Skip to content

1991 Polo GT Coupe

Featured Replies

Hey,

Some of you probably remember my GT got crashed into from behind about a month ago, here's a link to the post if you want to have a look.... linky

Anyway, the other driver has admitted full liability and a week after the accident an insurance assessor came to have a look at the car. He deemed it a category 'B', total loss write off. It can't be repaired due to the shell being twisted, and has to be broken by an approved salvage company.

Last friday I got a letter from the insurance, and the assessor has given a 'pre crash value' of £350.

Now this is a bit annoying because they've obviously gone on the mileage and market value of the car, not based on the individual merits of the vehicle. I can understand this, but they say that if I want to dispute the valuation I need to get some evidence of what it would actually have been worth if I had sold it prior to the crash. This is where you guys come in :)

I'm also going to get some auto trader adverts (if I can find any GT's), and also maybe eBay adverts to back up my case.

So, here's a picture of the car:

And here's a list of its spec (please read carefully!)

General

1991 VW Polo GT Coupe

139,000 miles

FULL, extensive service history (so thick I need a box file to keep it in)

LA9V metallic black paintwork

Shell in very good condition, a few minor dents on the swage lines where doors have been opened into it.

No rust, apart from one tiny patch on the bottom of the drivers door

picture-2.jpg

IMG_1633.jpg

picture-1-1.jpg

Polly630107.jpg

Engine/Transmission

1272cc 3F engine

Oil changed every 3000 miles, run on 10W40 semi-synthetic Fuchs oil, genuine filters.

Recently serviced with new consumables (plugs, leads, rotor arm, cap etc) (137,000 miles)

Cam belt and water pump replaced at 120,000 miles

New radiator, thermotat, expansion tank and G12 coolant at 120,000 miles.

No oil leaks

No rattles or funny noises

Smooth power output.

NEW hall sender fitted December 2007

NEW throttle position sensor fitted January 2008

NEW ECU coolant temperature (blue) and temperature gauge (black) senders fitted June 2007

NEW Lambda sensor fitted November 2006

NEW AFM fitted November 2006

Timing and idle set-up using the correct method.

Standard GT gearbox, no whines, engages every gear nicely without crunching.

New outer CV joints and boots fitted October 2007

Suspension

Standard springs and shock absorbers

Front lower brace bar fitted

G-Laderseite front ARB blocks fitted

Steering tracking adjusted to factory settings once the ARB blocks were fitted

NEW genuine rear beam bushes

Brakes

VWII front calipers, rebuilt in July 2007 using new genuine seals

239mm vented front discs

Standard pads

Fully reconditioned rear brakes including:

New drums

New shoes

New stub axles

New wheel bearings

Reconditioned backplates

22.2mm master cylinder

Dot 5.1 fluid

see pictures below:

IMG_1234.jpg

IMG_1230.jpg

IMG_1227.jpg

Wheels/tyres

Excellent condition BBS RA 13x5.5 (G40) wheels, fully balanced

Yokohama A539 tyres, all with 2-3mm tread, in 185/60x13.

Spare GT steel wheel with a 175/60R13 Toyo CF1 fitted (brand new)

Interior

Completely standard interior - absolutely mint, no saggy bolsters, rips or tears. The interior was bought from a guy who kept it in his garage for 10 years after writing his GT off, paid £150 for it! Picture probably doesn't do it justice but never mind:

Polly430107.jpg

IMG_0850.jpg

Black parcel shelf

Black boot side carpets

Fire extinguisher mounted in the boot

Genuine VW Mk3 carpeted mats front and rear, bought in November 2006.

Mint condition leather gear gaitor

Leather gearknob

Normal GT steering wheel and clocks, reading the correct mileage.

Alpine CDA-9831R motorised flip front MP3 compatible head unit

JBL GTO 8.5cm front speakers in the original position

JBL GTO 6x4" rear speakers in the original position

Speaker wires fed correctly under the carpets through protected cabling to the rear.

Fully wired in ISO connector for the stereo.

Extra switch mounted in the dash to activate the radiator cooling fan. The switch is an OEM rear window demister, and has the correct wiring so it illuminates with the headlights and shows orange when the fan is switched on. (Incidentally the fan sender unit in the radiator does work, I just never like the coolant temperature getting to 102 degrees before it came on, so I like to help cool it down before it gets there).

Exterior

Late spec rear lights

Clear indicators

Clear side repeaters

Genuine OEM fog lights (bought new from VW in June 2007), correct VW wiring loom (still with label!), salvaged from a car in a scrapyard.

Full GT trim set in good condition.

Bee-sting amplified aerial (aerial hole in front wing blanked using a proper blank).

Armour door plates

Pressed steel number plates with the 'Old VW's never die.....' surrounds

I think thats about it!

Basically the car was pretty much exactly how I wanted it other than the suspension (I wanted to fit a H&R kit). I never doubted it would start, especially after replacing pretty much everything on the engine! It had a new fuel tank in about 2003, and was a great car to drive, no pulling or wandering on the road.

I personally think its worth more like £8-900, and I'd like to see what you guys think. If you could say what you think its worth and give your reasons why, that'd be great.

The reason I want serious replies only is because this entire thread is going to be printed off and sent to the insurance company, so I don't want it filled with spam.

Thanks in advance, hopefully it'll help! :D

Tom

  • Replies 25
  • Views 7.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

You would pay a grand to buy one like that today from within the scene. Even out the scene, people are starting to come to terms with the older VWs becoming classics in their own right without the whole aircooled thing waving it's head about.

The mileage isn't the lowest obviously, but there is no denying it's been a well looked after car.

So I would say your £800-£900 estimate is quite close.

A friend of mine has just sold a similar car with lower spec for £600.

I had an accident in my Golf years ago, and got valued way under the real value by the insurance assessor.

I got an independent evaluation of the pre-accident value, cost me £50, but worked.

Insurance companies go by market value and in the grand scale of things its just a high mileage 15 year old polo. A well maintained car with history is considered 'the norm' and anything less is normally a reason to reduce the price, opposed to adding value.

Fog lights, late spec rears etc are just lights to anybody except the users of this site.

Headunit etc is normally a seperate fixed value unless otherwise agreed with your insurer.

New parts etc again sad to say it doesn't add value.

Sorry to sound all doom and gloom but realistically most of us drive do actually drive 15 year old VWs just we are overly obsessed with looks/maintenance.

If you felt your car was worth more then you should of gone for an agreed valuation. Reject the offer and mention you looked to buy another Polo Gt of similar condition and spec and you feel their offer is not sufficient in putting you in a position to replace your car. Not off the forum, but eBay screen shots, autotrader ads etc for evidence.

well 900 to one of us, but minus the scene tax maybe 700 as its quite a minter?

would screen shots off the for sale section here not be accepted as evidence? what about piston heads as well maybe?

just get as much evidence of current prices as you can to help you, and as said above an independent evaluation might help.

£1000 in the scene quite easily if there was someone looking for a mint black GT.

£600 - 700 outside the scene - still a mint car

If they wont offer more then £350 then i would cancel the claim and break it.

£1000 in the scene quite easily if there was someone looking for a mint black GT.

£600 - 700 outside the scene - still a mint car

I would agree to this.

I would hope you could get this value but I would say agree to perhaps £500-600ish and ask for the car back and the brake the rest of it.

I think around £600 is about the right place.

At the end of the day a black GT in good condition is always going to hold at least that much of its value.

I agree, I would pay £600 for that.

I managed to get around the 1k mark for my GT, which would have been similar to yours, offered me 400quid to start with, I just hagged and haggled! try it!

If you want some real evidence I'm sure i could put something in writting about how much i paid for my GT, and I'm sure the seller stu who i still talk to alot would also help out if need be.

I think it would have def been worth £850-£900.

PM me if you want me to put something in writting.

Dan

GiorgioGT has got it in a nutshell.

A very sensible and pretty much perfect reply.

Your best bet is to haggle as much as poss.

How much did you insure it as being worth?

I dont really have any ideas, just that www.parkers.co.uk does a price guide which could prove handy...

Push for as much as possible, give them examples of cars for sale on here and elsewhere as a guide. Then aim to buy back the car as salvage.

Yoof's car got hit by one of his mates a few years back - minor damage, but it needed a new TCA and wing. The insurance assessor came round to write it off, but when he was greeted by the wallet full of service history, show & shine trophies etc. he was easily talked around.

Stuberts G40 was written of las December and the assessor came out and gave him a call to inform him of a £312 (or nearabouts) payout. To say he was furious on the phone would be an understatement. He told them to go and look at Pistonheads for a g40 and see how much they are going for.

He got a phonecall back later that day offering him a much healthier sum of £2000.

He still had problems as one of the channels int he claim wasnt happy with the valuation, but it stayed.

So i would say just be persistent with them, also as Tav says, what was the car valued at on the insurance policy?

Show them adverts from here and pistonheads, autotrader. At the end of the day they are probably just sitting on a chair thinking, its an old polo ' here give him £300' show them its not.

I got my mk2 Polo upto a valuation of £565 from £285 Gross, both including a £25 charge for the valuation.

Autotrader is your friend, try and use local examples, within 60 miles but the odd one 100mile out won't go a miss.

Work on the condition rather than mileage, don't work on mods unless you declared them.

You want to display a range of cars showing the the most exepensive models you can find, not necassarily a GT but if G40's come up, do not post titles with supercharged.

I went through the autotrader website and took screen shots, about 100 of them all showing prices between £500 and £1,000 for mine, I used small shots, about ten per page clearly showing the picture, cost and vehicle description.

I also sent in clippings from autotrader, clubpolo and UK polos for similar cars.

I put a spec list of my vehicle, i.e electric windows, FVWSH, lack of rust, overall condition ect ect. and asked that I be returned to a vehicle of equal condition. The insurance company said they couldn't offer me that but re-valued the car to £565

my GT got valued @ £265! I know it wasn't to everyones taste but it was very well looked after and never let me down. The assessor even commented on how clean the engine bay was (washed with the car every time). Haggle then like hell and don't let up. OH, i got to keep my car for free too which was nice of them!

Edited by vwmk3jon

def provide evidence of value and get independant inspection.

Also state you wish to keep the car as part of the payout.

least that way your get your £150 interior etc back to sell.

hassle but only way your get your money back and at least your feel like youve won the battle.

Edited by ashley555

A few years ago, my GT in similar condition but less mileage was valued at £600 when it was Cat C'd.

  • Author

Thanks for all the replies and advice everyone!

Tav - I told the insurance it was worth £1000 when I insured it, so thats something, but I don't think it makes a difference to them.

I'm currently getting lots of evidence together so I'll send of as much as possible!

Thanks for all the replies and advice everyone!

Tav - I told the insurance it was worth £1000 when I insured it

1000's about right i think

but it was very well looked after

by you maybe... :badgrin:

Edited by modest mouse

like some one else has said, a lot of the parts youve fitted were standard equipment for another polo from the same mark. so the insurance company probably isnt seeing half of your 'mods' as a mod. plus youve got to remember its a 15 year old polo. might be worth a grand on here but unless you can prove its worth that from somewhere that doesnt have an enthusiasts base they are only going to offer you book value. well, under book value from my previous experiances so theyve got a bit of room to come back and offer you more. just print out as many of the over priced mk3's you can from the classifieds on ebay and autotrader and it should help your cause (theres a genesis thatd be worth printing out on there now). you may not even have to go that far. just refuse the offer with the right words and wait for them to come back to you.

good luck with it dude. was a nice looking car before the incident. that money could make your new-un amazing. its got the right colour for startes :x:lol: (not jealous).

a possible tip...be nice in the begining, going in all guns blazing doesnt always help your cause. if i ever have to deal with some high an mighty big mouth they get the worse deal in return for their rudeness.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.