Skip to content

soo confused.what should i do?

Featured Replies

Hello again. Well after having my afh conversion my gearbox went the next day. Getting a recon would cost me 400 plus 60 for the clutch and another 1300 for a respray. Back of my mind is telling me to break it and cut my losses and buy a clio 172 most likely a 182 . The other half of me is telling me to keep it. What would you do? Fix repair the polo or get a clio 182?

Nimal

  • Replies 24
  • Views 1.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • How many boxes are you going to go through till you realise that you should of just got it reckoned so it lasts? As it will end up costing you the same. If you like the polo and want to keep it get t

  • Even still nearly every car comes with its own problems, you have come far with this one to warrant finishing the job and enjoying it longer, always time for fast clios etc won't lie I like them but a

  • Yeah I have the same fetish lol, 106/205 rallye and 106 xsi. Love an old vtr/vts. I've nearly bought a vts as a run around but when I had a saxo I remembered I wasn't actually that happy lol

Posted Images

£1700 for a £500 car, if you dont have to love drop it. £1700 gets you a decent runner and more poke probably

Get a second hand gearbox and buy a new clutch...all in about 150 quid and don't worry about paint just yet.

If you go recon box I would say the same and don't worry about paint right away.

Plus you can either have a tidy-ish clio which have appalling build quality in some areas of the car or a resprayed polo valver which will look showroom fresh and better than a clio will ever look in a bit time

  • Author

Get a second hand gearbox and buy a new clutch...all in about 150 quid and don't worry about paint just yet.

If you go recon box I would say the same and don't worry about paint right away.

Plus you can either have a tidy-ish clio which have appalling build quality in some areas of the car or a resprayed polo valver which will look showroom fresh and better than a clio will ever look in a bit time

thats the thing. i cant justify buying a s/hand gearbox and having it let go again as these gearboxes are weak. I know what your

saying about the build quality inside the clio. But there quick and faster than my mk4 daily. The 172 doesn't look any special to normal clios but the 182 is :wub:. both have come down in prices aslong the cambelt, aux belt and dephaser pulley is done its all good. As thats £800 with parts and labour

Edited by madnemo

Even still nearly every car comes with its own problems, you have come far with this one to warrant finishing the job and enjoying it longer, always time for fast clios etc won't lie I like them but as much as you have the bug for a 182 atm I'll almost guarantee you miss the polo after a month or so

Edited by wizardmanjm

  • Author

Even still nearly every car comes with its own problems, you have come far with this one to warrant finishing the job and enjoying it longer, always time for fast clios etc won't lie I like them but as much as you have the bug for a 182 atm I'll almost guarantee you miss the polo after a month or so

thats true. I think ill have a rest and then decided on whats best. I've always love french hot hatches its my deepest darkest fetish :ninja: way before i got into germans ie mk2 golfs, had a few saxo vts's and a 106 gti in my early twenties but never took a glance on the clio sport range.

How many boxes are you going to go through till you realise that you should of just got it reckoned so it lasts? As it will end up costing you the same.

If you like the polo and want to keep it get the box professionally refurbished. Worry about the other stuff later.

Yeah I have the same fetish lol, 106/205 rallye and 106 xsi. Love an old vtr/vts.

I've nearly bought a vts as a run around but when I had a saxo I remembered I wasn't actually that happy lol

As said 172 and 182 Clio's come with their own problems. I've seen them rendered almost useless following immobiliser problems, also these days all the ones I've seen have horrible looking wear on things like the steering wheel and dash.

If you don't 'need' the car and have the money and time then why not get the 'box taken out and get it rebuilt by a professional. That way it should last you a fair while, probably even the length of time you own the car.

Yeah my mate had one with full service history, he looked after his cars and had nothing but issues.

Wierd things happened like the bottom ball joint securing pin broke or something and the ball joint came out, I seem to remember all his interior cracking, sagging and fading. Mostly his issues were electrical though iirc

On the other hand not much else can go and handle quite like it which is the same size and cost. A fella at the bodyshop where my car was sprayed had a 330 bimmer and his clio 182 apparently lapped on track miles quicker than it

The build quality of those Clios is appalling.

Conversion - means deep pockets. It sounds to me you want a quicker car so I would do that.

  • Author

well alot of thinking. and I've decided to keep it and carry on. should be picking up another rusty valver in a few weeks cheap for the box. i still like those 182 sports and test driven one on friday . there fast and handles sick for standard suspension . but rattly and plasticky inside . as much i want one. i look like a teenage chav .lol.

That's good news, tbf a lot of nice cars feel cheap on the inside after being in VW's I think

You would have looked like a chav too lol how much is a recon box? Atleast you wouldn't have future problems

  • Author

That's good news, tbf a lot of nice cars feel cheap on the inside after being in VW's I think

You would have looked like a chav too lol how much is a recon box? Atleast you wouldn't have future problems

all i need is a nike baseball cap and a nike tracksuit to fit in with the owners of a 182 :lol: recon box is under £400. lucky during my dog walks I've found a 6n valver close to my house that might be for sale soon cheap no mot runs and drives perfect but a rust bucket sitting on the driveway . already test driven it. soo that should be mine next week or two .Honest truth the only thing from stopping me from scrapping it is the color :wub:

Edited by madnemo

People here I've noticed seem to gather lots of the same car! On other forums everyone was happy with just one lol

Let's be honest, the build quality of the 6n is pretty piss poor too. OK interior trim might he made of slightly better plastic, but the shell is made of much worse metal.

Unless you have a lot of love for your 6n it really isn't worth spunking £1700 on, because a bit down the line you might feel like a change and there's no way your gonna see that money back when you sell. If you're doing it because you really love that car then the financial side kinda becomes irrelevant, but it doesn't sound like you have a lot of love for that car with you considering breaking it and cutting your loses.

Second hand boxes aren't expensive nor are 16v conversions, easy to buy another box and put it in

Should've gone for the 172/182

I'm not even going to argue about build quality and whatnot, all I'll say is, it may rattle and creek but atleast its not crumbling to bits like a 6n will.
Spend 1700 quid on a 6n and its still never going to have anything on the clio in regards to performance.
You WILL NOT miss a 6n later on down the line, not as much as you think anyway. Didn't miss my polo anywhere near as much as I thought I would, and I'd owned that sexy bastard 7 years.

After a year with the 172, I'd never go back to anything polo shaped other than a G40.

You do need luck on your side when buying one though, or maybe just common sense. Buy cheap and its gonna be shit (like both my mates who bought them cheap with no history who now constantly say all Renaults are shit) yet mine has been more reliable than the polo was.....

I've heard horror stories reliability wise so far...but as I posted a good while back I think vw reliability is a bit of a myth too

I think your lying about missing the 2F because that was a sexy beast! Lol I definitley agree on performance! I would have a 172/182 but no other clio would do. Polo's tickle my pickle more despite not being so hot of a hatch

I've heard horror stories reliability wise so far...but as I posted a good while back I think vw reliability is a bit of a myth too

I think your lying about missing the 2F because that was a sexy beast! Lol I definitley agree on performance! I would have a 172/182 but no other clio would do. Polo's tickle my pickle more despite not being so hot of a hatch

Haha I do miss it sometimes, just not as much as I thought I would.

I miss simply looking at it rather than I do driving it.

Yeah, never get a none sport. Built in a different factory for one, they're put together better.

Dieppe for those interested, where all the Alpine Renaults were built back in the day.

I do however regret not getting a 205gti instead. I want one badly.

205's are the dogs, I'm looking for a tidy 106 rallye s1. I think I just love the lairy stickers on them. A rallye with the gti 16v would be an awesome little track weapon!

My mate Andrew had a 106 Rallye, thing was quick but still evenly matched against my 16v, but then again mine wasn't slow with the mods I had.

post-10666-0-88589200-1456832156_thumb.j

That's gorgeous. I am more of a s1 man myself though

I think it's the 106's handling which is it's strong suit. Don't really know to much about polo handling other than the mk2's aren't great lol

  • Author

I'm gona carry on and get the polo on the road and enjoy it and hopefully this year November id get a 172/182 rs as my replacement

Edited by madnemo

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.