Skip to content

tough decision

Featured Replies

if i can get the polo sold very soon i dont know what to do as far as my next car is concerned, because i want something bigger (i carry a load of stuff for uni u see, struggled to get my last project in the car with the seats folded) and cheaper, and iv narrowed it down to two cars atm a 2001 51 plate Honda Accord Sport 1.8 VTEC and a 99 T Audi A4 1.9TDI SE 110.

basically i dont know which to go for because they both have their pros and cons

the accord is newer, has only 48500 miles on, looks mint, is cheaper to buy and insure, but fuel economy wont be that good especially for me being a student.

and the a4 i really like as well, its tdi which i could get remapped, its a higher spec than the honda, obviously better fuel economy, but it costs more to buy and insure and has done over 100k

which would you choose?

theres no point in me dwelling on this too much because i cant seem to shift the gti lol but even so

Edited by michaelg1001

  • Replies 9
  • Views 1.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

the turbo diesel audi. perfection on four wheels, just like the passat 1.9 tdi's. jap cars are great but you cant beat german build quality. PLUS the audi will hold its value for years, better than any honda, thats my opinion anyway. both of them sound great

Go for the Audi will serve you better with increased quality compared to the Honda.
  • Author

well originally it was the audi i was going for but this accord just came out of the blue. i cant imagine il keep it more than a year maybe but it will probably all come down to cost, cos the accord is cheaper to buy, cheaper to insure and with price of diesel compared to petrol it cant cost much more to run. and vtecs dont generally break lol. put it this way, there would be about £800 difference between buyin and insuring each of them, and theres a lot of petrol for 800 quid

Edited by michaelg1001

well its all down to what you would prefer mate, both are exceptional machines, and very nice, there are two audis like that down my street and a red X reg accord vtec, they are very nice, its what you can afford at the end of the day and which you would rather see yourself driving?

well originally it was the audi i was going for but this accord just came out of the blue. i cant imagine il keep it more than a year maybe but it will probably all come down to cost, cos the accord is cheaper to buy, cheaper to insure and with price of diesel compared to petrol it cant cost much more to run. and vtecs dont generally break lol. put it this way, there would be about £800 difference between buyin and insuring each of them, and theres a lot of petrol for 800 quid

If it's purely economic on your decision, then it has to be the cheapest, which is the Accord.

Are these just cars you've found by searching Auto Trader or something? It's just that I'm sure you could get other cars which would do the job too at a similar price to the Accord.

Is it like this?

HondaAccordI.jpg

Edited by PSWPolo

Seeing as your used to driving a quick petrol motor - you'll be better off with the accord, yeah diesels are great and i'm all for diesel but the 110bhp version in that Audi A4 isnt anything to shout about.

A custom-code remap would see a really big gain and you can have it mapped to drive more like a petrol, but like you said - the inital higher purchase price, insurance and 10p a litre extra for diesel makes the accord look more suitable. Oh, and proper diesel remaps are £300++

  • Author

i dont know! if i can get the polo sold might go for the accord just cos its so cheap and money is not something i have a lot of at th moment hence why the polo has to go

  • Author

http://atsearch.autotrader.co.uk/www/cars_...200820310188216

thats the accord. i work there btw so id be gettin it a lot cheaper than that :-D, hence why I'm considering it

the a4 iv been offered belongs to one of the mechanics

Edited by michaelg1001

http://atsearch.autotrader.co.uk/www/cars_...200820310188216

thats the accord. i work there btw so id be gettin it a lot cheaper than that :-D, hence why I'm considering it

the a4 iv been offered belongs to one of the mechanics

Thats nice mate I like that, cant go wrong with Jap cars... I mean I know VW's are very reliable, but the Honda's/Toyota's are even more so.

Quite heavy cars tho mind, saying that though anything with a diesel engine is pretty hefty! :p

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.