Skip to content

Bit of a dilemma

Featured Replies

Ok, lately I've been looking at G40's.

I own a mk3 Polo at the minute which will be up for sale in june. Its a Coupe Genesis with the NZ multipoint engine. Serviced twice by me using all VW parts. Its got recently refurbed BBS RA's on it with good TOYO tyres, rover half leather front seats (back is stripped but genesis seats will be included in the sale) Its lowered on a philJ 70mm kit and has a straight through phil J exhaust with back box. Mileage is 126,000 has had cambelt and headgasket done in the last 6 months and I have installed a GT cam, dewedged the throttle body and polished the casting marks from the manifold and inlet ports on the head. Its a nippy little so and so for what it is. Engine runs well and starts on point even sub zero temperatures. It has 10 months MOT and 5 months Tax on it. Bodywork is generally good with a few surface rust spots in the usual places. But (a downer for some people) is it is sprayed in matt black. The car originally was gloss black but paint was sketchy in places so I sprayed it matt (however it wasnt a 'pikey spray over the dirt' job, windows were removed and everything was done properly.

How much would be a reasonable price to sell my car for?

I also own a mk2 Golf GTI 8v which is my project car, I've repaired all rust and its having a respray in the next month or so. Its got a full black leather interior, coilovers and will be running mirror polished schmidt modernlines in the 16x9 flavour. I estimate its value when finished to be £1800 to £2000

Now, I'm weighing up either keeping the GTI or buying a G40 as I really love the 'street sleeper' aspect they have got going on and in all fairness I am getting bored of seeing mk2 Golfs everywhere.

How much would i realistically need to spend to get hold of a good condition G, i know charger rebuilds are a common issue so how much is the eaton conversion kit and an M45 to buy?

The other limiting factor is my age, I'm 18 and in june I will have a years NCB. Premature insurance quotes for a G40 are starting at £1600 (which is cheaper than I'm paying on my polo now with all modifications declared) however the GTI is looking to be around £2000. Does this sound right? Are there any young G40 owners out there that can offer any advice?

Cheers for any help/info.

  • Replies 8
  • Views 1.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Author

Also:

What sort of fuel economy do G40's get when driving nicely?

Whats the price of G-Lader rebuilds and where can they be done now PSD are out of action??

Standard charger rebuilds cost around £300 - £400 iirc.

How many threads have you seen saying "Finaly got the G back" etc, some people have many problems with them - Plenty describe them as money pits. Sure, there will be people that own them that will have had no major problems or they have the skills to sort alot of things out themselves so they don't seem to cost that much to maintain.

Tbh i think your getting a bit ahead of yourself as your not even 18 yet,

Have you even driven your Golf yet? If you havn't why not give that a go for a bit?

Circumstances can change, you might not get your NCB (I obviously hope you will!!)

Do you really want to spend that much money on insurance?

Just my thoughts, i am tired tho!

Keep it low and slow, I just walked home from work there (bartender) and nearly got run over by some arsehole showing off his Lancer Evo, he nearly clipped me flying up the road with a police car tailing him (hope he gets caught for something). You dont have a years NCB yet so dont get too far ahead of you, hell I'm not even on R plates yet, but that doesnt mean we wont make mistakes. There was a fella killed in my hometown there earlier this week testing the speed of his Fiesta, he was doing over 100 and the car left the road, cleared a fence and crashed in someones garden. The driveshaft broke off and flew through the house window. He had just 3 months on the R plates, and was buried on wednesday.

If you get a G40 can you honestly say you wont be testing the speed? if you get a powerful car with a lack of long term driving experience, you may end up in the same situation as that other fella....and I'm sure he didnt see his Monday night drive being the end of his life?

I agree with Kerrly on this one though, stick to the good old slow but low for a couple of years until you have lots of experience driving and lots of NCB's, cause who knows what tomorrow brings... a pregnant girlfriend, a change of job; you may even see yourself growing an interest in something else...

  • Author

I understand what you guys are saying. I'm not a speed freak driver, it may sound unbelieveable but I religiously stick to speed limits. But we all have silly moments now and again and I'm no exception.

I have thought about things going wrong and the only worrying part is the cost of replacement parts, I'm pretty handy with a spanner so labour isnt a problem. What are the most common faults with G40's? I'm guessing the usual Polo hall sender syndrome etc, but is there anything bigger (more expensive) bar the charger?

I might not get the NCB but I'm just trying to think in advance. The Golf will be ready for june either way but tbh its just not doing it for me like a G40 would. I would be looking for a standard G40 and keeping it that way. And I dont mind paying that much for insurance tbh. If its what you want then you have got to go after it right? And the way the prices of driving are going in this country I might not have the opportunity to own such a car for much longer :?

I think i'll do some more research into general running costs and maintanance. As i said it will be kept standard but it will have to be used daily, which is something to think about.

Any more info/experience from G40 owners is appreciated.

Cheers.

edit:- @Kerrly, i was 18 in january mate :lol:

Edited by XRP

Kerrly just misread it through this line "I'm 18 and in june I will have a years NCB". I read that and thought it meant you are 18 in June, just a trick of the eye. In all honesty I'd rather have the mk2 GTI over a G40, my mate has a mk2 GTI 1.8 16V running a Magnex exhaust, and the sound of it gives me goosebumps. GTI's are much beefier, allow more tuning potential, and wont be so weighed down when people are in the back seats aswell. Your call.

Either would be amazing, but do you really wanna be breaking an arm and a leg to pay insurance premiums before you have any NCB?! You're obviously gonna be getting ripped off by any insurance company cause they love us new drivers......

  • Author

Quotes I've got so far suggest the g40 would be cheaper to insure than the gti. And lower tax bracket so cheaper to tax as well. I'm used to hectic insurance mate. My first car was a 1100cc mk1 golf on coilies and 14x8 Borbet T's which was £1700 and my polo is £1840. With a years no claims a g40 works out cheaper than both of them :-D However, I get what your saying.

Fair play then XRP, I can just about afford to insure my mk3 1.0 with a few pints a week left over.... if you can afford it easily then go for it!

If it's gonna mean you cant afford to go out at all or afford a nice meal every now and then, then I'd forget it. Cant see a G being very economical though...

  • Author

Yeah i know what you mean bud.

Does anyone have any figures for G economy?

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.