Skip to content

Best Economy MK3 SPI 5-Speed

Featured Replies

Just wondering thats all.

  • Replies 22
  • Views 2.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Id say 1272cc as it don't need to be ragged as much to keep up with traffic, I've always thought the 1.0's are a false economy!

Agreed. As long as you can resist the temptation to floor it,the extra torque (and gearing) of the 222cc bigger capacity can pay for itself in reduced revs/throttle at traffic speeds. I believe that use of the 1.4 version (all three engines have the same bore) with an even longer ratio gearbox and even lower revs/throttle can match the previous,too. Its simple maths,really.

For motorway cruising though,you want the 1.0 with a long ratio box - hold lowest revs,with low capacity.

i get just under 45mpg in my mk3 1L 4speed square, and it gets ragged everywhere - it would have an easier life if it was a 1.3....

I would say a 1.3 also mate . my old 1.0l used to drink ..

My 1.05 drinks very nicely thankyou very mcuh.

I suffer a bit from 'digital right foot' syndrome.

i used to see 45mpg out of my mk2 when i didnt have a brick like right foot ;)

my other half uses the 1.3 AAV every day to work about 30 miles each way on country roads and recons it does around 53mpg pushed it quite far towards 500 miles per tank. I couldn't recommend one highly enough its a great little car once you sort out the suspension and skinny tyres :lol: got more poke than my mk2 and much better on mpg cruises along very nicely :-)

edited to say i still wouldn't swap my mk2 for one :lol:

had this discussion with some wanting to buy a polo other day.

I've had all 4 excluding the g40

1 litre 4sp - absolutely shite. to do any sort of reasonable speed it needs ragging. fine if uyour a granny. i am not.

1.3 spi - perfect for nipping about town

1.3 NZ - slightly better for nipping around town

1.3 gt -perfect, drive it nice round town 40mpg easily, rag the life out of it, 35mpg

1 litre is a massive false economy, fact

1.3s with the 5 speed box (a small few did have a 4 speed box) are generally more economical overall. The figures quoted by VW themselves showed this to be the case, although the 1.05 was always more economical on an urban cycle. Mind you, the differences quoted by VW varied as time when on, but there was a 5-8mpg difference between 1.3 5speed, and 1.05 4-speed at 75mph IIRC.

Real world economy, as recorded by the likes of the AA and Autocar in road tests backed up the above, but overall, there wasn't a lot in it. The 1.05 4 speed, 1.3 5 speed and 1.05 5 speed did 44, 45, 46 mpg overall respectively but the biggest difference was at 75, where they did 40, 45 and 47 (Figures from the AA).

Thus, 1.3s are generally the best blend of performance and economy. As said above, if you drive 1.05s very slowly and gently, they'll achieve excellent economy. I always average 47mpg, but have had 57mpg on a handful of occasions now.

Edited by Daniel R

I get 44mpg (tested over a long time) out of my 1.05 4 speed (bog standard). I do 20 miles of M-way and 15 miles of A-road with roundabouts each way to work.

M-way tend to 75mph and on the a-road it depends on whose in front. I don't hang about but I don't rag it everywhere either.

Coming out of roundabouts I change up into 4th at around 45 mph.

HTH

ol_smokey

Coming out of roundabouts I change up into 4th at around 45 mph.

Does it even pull that? No offense :lol:

I bet most of the 1.0 drivers are just looking for 3rd at 45 haha!

Coming out of roundabouts I change up into 4th at around 45 mph.

Does it even pull that? No offense :lol:

I bet most of the 1.0 drivers are just looking for 3rd at 45 haha!

don't change into 4th till 60...

Coming out of roundabouts I change up into 4th at around 45 mph.

Does it even pull that? No offense :lol:

I bet most of the 1.0 drivers are just looking for 3rd at 45 haha!

don't change into 4th till 60...

Who needs a 4th gear?

3rd goes up to 85mph :D

I really do think I was about 3 rpm off the limiter every time I changed gear in my 1.0 lol and still managed 30-35 mpg

I was about the same (once i discovered there was a limiter) and due to the long runs i did i was getting a good 40mpg regularly

Assuming no long stretches at motorway speed, I found a GT to be quite a bit better on fuel than any other polo I've ever driven.

I haven't got much experience of SPI's (because I don't really like mk3's). But on mk2's my 1.05 carb'd square was about the same on fuel as my 1.3 carb'd coupe (which runs a 1.05 5 speed box), and I know by far and away which I'd rather drive.

I'm usually in fifth by 40mph. It'll pull that reasonably comfortably,with the lightest touch. I can cruise in a 30 zone in fifth,but its not practical on anything other than a clear and ramp-less street,as I'm only at like 1,300rpm.

My GT is much more ecnomical then my 1.3 spi ever was, i can get abit more then my old engine in my GT and it will do 35mpg at high revs, whereas the spi's drink fuel when you get to higher revs, and thats with the GT gearbox which is rediculasly short.

I have taken it to 55mph in 3rd but by christ I swear that it did not sound good. Now that I know there's a rev limiter I might see if it smoothes out after 60mph now though :unibrow:

  • Author

Cheers guys, reason I ask is that my 1.8 Rocco is a GUZZLER! Might sell soon and get another Polo as my daily :(

get a GT mate for economy and performance

i barely put any fuel in mine coz i got fuckall money and i hardly ever have to put any more fuel in :)

Edited by doug

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.