Skip to content

1.4 16v vs 1.6cl

Featured Replies

Was searching the forums for ages looking for an answer to this, but couldnt find anything.

Performance wise, whats the difference between the 1.4 16v and 1.6cl? I'm guessing the 1.4 has the edge probably quicker, but they have the same bhp and roughly same 0-60 times. Think they're same on insurance as well?

  • Replies 38
  • Views 3.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

1.4 16v is 100bhp

1.6 cl is 75bhp..

valvers are more what people want so i guess they're better.

8v ftw though lol

75bhp for a 1.6? Prob uses more fuel as well. Think i'll pass. Thought i read somewhere it was 100bhp.

Interested in a 16v, but finding that they are rare. wanting to spend up to about £1500 for a mid-high miler in good condition. As i said in one of my previous posts, difficult to find a 16v when on autotrader, 10million people have listed their 1,4 cl's as 16v

the 1.6 that is 100bhp is in the polo saloon the 6kv, it its a tall block compared to the 1.6 in the hatches

thats more than likely what you had read :)

1.6 8v have got more torque than the valvers.... but everything else is worse, I own one lol

I've owned both - both have about the same MPG - even when pushed along (32-38mpg) 1.6 8v is a lazy cruiser - the 16v is very "busy" at motorway sppeds, but on the A & B roads the 16v feels faster. But I timed a run from my Parents place to the local town and the time it took me on a std 16v was the same time almost exactly to a tweaked and stiffened 1.6!

Remember that the difference between the two goes beyond the power output of the engine. The 16v has a rear antiroll bar, they fitted lowered & stiffened suspension :lol: 10mm! :lol: ), the 16v has 256mm brakes at the front, as opposed to the 239mm ones on the rest of the range, stuff like that.

16vs handle and can accelarate

1.6s go straight on all the time and quite happily pull 5th from 30... but it's like driving a diesel, you try and make up the cars lack of performance by telling everyone it's "got loads of torque"

Just the way it is- sounds like the good old 8v vs 16v GTI debate :lol:

edit: this is my opinion and I am joking

Please don't get offended people who sadly own 1.6s

Edited by tobyk

I'm not really sure what the difference but some dealer told me not to get a 16v as everyone has so many problems with them?!?

Like? Gearboxes. 1.6s do gearboxes too. Honestly, I think gearboxes are their only problem. A few niggly other faults but they are applicable to the rest of the range.

the valver gets cheaper tax too no?

Yes!

well my gearbox has just been replace in my car. one of my mates had a 1.416v and he had electrical and engine problems all the time until he hit a manhole cover and twisted the whole car. stupid question has the 1.6cl got 8v or 16v?

8v

If your only gonna be doing lots of motorway mileage go for the 1.6 perhaps. Valvers annoy me on the motorway, but at least you dont have to down-shift when overtaking :lol:

yeah down shifting is annoyin!!! like the person above said depends if you are doing motorway or more country roads

If your only gonna be doing lots of motorway mileage go for the 1.6 perhaps. Valvers annoy me on the motorway, but at least you dont have to down-shift when overtaking :lol:

Yeah 16v's are a bit intrusive on the motorway, especially if it's loud, as you'll be sitting at about 4k RPM. Makes overtaking effortless though as it's around the peak torque area I think :-D

been thinking about this aswell. 1.6s are cheaper on insurance? valvers are group 10?

not too concerned on the insurance - just concerned that the mpg is going to be the same on the 1.6 and you get less power, which to me is lose- lose. The tall block from the saloon i presume acts the same as it has the extra weight. Dont think I've seen many polo saloons though.

I'm not really sure what the difference but some dealer told me not to get a 16v as everyone has so many problems with them?!?

A dealer would say that to you if he is trying to sell you an 8v Polo he has that he is trying to get rid of :lol:

8v

yeah he wasnt trying to sell me an 8v i was buying a gear box and my mums boyfriend mentioned i wanted and they said dont get one stay away from them

My mildly modified 1.6 8v (94bhp & 120LB/FT on the rolling road) and I minced 2 gearboxes within a year (my first within 2 weeks of taking delivery of the car) and my 2nd 10 month later. When it went the third time I put a MK5 TDi box in it with a few tweaks by my dad (he builds helicopter gearboxes and this was a piece of piss!) made it indestructable!

'

could someone in the know post 1.6 and valver acceleration top speed figures please??? :-D

About 12s to 60 and 105 mph ish

All road test figures vary

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.