Skip to content

MK3 Gt as a daily?

Featured Replies

you can get better MPG out of a GT than a 1.3 SPi, the multi-point injection system is more economical. Although it depends what sort of driving you are doing, on a motorway drive you'll get more MPG from the SPi simply because it's got longer gears.

I also don't see how an SPi is more simple and less to go wrong, there's no more things to go wrong on a GT, not like they have any electrical gadgets or anything, what things on a GT are you thinking of that go wrong Daniel? I don't see why the digifant is any less reliable than mono-motronic, what makes you say that?

  • Replies 37
  • Views 3.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Author

Cheers guys keep the comments / experiences coming and also let the GT/Spi debate rage on!

To qualify things a little i've got a diesel golf for the regular motorway trips, the other halfs '73 beetle for a project and my Karmann Ghia with a 2.2lt subaru engine for a fun weekend car. So this one really is just a get me back and forth to work effort.

So its a back and forth to work reliably and cheaply but if it can make the commute a bit more enjoyable then all the better :-D If i wanted uber cheap reliable transport i'd get a diesel corsa :lol:

Its a compromise between being reliable and cheap but not boring!

  • Author

oh and one other thing, whats the deal with the decat exhausts, are you ok when it comes to MOT time?

oh and one other thing, whats the deal with the decat exhausts, are you ok when it comes to MOT time?

To legally decat the car it needs to be a J plate or before. I got a genuine VW cat replacement pipe for my G40 (there may be one for the GT; I think the G40 is a bigger bore) and it has no issues with passing the non cat MOT. The replacement pipe keeps the lamda probe so fuelling all works as normal, just without the cat to clean up the gases. GT in general is very similar to G40; it's got the rear axle with anti roll bar which the SPi doesn't have.

I like the sound of the beetle, got any pics?

  • Author
I like the sound of the beetle, got any pics?

a little off topic but i'll post some pics later :-D Forgot that i've also got a rather special morris minor, but that dont count as its not really used or useable!

  • Author
oh and one other thing, whats the deal with the decat exhausts, are you ok when it comes to MOT time?

To legally decat the car it needs to be a J plate or before. I got a genuine VW cat replacement pipe for my G40 (there may be one for the GT; I think the G40 is a bigger bore) and it has no issues with passing the non cat MOT. The replacement pipe keeps the lamda probe so fuelling all works as normal, just without the cat to clean up the gases. GT in general is very similar to G40; it's got the rear axle with anti roll bar which the SPi doesn't have.

cool cheers for that. So its 91/92 ish and after that you've got to have a cat to pass the mot sort of thing?

I've only had two cars with cats on before (the rest have been too old or diesel) and one (audi coupe) had no probs with the mot, the other (mk3 golf gti) had a decat pipe which needed to be swapped for the cat to pass the emissions.

theres no VW replacement pipe for a GT as i tried to get one when i ripped my decatted downpipe away from th flange! problems of having it to low!

had 2 GT's, both have been wicked and lasted me roughly 18months each of heavvvvvvy abuse/little maintenance daily driving on average 350miles a week which cost a tank of fuel + £5 but even full on abusing a tenners worth i still always got 75miles+ out of it!

reliability- had a fair few coils randomly pack up, and head gaskets but then they are getting to age now! god the youngest are 14 years old!

Edited by tainmrk3polo

cool cheers for that. So its 91/92 ish and after that you've got to have a cat to pass the mot sort of thing?

yeah, anything on a K-plate or later has to pass the stricter emmisions test (whether it legally has to have a CAT on or not is something of a grey area, technically certain engines when in good order can still pass the test even without a cat).

lasted me roughly 18months each of heavvvvvvy abuse

Note to self - never buy a car from 'tain!

you can get better MPG out of a GT than a 1.3 SPi, the multi-point injection system is more economical. Although it depends what sort of driving you are doing, on a motorway drive you'll get more MPG from the SPi simply because it's got longer gears.

Without the benefit of personal experience, can't verify that myself, but as far as contemporary road tests were concerned and VW themselves, the GT never achieved better mpg than the Spi 1.3. Granted, there wasn't always a lot of difference.

I also don't see how an SPi is more simple and less to go wrong, there's no more things to go wrong on a GT, not like they have any electrical gadgets or anything, what things on a GT are you thinking of that go wrong Daniel? I don't see why the digifant is any less reliable than mono-motronic, what makes you say that?

It could be the higher percentage of Mpi's to Spi's here on CP, but there are occasionally gluts of posts in the tech section of people with GT's who can't seem to get them to run right, or is it just me? Issues I was thinking about were lumpy idles, poor economy and running rich etc. Most of the time these are really only linked to throttle potentiometers, MAF faults or poorly set idle and CO screws , all things which either the Spi aren't fitted with or simply don't ever cause issues.

That said, i'm not trying to make the GT sound bad, far from it. Most of the time, if they're left alone, they're ok. But even then they can suffer problems that Spi's don't.

I find my GT great in stop start traffic. All the mk4's I've had have been terrible in queues and traffic.

How can a car be terrible in a queue? :? lol

all my cars I've owned have ended in the scrapyard...... :paranoid: although some welsh kid bought my first GT lump!! the other ones sat in my car just now doing noghint anlthough bottom end has FAIL written all over it

i had a GT, ragged the fuck out of it on a daily basis and it never let me down (well it did once when the hall sender went, but that seems common on any vw i've had :roll: ). not the best handling car in the world but if its just a daily comuter then that won't bother you i'm sure.

i wouldn't pay over 800 for one tho (not worth much more than that unless its the mintest of the mint imo), some one mentioned in the first reply they are selling for high prices at the min, not sure why, must be scene tax or just people living in dream land.

good luck any way mate.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.