Skip to content

Mk2f or 6n2 TDI/GTI

Featured Replies

Evening guys,

 

Currently have my Mk2f which I've owned for the last 6 weeks now. It's my only car at the minute and I drive it to and from work. Roughly a 20 minute journey around town, followed by a 3 mile drive on a road littered with potholes, mud and the usual unmaintainted British countryside. Other than that I cover probably an average of 250 miles a month? I very rarely have to drive for more than 45 minutes, and try to avoid journeys that take much longer if I can. As you may have gathered, I'm struggling to deal with the negatives a 25 year old car CAN give you.

 

My point to mention this as you may have realised having read the title of the thread is if I should consequently change my Mk2f for either the 1.4 diesel or 1.6 GTI version of the 6n2. I know some of you may instantly shudder at the thought of doing that, but I'm trying to be realistic here and see what the best Polo is for me. Those wondering, my first car which I still currently have (though up for sale) was a standard 6n. I have heard several negative comments about 6n's but never really understood the stigma attached to them. I did 10,000 miles in my first year in that car and nothing went wrong bar the interior, which ended up being both electric Windows burning out and the same for the rear wiper. I mean yeah, problems but easy £10-20 fixes which I could deal with. Secondly I then went to a standard Diesel 9n which was a nightmare of which I won't go into detail about. But to summarise, rush buy, 178,000 miles and the previous owner did me over. I will leave it there.

 

I found good and bad points to each car, as you do with every car. I just felt that neither were quite fun enough for me. Since owning the Mk2f I've had my first real look at customising my car. Not doing anything mechanically, just messing around with bits here and there.

I intend to keep learning and doing more for my car as I go along, whether that means in my existing or anything that comes in the near future.

 

Pros of the Mk2f

- Character

- Always wanted one

- Great in the summer

- Head turner.

Cons of the Mk2f

- Reliability

- Needs constant checking

- Hard work

- £££

 

Pros of the 6N2 TDI

- Good MPG

- Reliable and sensible

- Cheap Insurance and Tax

- Still can look decent

Cons of the 6N2 TDI

- Not many in 3dr around

- Put off by my old 9n

- Almost a bit too standard?

- Do like a good petrol

 

Pros to the 6N2 GTI

- Bit spicy

- Looks a bit better

- Knowing you own a 'GTI' haha

- Ultimate performance!

Cons to the 6N2 GTI

- Insurance

- Not a fan of the standard interior

- Little bit more expensive

- Insurance (haha)

 

I tried to be as honest as possible. I believe those are my options which I'm fairly stuck with at the minute. I could just do with some honest opinions and advice! I don't want to get rid of my Mk2f as It's an absolute pleasure to drive on a nice day. I'm more preparing for winter and trying to be sensible about how it will effect me in the long run. I don't go mad with modifications, just keep it simple. A set of alloys, maybe leather seats or definitely a non standard change and lowering is all I'd be probably looking to do.

 

I have had a few offers already for straight swaps e.t.c but I don't want to rush into anything and regret losing something I love. Any help at all I would appreciate! I have just over a years driving experience, any insurance advice or Polo known problems are definitely of help to me, along with any previous experiences or reviews. Feel free to reply to this thread or even private message me :)

 

Thanks all, you'll be a massive help to me.

  • Replies 11
  • Views 770
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Could you not insure the coupe under classic car policy and then buy a more modern car for winter etc.. I have had a few 1.4 6ns and they always been reliable.  We now have a 6n2 petrol and it's great

  • I would say go for the Tdi, absolute beasts. Make sure it's Y reg onwards for £30 tax a year (previous are £130)    i did roughly 30k in mine and loved every minute not a single problem 

  • heartagram
    heartagram

    You won't be disappointed with a TDI. They are fun little cars to drive. 

Could you not insure the coupe under classic car policy and then buy a more modern car for winter etc.. I have had a few 1.4 6ns and they always been reliable.  We now have a 6n2 petrol and it's great, I've also had a 6n2 tdi (1.4) and that was a super car.

 

as much as I love older polos I'm not sure I could cope with having one as a daily unless I was doing very little mileage.  That's just me as I'm getting older and have less time and passion to run one.

I would say go for the Tdi, absolute beasts. Make sure it's Y reg onwards for £30 tax a year (previous are £130) 

 

i did roughly 30k in mine and loved every minute not a single problem 

71B4A55D-CA42-4BB8-B215-1089417BB49F.jpg

GTI is really fun to drive. I bought mine and drove through some nice twisty roads in Yorkshire and it was a blast. MPG wasn't bad either. 

 

I have a TDI which is silly on fuel. I think the most I got out of a tank was 650 miles. It's got more than enough power to have some fun with as long as you keep it in the right rev range. The GTI you have to keep at higher RPM to have fun where as the TDI is much lower. You drive it differently.

 

The best thing you can do is test drive both and see what you think. I was really surprised at the TDIs power delivery and how good it is around town. It has the power in the right place to be nipping about. Where as the GTI you have to ring it's neck a bit more to get performance from it.

 

 

  • Author

Thanks guys, just seen all these. 

 

To my knowledge, you have to be 25 or older to be able to apply for classic car insurance. I'm sure I tried a few online and it said I wasn't eligible for that reason?

 

I have read into and looked at these a lot over the last few days. The insurance is my main concern now as GTi with basic mods declared was over £1800 with one years' no claims, for the TDI it's just over £1000 with the same input! The difference clearly means I'm going to look for a TDI. Just seems the right thing to do. I've seen so many nice examples of TDI's and couldn't really tell the difference! (As above!)

 

And thanks for the tip on the tax, I'll keep an eye out as that's a huge difference.

 

I'm going to write off searching for a GTi, I've heard such rave reviews from you lot here and elsewhere that I don't need to look any further.

 

If anyone sees one going or knows one, feel free to get in contact with me and I'll take a look. Preferably a 3 door and in ideally grey or black.

 

Appreciate the help everyone, every little helps!

You won't be disappointed with a TDI. They are fun little cars to drive. 

A TDI will be a cracking car but at some point you will need to fix it even if it is a lot more reliable short term term than a 2F. It will inevitably be a bit more difficult for a first timer to work on than a mk2f.

I would suggest going all out with the 2f and learning the car inside and out by fixing whatever problems may occur. They are cheap and it doesn't take long to get capable doing any job on one.

On the other hand it might be more sensible if you need a daily to store the 2f for another day when your more competent and then just use it as a SORN project and then buy a diesel to get you about

Sent from my SM-G925F using Tapatalk

In case you haven't read up the law on 30 quid a year tax changes next year so cheap tax is gone the 6n2 maybe reliableish however pedal box and gearbox issues with these would keep me steering well clear I'll take a mk2f any day 

I've never owned a Polo newer than a Mk2f, I used them as my only cars did a 40 mile a day commute and went all over in them! They're not inherently unreliable and they don't really need any more checking than you should do for any car.

 

However the 6n2 will be "nicer" to drive, feel more modern, less rattly, quieter and probably quicker and better on fuel. 

Edited by Qwerty

  • Author

I love my Mk2f but I constantly feel uneasy driving it due to every little noise I hear, worrying thinking it could clonk out at any minute.

 

The comfort isn't really a problem but I do believe when I have 2/3 people in the car it does become that extra bit harder to drive.

 

With the Mk2f also having 11 months MOT I'll probably have a better chance of selling it now rather the 8 or so months down the line. I love the simplicity of the car, and I would love to continue work on it, but I just feel that I can't rely on it day in, day out.

 

It's one of those situations where If I had 2 spaces for 2 cars I'd happily own the Mk2f and a TDi but It just simply isnt an option unfortunately!

I thought the tax changes weren't retrospective? 

I've owned my polo 6n2 gti for around a year now, I'm 25 and had about 20 cars.. most alot faster then the GTi but.. I just keep coming back to it!! For the price of running it, it's so much fun to drive and I plan to do some engine/handling mods rather then upgrading the car. In my opinion I think the 6n2 GTI'S are at the lowest price they will hit now, that's why I'm hanging onto mine as I think they will start going up soon :)

Sent from my SM-G928F using Tapatalk

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.