Skip to content

This months PVW

Featured Replies

I was reading this months PVW and in the tech talk section theres an email from someone wanting to drop a 2.0 16v motor into a 1990 polo coupe, and convert the hubs to mk3 golf items so they can run discs all round!

The response from The Phirm implied suprised me a little. Firstly, as has been covered so many times its hardly worth even replying to, there is near enough no point at all in dropping the heavy lump into the already crap polo chassis. Yes it will be quicker in a straight line, but the cornering really will be appalling. Surely it would have been wise to mention that?!

Secondly, i don't see any reason to use mk3 golf suspension in order to run discs? There isnt really a need for rear discs on a polo anyway, and if you do you can basically use everything off a mk2 golf with custom handbrake cables, which they didn't mention either.

Their response covered the direct answer of how the work needs to be done, but didn't deal with the fact of what the car will be like post-op, if you like. Maybe I'm just rambling pointlessly, i don't know, but it just seemed a strange response!

Discuss?

  • Replies 16
  • Views 2.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

These days people are going to greater extremes to fit engines into cars they shouldn't, all so they can be the first.

maybe they see £ signs to charge for a conversion?

i know i'm going to get shit for this but i don't see why you guys have such a problem with this,

yes ok it wiull make the car handle like shit and isn't worth doing for a trackl car but surely something like this should be embraced especially if someone is willing to spend the time and money in doing it, if you didn't take such a negative view over the conversion you would find more people would find more answers to problems that arise therefore creating more 'open doors' to the world of modifying polos and doing something different.

i'd like to see some one just try something then see what happens and if that doesan't work, try somethiung else!!

just my opinion like or you could just tell them the same things as everyone else gets told 'just G40 it'

maybe they see £ signs to charge for a conversion?

my thoughts exactly!

just my opinion like or you could just tell them the same things as everyone else gets told 'just G40 it'

if all you are bothered about is being "different" then fine, no problem with that. Personally I mess about with my car to make it go faster on a budget so I don't see any sense in spending £1000's fitting a tall block engine like that when a g40 engine will net you the same performance result (or better!) without messing up the weight distribution even more. If I were to look at sometihng like that then the engine would be going in the back of the car and the engine would be a 20vT or a VR6.

i know i'm going to get shit for this but i don't see why you guys have such a problem with this,

yes ok it wiull make the car handle like shit and isn't worth doing for a trackl car but surely something like this should be embraced especially if someone is willing to spend the time and money in doing it, if you didn't take such a negative view over the conversion you would find more people would find more answers to problems that arise therefore creating more 'open doors' to the world of modifying polos and doing something different.

i'd like to see some one just try something then see what happens and if that doesan't work, try somethiung else!!

just my opinion like or you could just tell them the same things as everyone else gets told 'just G40 it'

thats a fair point, but i think the point that skatty was trying to put across was that they didn't mention that they could spend all that money and be left with a shit car. you can make any engine fit any car with enough cash, so they should of gone into more detail about what the car would be like afterwards as after all thats the most important thing at the end of the day?

but what do i know i haven't read the artical :lol:

The Phirm are well known to be able to do ANYTHING if you pay them enough money. With answer like the ones above nobody forgets that.

They are business and answer questions to advertise their expertise.

They are more than happy to strap a rocket to your rollerskates if your paying

thats a fair point, but i think the point that skatty was trying to put across was that they didn't mention that they could spend all that money and be left with a shit car. you can make any engine fit any car with enough cash, so they should of gone into more detail about what the car would be like afterwards as after all thats the most important thing at the end of the day?

also a very good point, i just think that we should help people out who are willing to spend the time and money on somthing like this thats all. long term benifits are only going to help us all out in the long run

"if" i was to put a 2.0 16v in a mk3 Polo......i would'nt bother with a VW engine, i'd stick a Honda Type R motor in it :D

deffo, that green one mk1 golf with the intergra engine is mint (might be the civic lump) theres also a blue one with a full scooby running gear!

V-tec and VW in one now that would be one cool car!

ust a note when i thought about my conversion it took me nearly 6 months just thinking hmm would that work whats it going to do to the handling how much reliable power can i get how much work and custom parts am i gonna need. my project is a g40 mk1 golf as its light didnt take too much work to slot in and didnt cost the world. i mean i thought why not "slot" a R32 in with a couple of turbos for good measure but then you snap back into reality and realise how much its gonna cost and there must be an easier i mean look at 256mm brake upgrades why go hunting around for uber rare parts your never going to find when you can use cheap as chips vauxhall parts who said u had to keep it vag???/

sorry for the rant

V-tec and VW in one now that would be one cool car!

Thats called a Polo GTI 16.

Lupo and Polo 16v GTI have "v-tec"

You dont need to be a rocket scientist to figure that putting a heavy lump up front is not gonna do great things for the handling.

Is that not blantantly obvious to everyone?

V-tec and VW in one now that would be one cool car!

Thats called a Polo GTI 16.

Lupo and Polo 16v GTI have "v-tec"

Just not quite as wild as Hondas setup I take it? The 20vTs have variable cam timing as well IIRC, but again, not very wild. One setup for economy I believe.

You dont need to be a rocket scientist to figure that putting a heavy lump up front is not gonna do great things for the handling.

Is that not blantantly obvious to everyone?

I fail to see the point tbh. Mk1 Golf - lighter than a Mk3 Polo, but comes with a nice heavy big block engine in the 1.5 and the GTI and whatever other engines it had. So what difference will it be with a Mk3 Polo? Mk1 Golf GTIs don't exactly feel nose heavy to drive.

also what about 2L redtops in novas????

put a set of coilovers on a nova with a redtop and they handle just aswell as with say a 1.6GSi in and i know that because my mates got one.

theres always ways round things and its the fact that people are just more willing to give up trying that theres nothing out there, look on youtube as there is a Mk3 with a 1.8T engine in and thats a weapon and seems to handle pretty well

  • Author

The mk3 chassis is wank, otherwise it would have received just as much praise for its handling ability as the golf. The golf was well designed, and while i don't understand the dynamics of it, what i do know is that the golf was designed to take a large-block lump from the start, and to handle well with that up front. The polo was designed to take your great aunt and her friends to and from the supermarket and the bingo hall, and so was built with relatively little chassis strength.

Add a heavy 1.8 engine to a chassis that already struggles with a small block 1.3, and youre going to have problems!!

The problem with this topic is that everybodes right.... and i mean that literally i see where everyone is coming from.

End of the day its personal preference. Some people just like to know theyve got 2 litres up front in a small car. It feels sexy i should imagine lol. At the same time yeh its gonna be crap to corner. But if no-one can catch up on the straights does it need to corner perticualrly well lol.

I refer you to the case of the pikes peak ralley car on gran turismo 2. LOL> I couldnt corner that for shit i hit every barrier and yet id win every race.

I was young and i didnt like breaks...

I dont know what my point was. Back to bed!

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.