Skip to content

is a 6n2 gti better than a 6n 16v

Featured Replies

hi I'm starting to get fed up of my vavlver so was thinking what to get and i like polos but i just want something different now and mybe faster as it feels really slow at the moment.

no i wont be doing anything for a while but i got holiday to zante next week but then I'm going start saving so end of the year I'm hoping its just i wanted some inf on the 6n2 gti as i save better if i know what I'm getting at the end of it (money burns holes in my pockets lol).

i rember when i first had mine i had the usal problems water pump,lambor sensor,heat sensor,temp sender,tb,ecu and little bits and bobs.

so wanted to know what are the common probs on a gti?

also the 16v is supost to be 10.2 0-60 but then picks up after that.

how does the gti perform is it loads quicker or just abit? opefully it handles better round bendys?

and last but not least does it get better mpg on long jurneys because my valver is worse on motorway than round town 3/4 of a tank just up to blackpool and back wich is 180miles and thats 80 all way back and not above 100 on way there.

gearbox hasnt been an issue with mine but herd it can be so take it there is the same chance the gti gearbox will be toss?

o one last thing I've herd my engine is very tunable (which i haven't botherd doing much of) but is the gti?

basicly my cars paintwork need sorting but i dnt want to spend £500 just on the paintowrk of a 1999 car i think its just wasting money to be hounest so looking at other cars and maybe moving up in the world hahahaha.

  • Replies 11
  • Views 1.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Have a look through this section theres around 3 - 4 questions regarding this!

On one hand if you want a moremodern car and one that's a bit nippier than your 6n 16v then tey are a good choice!

GTI gives pretty good fuel consumption on super unleaded for a 1.6 in a higher state of tune. I've managed 46 MPG. I've never had below 30 MPG when totally ragging it

Gearbox's on 16v's are a nightmare, mine just went yesterday :( However, I think generally the GTi box and pedal box are a nightmare too so defo a common fault. I'm not sure the GTi lump is as tunable as the valver as VW have got the most out of it to get it to 125bhp anyway. The vavlers more tunable for the fact the AFH came from a rallying background and I know some parts from the GTi lump also fit into the AFH. If your not gonna do much with the lump as you haven't with the valver, then your better off not thinking about that aspect and just go with the more powerful option!

Possibility of easy 150+ bhp for a cammed AFH on ITBs

Haven't really seen many tuned GTIs

I'm not sure the GTi lump is as tunable as the valver as VW have got the most out of it to get it to 125bhp anyway. The vavlers more tunable for the fact the AFH came from a rallying background and I know some parts from the GTi lump also fit into the AFH. If your not gonna do much with the lump as you haven't with the valver, then your better off not thinking about that aspect and just go with the more powerful option!

I think the main issue with tuning the GTi engine is the head design as it uses followers in the valve train. In the AFH the cam acts directly on the tappets. From what I gathered on Club Lupo the followers are prone breaking as RPM is increased beyond standard...and since more power from an N/A engine generally requires more RPM that's an issue....well an issue for those who are seeking out large power increases. So in that respect the AFH is the better engine to tune...I think it can also be made 1600cc by using the internals from the GTi, again that's from reading a thread on Club Lupo. There was mentions of outputs in excess of 200bhp...but then that's probably after sinking in ALOT of money.

As you've said you've not really be into tuning the engine none of the above should really concern you that much...if I were buying a car to leave practically standard I'd choose the GTi...if I were planing on doing some motorsport/trackdays/project car I think I'd have the Mk4.

...then again I couldn't stomach the potential gear box issues so I'd skip the GTi and go for something else....6 Speed Lupo GTi or an Ibiza Cupra.

GTI gives pretty good fuel consumption on super unleaded for a 1.6 in a higher state of tune. I've managed 46 MPG. I've never had below 30 MPG when totally ragging it

Higher state of tune than what? A dishwasher? 125bhp isn't really pushing any boundaries...Toyota were running 130bhp-140bhp though the 80's - 90's...Honda are rocking 185bhp and good MPG thanks to the wonder that is MADVTECy0!

Edited by Tav

  • Author

thanks for the replies everyone didnt mean to start abit of an arguement here.

so basicly the afh i have is (with enough money) easy to tune up

but if i do it will eat its way through gear boxes.

and its in need of a paint job mmmmmm

i think i just going save up after i get back off me hols, in may and think about it again later in the year.

Both engines will cost about the same to tune for 99% of people...only a few would be bothered by the head design.

Both cars have crap gearboxes so you won't avoid those issues.

Mk5 GTi's at really nice..especially with leather...feel like a grown up car.

  • Author
Both engines will cost about the same to tune for 99% of people...only a few would be bothered by the head design.

Both cars have crap gearboxes so you won't avoid those issues.

Mk5 GTi's at really nice..especially with leather...feel like a grown up car.

thats the bit i love the most bwt the valver is the inside no cheap looking plastic.

yeah basicly my polo is a t-reg.

needs full resray and alot more to get it looking how i want it and then i would really like it to be quicker.

as much as i love the car it just keeps coming back in my head "why spend that much on a t-reg polo"

like i said i going look into it when I've got the mney in the bank.

i have seen few other cars which i like the look of but would mean leaving club polo.

i have seen few other cars which i like the look of but would mean leaving club polo.

I wouldn't let that bother you... :lol:

  • Author
i have seen few other cars which i like the look of but would mean leaving club polo.

I wouldn't let that bother you... :lol:

haha like i said i just weighting up how much i want to keep the car and if its worth spending the money on.

ill probley end up moaning about it for a while then speing the money on it then moaning bwt spending the money thats what i normaly do.

.

GTI gives pretty good fuel consumption on super unleaded for a 1.6 in a higher state of tune. I've managed 46 MPG. I've never had below 30 MPG when totally ragging it

Higher state of tune than what? A dishwasher? 125bhp isn't really pushing any boundaries...Toyota were running 130bhp-140bhp though the 80's - 90's...Honda are rocking 185bhp and good MPG thanks to the wonder that is MADVTECy0!

I know it ain't pushing boundaries Tav, and excluding Jap cars most 1.6's are around the 100bhp mark. I think the fact you can get 140 bhp out of the AVY with just an exhaust and air filter, that's pretty good considering there is not turbo or VTEC yo! Both engines are tunable but it will cost a lot of money. You can get 200 bhp out of the AVY but I wouldn't like to know the cost

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.