instant, but they still fumble around for gears if you need oomph all of a sudden. A lot, if not all, of what makes a car enjoyable to drive is how it feels on the road. Punching a manual gearstick around and revving the engine hard suits a nippy small car like the Polo. I can understand DSG as an option for those who want it but it forces a perceived lethargy on the car that you don't really want in a car like this. I found myself adjusting my driving style around the gearbox, lightly pressing the throttle at junctions while keeping my foot on the brake and so on.

It's not natural if you try to drive it like a manual, I agree!

  • Author

Putting the deposit down this week :)

  • Author

Have a quick look at this;

https://skydrive.live.com/redir?resid=216C9...1013980!383

How much do you reckon i should be paying to get those scratches fixed up?

Oh yeah, if anyone wants it for £3k its yours! 33,450 on the clock, *nearly* full service history, 1 owner before me, 57 plate. Bargain :)

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.