Skip to content

Mk4 8v vs Mk4 16v

Featured Replies

I've got me a Mk4 8v, its done 51K miles, and I'm thinking of getting a 16v mk4. Its done 80-odd, got a few questions. I'm planning on doing this to my polo over the summer:

Bike carbs (£300 from a guy on here)

BMC CDA (I think they're around £150)

Coilies or complete exhaust system from PhilJ. (£200 for coilies, £300 for exhaust)

Now should I go ahead and get that 16v, or keep my Mk4? I'm not sure how much more my insurance would ask for a 16v, haven't checked with them atm. (I'm with Kwik Fit, underwritten by Zurich) Are stock 16v noticably faster than 8vs?

I'm kinda stuck at the moment, I really like my Polo but I cant really do an engine conversion. (I literally got my haynes three hours ago) So my only real option is a trade. Bit of a dilemma :disgust:

  • Replies 21
  • Views 2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Get a 16v and do what you said you were gonna do with the 8v. 8-)

16vs are MUCH faster than an 8v. 16vs arent fast mind, just 'quick'.

Edited by Tom66

  • Author

Hmmm.. but I really like the Polo lol.. I'll have another think over about this, any more opinions? :)

16v is a polo? they all are the same car just the 16v is alot quicker and has the sexy 16v bumpers and interior

i would sell the 8v for a 16v and mod that on visual rather than performace

  • Author

For starters, I'm not really going for an aesthetic look. The guy's taken the rear wiper off, which I'm gonna re-attach. And I also wanna screw the back number plate back on, he's taken it off for some reason lol. Most of the 'aesthetic' work would be done in the interior, but thats after my engine stuff :)

The 16v isnt a 5dr either.. and someone still hasnt really answered my question lol.

Edited by Trunkz

You get 16v's in 5 door guise!

But I'd personally have a 16v Mk4 over an 8v all day long! (not bias cuz i got one or anything :lol:)

They are alot nippier than the 8v and the sound is just amazing! And with all the nice extras as standard 16v bumpers, seats etc then they are just a really nice car to drive.

They are however group 10 insurance whereas a 1.4 8v is like group 5 or something so you will be looking at a heafty whack more for insurance but I'd personally say its well worth it!

  • Author

I'll have a check with my insurance company, if they're alright with it.. then I'll go on ahead. Thanks for the input guys :)

Note - I just wasted a perfectly good haynes manual. 3hrs old dammit!

do the bike carbs inclue a custom inlet manifold for 300?

after owning both an 8v and 16v the increase in power is very noticeable between the 2!

The Haynes manual should be good for the 16V trim wise.

Are you really going to be fiddling around with the engine that much?

The 16V is:

Faster

Better looking

More comfortable

Sportier

With bike carbs on the 8V the 16V will still be quicker but it will have better fuel economy.

The money saved on the 8V insurance will disappear on those modifications.

  • Author

Hmmmm.. Aight then, well I'll phone up the insurance lot, see what they're saying. I still want bike carbs lol, they look cool =D

Edited by Trunkz

dunno why u need all them horses( :lol: ) under the bonnet! the speed limit is still 70 and the 8v gets there no probs :p

  • Author
dunno why u need all them horses( :lol: ) under the bonnet! the speed limit is still 70 and the 8v gets there no probs :p

Oh I could swear we have nationwide autobahns.. :unibrow:

do the bike carbs inclue a custom inlet manifold for 300?

after owning both an 8v and 16v the increase in power is very noticeable between the 2!

Just realised this, but I think I'm gettin the 16v off yer mate.. :o

Edited by Trunkz

  • Author

I just phoned up the insurance folk, and its gonna cost me £184 odd extra (inc. the £25 charge to changeover the car lol), bringing up my monthly direct debit to around £151 p/m.. Not tooooo bad me thinks.

Ill answer your question.

Get a valver you tart, they are sa-weeeeet.

And i fookin love mine.

Hope that helps dude. :-)

  • Author

Aight basically,

I've decided that everyone on clubpolo is wrong, and I'm right lol.. The 8v > 16v, in my ideal world anyway lol.. Jokes aside, I just felt that I'd rather do work on my own motor, than buy someone elses ;) Plus with this one, its physically impossible for anything else to go wrong, because.. there's nothing left in the car that hasnt been replaced, minus the seats.. I wonder if they'd just catch on fire or somethin? ;o Got some nice plans for summer..

P.S - Is there a cheap place to get BK alloys? I looked at the bk site, and it'd cost me £450 for em =/

dunno why u need all them horses( :lol: ) under the bonnet! the speed limit is still 70 and the 8v gets there no probs :p

But the 16v gets you to 70 far quicker :-p

I'm loving my valver, great daily driver 8-)

OP

Edited by OP1

i reckon a 1.6 8v on bike carbs will a full exhaust should see a valver off??

tan loads of fuel tho

  • Author

I'm not really gonna go heads-in into the performance aspect just yet, otherwise I would have got a 16v. Going to sort out the exterior first, then basic performance parts (BMC CDA + De-cat kit should do it), then move onto interior, go back to exterior details, then start spending heavy bucks on performance. Thats my plan anyway :)

Either way.. Ima be working like a bitch over the summer xD

spending heavy bucks on a 1.4 8v will get you nowhere tbh...unless you look into turbo or supercharging it...hmm

i reckon a 1.6 8v on bike carbs will a full exhaust should see a valver off??

tan loads of fuel tho

I'd put my money on the valver but regardless of that the 16V will be cheaper to run, maintain and insure.

Even supercharging an 8V 6N Polo engine is expensive for little gains. AWTracksport's supercharged 6N is living proof of this, pathetically slow with a big cost.

I'll have a check with my insurance company, if they're alright with it.. then I'll go on ahead. Thanks for the input guys :)

Note - I just wasted a perfectly good haynes manual. 3hrs old dammit!

Ill take your haynes manuel off u, 5er posted?

  • Author

I could always just get a 16v engine, and stick it in at a later date. No one is selling 16v (5dr blacks) on a decent milleage anyway, so there isnt much point :)

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.