Skip to content

Mk5 polo

Featured Replies

Is there a mk5 polo TDI? if so which choice would be better between that and a GTI

  • Replies 31
  • Views 2.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

TDI is 1.4 75bhp (I think)

GTI is 1.6 16v 125bhp.

The amount of power, delivery of power and fuel consumption are going to be totally different and I'm guessing the GTI will have a higher trim level.

GTI will come with Xenons, Aircon, Leather Steering Wheel, Rear Spoiler, Front Splitter, Headlight washers, Chrome Dials.

TDI will have much much better fuel consumption, if it's post 2001 model only 35 a year tax and much lower insurance.

Go for the diesel! :-) Probably worth it for the better fuel consumption with fuel prices at the moment.

some one on here has had there TDi remapped to 110 BHP and then more torque , so would prob be nearly as quick as a GTi anyways !!

some one on here has had there TDi remapped to 110 BHP and then more torque , so would prob be nearly as quick as a GTi anyways !!

That would be me :-D 110bhp and 185 lb/ft anyone?

some one on here has had there TDi remapped to 110 BHP and then more torque , so would prob be nearly as quick as a GTi anyways !!

That would be me :-D 110bhp and 185 lb/ft anyone?

I cant wait for my map anymore.... :-D :-D Who did your remap matey? Any other mods or just the map? Btw, the tdi's can meet gti spec if u buy a colour concept, you wont get zenons though or the funky climate control thingy... lol, you get better seats though 8-)

some one on here has had there TDi remapped to 110 BHP and then more torque , so would prob be nearly as quick as a GTi anyways !!

That would be me :-D 110bhp and 185 lb/ft anyone?

I cant wait for my map anymore.... :-D :-D Who did your remap matey? Any other mods or just the map? Btw, the tdi's can meet gti spec if u buy a colour concept, you wont get zenons though or the funky climate control thingy... lol, you get better seats though 8-)

Jody at Midland VW did mine, Custom Code map I think it is, put it on, took it out, came back and said its better but there's more, rung up and got alter map down :-D bloody shifts now!

Just the map at the minute buddy, though exhaust is on the horizon (soonish hopefully) and maybe a panel filter (though a friend is trying to flog me an FMIC off a 530d :lol:)

some one on here has had there TDi remapped to 110 BHP and then more torque , so would prob be nearly as quick as a GTi anyways !!

That would be me :-D 110bhp and 185 lb/ft anyone?

I cant wait for my map anymore.... :-D :-D Who did your remap matey? Any other mods or just the map? Btw, the tdi's can meet gti spec if u buy a colour concept, you wont get zenons though or the funky climate control thingy... lol, you get better seats though 8-)

Jody at Midland VW did mine, Custom Code map I think it is, put it on, took it out, came back and said its better but there's more, rung up and got alter map down :-D bloody shifts now!

Just the map at the minute buddy, though exhaust is on the horizon (soonish hopefully) and maybe a panel filter (though a friend is trying to flog me an FMIC off a 530d :lol:)

How much difference do u reckon it'll make? I've been thinking about front mounts too but not sure which or what one would be compatible with the polo....? What kind of power increases can u expect from it? Oh, btw... lol how long do u want your gearbox to last?? lol

Edited by big_k

with current fuel prices i would have to say TDI, ( not just because i own one)

mines running on 110 bhp, torque touching 200. all just from a custom re-map and a pipercross induction kit.

with the extra torque i really do believe that i can pull away from a gti after 60mph, so your not just buying it for the economy.

i pay £35 road tax, got 400 miles on my last tank ( but become heavy footed since remap). can get 500 when driven sensibly(76.3mpg motorway driving).

insurance group 6 ( gti's r group 12).

the problem is your gonna av a hard time findin 1, not many people sell n when they do there not cheap. £3000-4000

I've seen loads of gti's go for £2500, gti's do look much better n come with loads of extras.

but with a few subtle mods u could get a tdi looking just a good.

post-14725-1211045062.jpg

Love it Ali.... 8-)

If i'd of had the money i'd have bought a tdi. having owned a seat ibiza pd130 which was also tuned to 170bhp and 321ft lbh toruqe, i can definately say i'd have it revo'd. 5 minutes in a garage, optional switch to move it from stock to performance and back to stock.....

even if you only get 100bhp from a re-map, iths the torque that you'll notice, like that big hill that you always had to drop down 2 gears to get up, you can now drive up it in ease in 5th gear LOL

tdi all the way fella :-)

How much does a remap for a TDI cost? and do they have the same crappy gearbox as the GTI?

If its revo you go for its around £500, and the switch i mentioned is about £150.

there is other methods, possibly cheaper but i cant say what they're like or costs sorry

All this talk makes me wish I had a TDI. :-)

The only thing that annoys me about the GTI is the lack of low down torque where I wish I had a TDI

If u go through edition38 and contact motech they'll do the map for 250 8-)... i think its generic though, not custom!

The only thing that annoys me about the GTI is the lack of low down torque where I wish I had a TDI

hell yea, they love high revs - thats where any go is anyway!!!

The only thing that annoys me about the GTI is the lack of low down torque where I wish I had a TDI

hell yea, they love high revs - thats where any go is anyway!!!

Can't complain past 3000rpm, then the noise past 5000rpm :-D

How much does a remap for a TDI cost? and do they have the same crappy gearbox as the GTI?

i had mine done for £180 by sp-tuning and he come to my house to do it, so i didnt have to go on any mission, but i got a discount as my brother had his 1.9tdi done as well.

i had it done last year so prices might av increased since.

I own a Gti polo and my younger brother owns a Tdi one.

His fuel consumption is so much better than mine. Full tank gets him around 450miles...and thats normal (not conservative) driving. I get 280miles from a tank.

Gti tax is 200 a year as appose to Tdi (35)

The Gti's are have more of the "nice stuff" however the Tdi is the sensible choice.

How big is his fuel tank though? How much does it cost him to fill the tank and how does that work against the cost of his 450 miles?

As far as i know they're the same.

My tdi costs about 40 quid odd to fill... get about 450 miles from a tank and thats with a few good rapings. If driving economically 550+ is easy, I've never got past 600 because as soon as i know I've got 400miles out of the tank i burn the rest lol :lol:

Edited by big_k

My polo costs around 45 max to fill...using V power shell.

Must mean the tanks are the same size

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.