Skip to content

? Polo 1400cc 8v Mk4 Vs. Polo 1300cc GT Mk3 ?

Featured Replies

Seriously, don't go thinking any Polo is 'quick' or handles well. Polo's have always been outclassed performance wise, even now the GTi only has 150bhp where others in it's class have 200bhp.

no they dont, your comparing the polo gti to the focus/renault sport etc....the golf is in that territory

polo gti is up against the fiesta ST etc which also has 150bhp

and i also contend that polos dont handle well because mine does, I've had some scruffy chav in the last version corsa (also pretty good handling) spin out on a roundabout i flew round without drama...

  • Replies 42
  • Views 4.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

110 outa my 8v lol, want a valver tho!!!!!

Dude, did you not even warm her up first?

if his car is anything like mine, cold weather + high speed = temp gauge read lower temps + not so warm air thru blowers :lol:

no they dont, your comparing the polo gti to the focus/renault sport etc....the golf is in that territory

polo gti is up against the fiesta ST etc which also has 150bhp

and i also contend that polos dont handle well because mine does, I've had some scruffy chav in the last version corsa (also pretty good handling) spin out on a roundabout i flew round without drama...

:lol:

I've watched an E36 BMW spin out on a roundabout in my rear view mirror after me

Seriously, don't go thinking any Polo is 'quick' or handles well. Polo's have always been outclassed performance wise, even now the GTi only has 150bhp where others in it's class have 200bhp.

no they dont, your comparing the polo gti to the focus/renault sport etc....the golf is in that territory

polo gti is up against the fiesta ST etc which also has 150bhp

and i also contend that polos dont handle well because mine does, I've had some scruffy chav in the last version corsa (also pretty good handling) spin out on a roundabout i flew round without drama...

my mate spun his corsa C sxi out on a roundabout coming into blackpool follwing my mate in a mk2 punto 1.2 8v beast

wouldve been funnier if it was without incident but he smashed sideways into a tree so only slightly funny depending on your humour. depends on the driver more than anything really

although to be fair that punto was a beast for handling was 10x better than my old 6n

also the polo gti turbo is a bit weak in comparison, when compared to the clio f1 and corsa vxr

Edited by doug

that guy i mentioned had pulled out dangerously right in front of me and then stared at me tryin to be "hard"

later on i seen him come up behind me only this time he had his bird with him. i put my foot down, he chased, then lost at the first roundabout :lol:

its not funny when its a mate who damages a car but when its some1 you dont know who wants to show off and fails spectacularly it really is

i was following my mate upto southport 1 time again he was in a corsa (on hire) come to a roundabout and once again he ended up swerving soooo close to hittin the kerb on the way out, and once again i went in hit the apex came flyin back out without any probs at all, and we're both fairly equal as drivers

and b4 anyone else says it yes i do go a bit daft on the roads sometimes, this time above there was absolutely no1 on the roads so we werent being dangerous...

were you going down the a59 towards southport with like loads of roundabouts on the way down?

thats v.v. close to my house i was a hero* down that bypass

*subject to interpretation lol

lol

to be honest I'm not sure but it sounds about right, dual carridgeway if i remember rightly? either that or full on motorway but think it was dual....

we were pissin about n racing etc all the way there...we only went for some midnight driftin fun on the beach :lol:

Edited by OGDMX

ayeeeeeeeee big long empty dual carriageway

is mint but a proper drain on fuel hahaha

mk4's can out handle many things with the right setup !!

Seriously, don't go thinking any Polo is 'quick' or handles well. Polo's have always been outclassed performance wise, even now the GTi only has 150bhp where others in it's class have 200bhp.

no they dont, your comparing the polo gti to the focus/renault sport etc....the golf is in that territory

polo gti is up against the fiesta ST etc which also has 150bhp

and i also contend that polos dont handle well because mine does, I've had some scruffy chav in the last version corsa (also pretty good handling) spin out on a roundabout i flew round without drama...

I'm comparing it to the Clio 197, the Seat Ibiza Cupra R and the Corsa VXR, all of which have 180-200bhp and are well within it's class. The Fiesta ST makes up for the lack of power with a razor sharp chassis, something the Polo lacks and always has.

Your mk4 may appear to handle well on the road as it has lowered, stiffened suspension etc. Meet an equivalent 205, 106, Saxo, Fiesta, Clio etc and you'll find that in fact it understeers like a biatch and wallows nicely in the corners.

mk4's can out handle many things with the right setup !!

It can out handle many standard cars with coilovers, braced front end and a rear ARB :p

Seriously, don't go thinking any Polo is 'quick' or handles well. Polo's have always been outclassed performance wise, even now the GTi only has 150bhp where others in it's class have 200bhp.

no they dont, your comparing the polo gti to the focus/renault sport etc....the golf is in that territory

polo gti is up against the fiesta ST etc which also has 150bhp

and i also contend that polos dont handle well because mine does, I've had some scruffy chav in the last version corsa (also pretty good handling) spin out on a roundabout i flew round without drama...

I'm comparing it to the Clio 197, the Seat Ibiza Cupra R and the Corsa VXR, all of which have 180-200bhp and are well within it's class. The Fiesta ST makes up for the lack of power with a razor sharp chassis, something the Polo lacks and always has.

Your mk4 may appear to handle well on the road as it has lowered, stiffened suspension etc. Meet an equivalent 205, 106, Saxo, Fiesta, Clio etc and you'll find that in fact it understeers like a biatch and wallows nicely in the corners.

i kinda forgot about the rest after fiesta st i couldnt think of any others :lol: but fair point with those, altho i used to work for ford and had an st as company car n they do hold the road pretty well but still not as well as my polo, and thats not with anything done to suspension setup at all, its only the last month or so that i lowered my car and that was because a spring snapped, but I'm not sayin it'll outhandle anything that'd be stupid, and i cant really compare with any of the frenchies etc because that kinda challenge has never arose nor have i driven any

my basic point tho is mk4 arent anywhere near as bad as people make out

i also cant believe this thread is still going :lol:

Seriously, don't go thinking any Polo is 'quick' or handles well. Polo's have always been outclassed performance wise, even now the GTi only has 150bhp where others in it's class have 200bhp.

no they dont, your comparing the polo gti to the focus/renault sport etc....the golf is in that territory

polo gti is up against the fiesta ST etc which also has 150bhp

and i also contend that polos dont handle well because mine does, I've had some scruffy chav in the last version corsa (also pretty good handling) spin out on a roundabout i flew round without drama...

I'm comparing it to the Clio 197, the Seat Ibiza Cupra R and the Corsa VXR, all of which have 180-200bhp and are well within it's class. The Fiesta ST makes up for the lack of power with a razor sharp chassis, something the Polo lacks and always has.

Your mk4 may appear to handle well on the road as it has lowered, stiffened suspension etc. Meet an equivalent 205, 106, Saxo, Fiesta, Clio etc and you'll find that in fact it understeers like a biatch and wallows nicely in the corners.

Ofcourse being 16 you have loads of experience driving these cars.

OWNED!

:lol:
Ofcourse being 16 you have loads of experience driving these cars.

Obviously not....

...but I do know the opinions of others who have, and I do know which cars do well in the hot hatch/stock hatch/hillclimbing etc, and it really isn't the mk4 polo :p In fact, I don't think I've ever heard of anyone even considering a mk4 polo.... If you've driven a mk4 Polo and can honestly say that it handles better than any of the cars I listed then go ahead and say.

But I severely doubt it.

Your 'engineering design' degree doesn't make the Polo handle well, or lose the understeer it's plagued with (and yes I do know that first hand!)

Ofcourse being 16 you have loads of experience driving these cars.

Obviously not....

...but I do know the opinions of others who have, and I do know which cars do well in the hot hatch/stock hatch/hillclimbing etc, and it really isn't the mk4 polo :p In fact, I don't think I've ever heard of anyone even considering a mk4 polo.... If you've driven a mk4 Polo and can honestly say that it handles better than any of the cars I listed then go ahead and say.

But I severely doubt it.

Your 'engineering design' degree doesn't make the Polo handle well, or lose the understeer it's plagued with (and yes I do know that first hand!)

What understeer? Maybe on your P.O.S Mk2...but in all of the Polos I have driven I haven't experienced any excessive understeer characteristics other than those to be expected in a front wheel drive car. I don't think I'll have much issues with bad handling in the Mk3 either...and that car has a worse suspension set up than a Mk4. Primary reason for not using a Polo for hill-climbing etc. is probably a lack of performance engines as standard and after market motorsport orientated upgrades available. Where as you can pick up a 205 with over 130bhp and a lot of parts available off the shelf....plus motorsport and road driving are quite different.

I've never driven a Fiesta ST, but I have been on track with one whilst I was in a Mk4 Polo 16v. Admittedly the Polo wasn't standard (coilovers & 1600cc bottom end), but it was at a disadvantage in the power stakes to the Ford - weight was probably fairly even, as there were two of us in the Polo. The Fiesta owner was gobsmacked by the Polo's performance.

Mk4 Polos aren't that bad, their standard suspension is just shopping spec - whereas other manufacturers tended to use much sportier spring & shock combinations on their hotter models. VW didn't really do a hotter model 'til the Mk5/6N2 GTI - and that was more cruiser than hot hatch.

I agree with Tav to a certain degree about the lack of Polos in motorsport. You've got to have deep pockets to want to drive a competitive Polo - e.g. you want a straight cut dog 'box with LSD for your classic Mini, it'll be costing you low 4-figures for a good one. Same for a Mk3/4/5 Polo? 5-figures, IF you can find one.

hey mikey, how did you do the power / weight ratio thing ??

i would really like to have the formula to do so..

but could you work out what 95bhp is on a stripped out gt ??

so maby 780kgs :D ???

thank you

Ahem. Power-to-weight ratio kind of tells you what you need to do - the clue is in the name!

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.