Skip to content

Offered a mk4 16v 5dr - should I sell my GTD or my G40?

Featured Replies

Hey - i've been thinking about getting a new project car for a while.

My G40 hardly get used - my GTD is getting used so much that its starting to rust quite badly!

I've been give a quote of £1000 to fix my GTD's rot. Which is exactly what cash I have in my savings account!

But just recently i've notice a black P reg Mk4 16v 5dr sat at the side of the road on the way to work. I hadnt seen it in 4-6 weeks so I thought nothing of it until I saw someone parking it up this evening. So I stopped and went back and cheekily asked if it was up for sale. He said that it was as it was his wifes car and she had just mentioned today that she wanted something newer! I said I hadnt seen it in a while. And he told me why! It snapped its timing belt and its just had a newly rebuilt head and a bottom end rebuild at a cost of £760 in parts alone! Its got 71,000 on the clock and its in pretty good condition, a few scabs and a few scratches, but nothing major! Its also got 12 months MOT & Tax. Alloys are in good condition and the whole front end has just been polybushed and an OMP lower strut brace fitted. Its only done 400 miles since its rebuild!!! He said he's after about £1300 for the 16v - its also got A/c and all the winter pack too!

But which one should I sell? The GTD is pretty rare especially in this colour - and I love my G40 I promised never to sell it - but its hardly getting used!

07052008016.jpg

13052008027.jpg

Let me know what you think!

  • Replies 15
  • Views 1.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

If I were in your shoes mate I'd keep the GTD and give in the G40!

New car... new problems...

In my opinion you've spent too much on the GTD to let it slip, plus IIRC that £1k includes a respray as well? So not exactly a waste of money.

Your G40 might not be the most reliable one about but it's all about the character, no? :lol:

I say no, and give me the phone number for the valver :thumbsup:

love the gtd and would be in the que to take it off you but also love your 40 so a say stick with what you have, the valver is nowt sensational and i'm really going off mk4 just now espically generic 16v bumpered one(yes i know the come as standard) so i say keep what you have.

Edited by stupotboy

i'd have the g40 off you right now haha

so theres you answer...time to move on 8-)

Edited by neil_dubgt

I say flip a coin :nod: both have reasons for keeping and getting rid, if you flip a coin then its all about chance, and not youre actual decision. That way you shouldnt regret selling which ever one the coin chooses :thumbsup:

better the devil you know than the one you dont,

in aother words keep what you've got need screw the valver

Valvers are good cars, it should be more reliable than the G40 and maybe a tiny bit more than the GTD but they lack character. Its nothing overly special to drive and they arent all that fast really. I'd personally say keep the G40 and GTD.

Get the engine re-built on the G40 and use it as a daily for part of the year.

I'd keep both. I'd rather have a GTD and/or a G40 than a 16v Mk4 anyday. As you said Andy, the GTD is quite rare and its a great car. No explanation needed for the G ;)

keep the G youl regret selling it

Are you mad? I'd keep what you already have. The GTD is rare so theres little if any chance of getting another should you regret the sale and the G is fast becoming rarer with alot being broken.

Classics ftw!

  • Author

Bought the 16v! Get it in a few weeks - need to sell some bits and pieces. And i've decided to sell on the GTD!!!

You strange man...

:lol:

Thought of a figure for the GTD?

  • Author

I have a figure in mind for it - it needs about £200 worth of welding and painting to sort out the holes in the boot floor! Spoke to Steve at C & R Enterprises and he says J reg mk2s are notorious for it - but they are easy enough to sort!

I've got loads of spare with it. I'd let it go for £700 - its MOT'd until october and it will have 6 months tax from now. It wont come on the Tresers - or the G60 steels - I may have to try and source another set of wheels to sell it on!

I'm pretty sure that Stupot has always had first dibs on it for ages! I'll see what happens with him first! :)

Yeah I think stu pretty much needs it! :lol:

I've got a couple of sets of wheels lying around if you don't get anything, let me know, I could bring a set of early 16v bottle tops down to the meet if you are needing. Reasonable tyres. Not wanting a lot for them at all seeing as they cost me £20 and I've had 6000 miles out of them :lol:

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.