Skip to content

FAO person who did the subforums oin the for sale section

Featured Replies

i prefered it how it was

i used to have a quick ganders at the for sale section incase something caught my eye or was a bargain, i cba to trawl through several sections

what kinda pain is it gona be if you're breaking car ...before you could just post up "mk2 breaking " and then in the post mention wheels, seats , k&n , radio or whatever

  • Replies 74
  • Views 6.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

It'd be nice if I got more constructive comments than telling me it's 'retarded'. Telling me that you don't like it isn't really grounds for it being changed back.

The section will be a lot easier to use and for people to find the parts that they are looking for. I appreciate that you won't be able to browse one forum section (clicking the next link numerous times) looking for bits that you fancy, but realistically it's not going to be any more clicks to browse through the seperate sections than it was previously, and there will be less threads that just say "Garage Clearance" etc and so will save people scanning through multiple pages of a thread to find items.

Sal. x

I think spliting the for sale section in to mk of polo is a good idea, then within each mk thread have the 6 new subframes, that would be ace.

oh an a general junk/random/miscellaneous section as someone is always selling something that is not polo relate

But all in all I'm just happy someone cares an takes time out to try an make the forum a tidier place for everyone. :thumbsup::D

thanks Sal

Edited by wozzapolo1.3

It'd be nice if I got more constructive comments than telling me it's 'retarded'. Telling me that you don't like it isn't really grounds for it being changed back.

The section will be a lot easier to use and for people to find the parts that they are looking for. I appreciate that you won't be able to browse one forum section (clicking the next link numerous times) looking for bits that you fancy, but realistically it's not going to be any more clicks to browse through the seperate sections than it was previously, and there will be less threads that just say "Garage Clearance" etc and so will save people scanning through multiple pages of a thread to find items.

Sal. x

but loads of people like to just browse...for instance i dont "need" anything but if the price is right theres lots of potential parts id buy , and what about rare/random items some people dont know exsist....browsing is good tbh

It'd be nice if I got more constructive comments than telling me it's 'retarded'. Telling me that you don't like it isn't really grounds for it being changed back.

The section will be a lot easier to use and for people to find the parts that they are looking for. I appreciate that you won't be able to browse one forum section (clicking the next link numerous times) looking for bits that you fancy, but realistically it's not going to be any more clicks to browse through the seperate sections than it was previously, and there will be less threads that just say "Garage Clearance" etc and so will save people scanning through multiple pages of a thread to find items.

Sal. x

It be nice if the constructive comments that i have said near 5 times now got a response, instead of picking up on the bad ones, which still portray the simple fact of it doesnt work...

It would be great, if one day i saw an admin or mod post on here (well that alone would be good lol) saying

"howdy members, we are aware their is a issue with the parts for sale section being cluttered, and we are debating how to adress this, does anyone have any ideas?"

Actually put the question to the forum members, and say loads of people give an idea to solve the problem, for the mod admin team to think "yeah thats a good idea think we should go with that"

And it gets done, and the forum runs nicely, the members get their input, and the forum runs better

everyone is happy and no one is annoyed, angry, nothing

?

Yes exactly!

The fact that there is no pre-discussion with club members about changes that are going to happen to the forum pisses alot of people off

i like it,

its 5 subforms for christs sake! no different to trawling through 5 pages of for sale section if you haven't been on in a few days. i agree with adding a breaking section, and a misc section.

the only downside i can see to these subforums is people posting their stuff in all 5, to get extra coverage. or someone with loads of stuff posting in all 5 rather than separating it into different threads.

i like it,

its 5 subforms for christs sake! no different to trawling through 5 pages of for sale section if you haven't been on in a few days. i agree with adding a breaking section, and a misc section.

the only downside i can see to these subforums is people posting their stuff in all 5, to get extra coverage. or someone with loads of stuff posting in all 5 rather than separating it into different threads.

its very different from trawling through 5 pages of for sale section

it is now 5 times trawling through 5 pages of for sale section!!!

i think a feedback bit would be good similar to ebay if u buy and sell leave feedback so others can see if the user isnt gonna rob u similar to the tread on here!!!

any one think the same?????

Yes exactly!

The fact that there is no pre-discussion with club members about changes that are going to happen to the forum pisses alot of people off

to me this forum is dying a death. i dunno what it is but a whole host of things just seem to be ruining the site for me. i remember the technical sections being very lively but they seem to be really slow now in recieving a response. a lot of technical bofins seem have done a runner from how i remember it....

i dont feel like the forum is for the members anymore, hence my request to cancel membership when it runs out. Sal this isnt a dig at you its just my overall feeling of late. to me it feels as though its policed and things change without prior notice, i dunno but it rarely caters for what i like to look at/read.

I'm devestated about pitstop forum and the company disappearing too...

Polo scene is dead, lets face it... See you all on the corsa owners forum :p

:lol: :lol:

Dan (and everyone else),

Your comments and have been taken on board (there have been some very good ones made), as I've said nothing has been dismissed out of hand. All I'm asking is that we give it a little longer to see how it goes.

I know what you mean about the pitstop forum, but times change and people/companies have to change with them as unfortunate as it may be.

Sal. x

It'd be nice if I got more constructive comments than telling me it's 'retarded'. Telling me that you don't like it isn't really grounds for it being changed back.

The section will be a lot easier to use and for people to find the parts that they are looking for. I appreciate that you won't be able to browse one forum section (clicking the next link numerous times) looking for bits that you fancy, but realistically it's not going to be any more clicks to browse through the seperate sections than it was previously, and there will be less threads that just say "Garage Clearance" etc and so will save people scanning through multiple pages of a thread to find items.

Sal. x

Interesting that you should bring up the garage clearance...gonna be fun for anyone who wants to have one of those now. Could end up making 5 threads instead of one.

I just don't get it. It seems like Admin for Admins' sake. The only thing that you gain is that it takes each item longer to reach page 2 of its respective forum, however from a sellers point of view I'd be pretty miffed that I've just lost about 50% of the passing trade because they don't want to browse through 5 seperate forums. Not going to be any impulse buying going on.

I'd be interested to know why this change was considered necessary? How many calls did you have from the 'bump' police? If you wanted to make it easier to find parts then DK's idea of a section for each mk of Polo is much better, most people only have one Polo, but I'm pretty sure they all have Wheels, Engines, Interiors etc....

I'm also interested to know how will you decide whether it's a success or not?

i liked the old for sale cause i would browse it and see if there was someting that tickled my fancy , i bought wheels that i had no intension of buying cause they were a bargain. i now cant be bothered to browse 5 different forums just to spot a bargain .

DKnight i think has a good idea with the Mk's but i think it should be like this : MK 1,2& 3 / MK 4 & 5 / MK 6& 7 / Wheels / ICE & other

also changes should be posted about in the discussion forums with a poll , as for this forum to remain health u need to identify the faults and then analysis the possible solutions then keeping us the user happy by asking our opinion .

People wont react happily to change without prior notice and input into the change , its just the way they are .

just my bit

Matt

Refrences: Chartered institute of marketing

Yes exactly!

The fact that there is no pre-discussion with club members about changes that are going to happen to the forum pisses alot of people off

to me this forum is dying a death. i dunno what it is but a whole host of things just seem to be ruining the site for me. i remember the technical sections being very lively but they seem to be really slow now in recieving a response. a lot of technical bofins seem have done a runner from how i remember it....

i dont feel like the forum is for the members anymore, hence my request to cancel membership when it runs out. Sal this isnt a dig at you its just my overall feeling of late. to me it feels as though its policed and things change without prior notice, i dunno but it rarely caters for what i like to look at/read.

I'm devestated about pitstop forum and the company disappearing too...

Well Spaniel I couldn't of said it better myself this is spot on and I am trying to cancel my membership but don't know how lol just think theres no communication anymore aswell

As you can see my avatar has been removed, I've asked and no one has replied, I am still clueless to why I have no avatar no admin/mod has pm'd me explaining and this is what will kill CP

and just like to say as said above it would be good if you have a poll for the members to decide on solving forum issues remember many heads is better than one so I bet some of the ideas would be good for example the parts section.

Not having a go at the admin as I think the parts section did need reorganizing as it was messy, but the way it is now I think buying and selling will go down the swannie due to the fact 1/5 less people will look through all the subforums.

I think you should have a poll for 15 days and let us vote on what we think would be best in the parts section end of the day were the ones using it that way it solves everyones problems

Edited by RedG40

24 hours is up btw.

well, i rathered the old layout, it was fun buying things you were not looking for :lol:

As mentioned above, its a bit of a nightmare if you're breaking cars now. I'm about to strip a g40 down, but can see its going to be a nightmare trying to advertise bits for sale.

I think it was fine as it was before(maybe have a bump limit as some people did it every 2 hours!) but possibly add a wheels/tyres for sale forum as an extra?

I normally look through the for sale section without wanting to buy anything, just see if anything catches my eye...

Now its a bit like, only looking on there if you know exactly what you want if you get me.

Preach.

to me this forum is dying a death. i dunno what it is but a whole host of things just seem to be ruining the site for me. i remember the technical sections being very lively but they seem to be really slow now in recieving a response. a lot of technical bofins seem have done a runner from how i remember it....

i dont feel like the forum is for the members anymore, hence my request to cancel membership when it runs out. Sal this isnt a dig at you its just my overall feeling of late. to me it feels as though its policed and things change without prior notice, i dunno but it rarely caters for what i like to look at/read.

I'm devestated about pitstop forum and the company disappearing too...

Spaniella..

I really do agree with you on this one mate.

(again.. not having a moan either.. I'm only still around because I can be of help in the tech section sometimes and I still really like polos.. so having a look through the build threads and gallery section is cool)

But...

I think ever since the ClubPolo stickers came about the forum has just gone more and more downhill. This isn't exactly the fault of the admin team, god knows you guys do a great job at running this enormous site, but more a reflection on a lot of the new members!

Back when it was porka, I agree that the tech section was far more helpful and lively. Now days the place seems to be overrun with 17year old chavs. OK.. that's an exaggeration, but you get the idea.

As for the for sale section... I think that if you're looking for something specific, it's great. If you're just having a browse.. it's not as great.

For instance.. I only go onto edition38 to see if there are any Rado wheels around... so it's two clicks. Perfect.

I do think there needs to be a space for "Massive clearouts and breaking" however

Just my 1.98878p

Josh.

Edited by Mariojoshi

Perhaps having the option to view the for sale section by mk, part or just no sections? this way it would appeal to everyone :D

I admit i loved looking through randomly, but usually only interested in a few things (that i can afford) so the sections dont mind me :)

cheers admins :D

also, if you click on view new posts it says 'polos' or 'non polos' or whatever - i can't tell if its chat, for sale, or technical when i use that function!!

Pete

I personally think its a good idea tbh.

Saves everything getting messed up.

If it is to stay how it is now we NEED a 'Breaking' section though.. or they are going to end up mixed in with the other stuff and it will be worse than ever.

I also think splitting into MK of polo would be good

Mk1 on its own maybe (possibly mix this in with MK3/4)

MK2/MK3 together as they may aswell be the same

Mk4/MK5 as they are pretty much the same

and so on.

Mods should also be sorting members packs out over things like tidying the for sale section :ninja:

It'd be nice if I got more constructive comments than telling me it's 'retarded'. Telling me that you don't like it isn't really grounds for it being changed back.

The section will be a lot easier to use and for people to find the parts that they are looking for. I appreciate that you won't be able to browse one forum section (clicking the next link numerous times) looking for bits that you fancy, but realistically it's not going to be any more clicks to browse through the seperate sections than it was previously, and there will be less threads that just say "Garage Clearance" etc and so will save people scanning through multiple pages of a thread to find items.

Sal. x

the search engine on here is w*nk. always has been, new for sale is a good idea, car-breaking & clear-out section is needed, dont listen to the tools.

JB

bring back Porka

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.