Skip to content

mk4 or mk5?

Featured Replies

i will be gettin about £2500 soon and want a standard polo which i can modify :)

for the money i would probably be able to get a really nice mk4 or an average mk5 and was wondering what you guys would do in my position?

I'm swayin towards the mk5 because of the interior and extras that you get but i love the exterior look you can get from a mk4 :)

cheers

  • Replies 63
  • Views 6.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

i chose mk5 as its alot more modern inside and out

I'd go Mk4 and not spend all £2.5k, save the rest. Spend £1500 on a Mk4 valver if you can afford the insurance and save or spend the other grand on modifying it. Would be my choice.

I'd go Mk4 and not spend all £2.5k, save the rest. Spend £1500 on a Mk4 valver if you can afford the insurance and save or spend the other grand on modifying it. Would be my choice.

:-D Agreed, a mk5 really is a over rated mk4.... MK4 FTW! :D

Hmm. Mk5 is much nicer inside and out and won't rust, however you won't get an amazing spec one for £2500 so I'd go for a higher spec Mk4 if your budget is low

i paid a hefty £2500 for my valver! :shock::badgrin:

the mk4s iv seen are more rusted then the mk3s, you can get a nice valver for 1500

MK4s have a weird looking arse and the dash board in them is woeful. Mk5 has a much much nicer interior and generally look a lot more modern.

Imo the mk5 GTI is the best looking Polo as stock.

Imo the mk5 GTI is the best looking Polo as stock.

Amen to that, they're just so goddam sexy

i prefer the Mk4 :) buy a Mk4 then plough the rest of your money into making it look tip-top.

MK4 all the way mate. Have something different instead of a valver, go for a 1.6 8v thats what i got. Quicker to!

Imo the mk5 GTI is the best looking Polo as stock.

Amen to that, they're just so goddam sexy

They are very sexy but they come at a hefty price. i paid £4250 for mine which was a pretty good price for milage etc

you will prob get more for money with a mark4, just depends what you really want

go for a 1.6 8v thats what i got. Quicker to!

Err since when?

go for a 1.6 8v thats what i got. Quicker to!

Err since when?

1.6 8v = 75BHP

1.4 16v = 100BHP (alot are producing more as standard)

Valvers shit all over 1.6 8v Mk4's.......fact!!

Back on topic though, I'd go for a Mk4 anyday! As I've always said its the most modern Polo I'd have.

Edited by kwijibo_coupe

MK4 all the way mate. Have something different instead of a valver, go for a 1.6 8v thats what i got. Quicker to!

Oops!

  • Author

cheers 4 input everyone :)

has anybody ever owned both? if so which did they prefer?

go for a 1.6 8v thats what i got. Quicker to!

Err since when?

1.6 8v = 75BHP

1.4 16v = 100BHP (alot are producing more as standard)

Valvers shit all over 1.6 8v Mk4's.......fact!!

Back on topic though, I'd go for a Mk4 anyday! As I've always said its the most modern Polo I'd have.

where the fuck did you here that a 1.6 was faster than a valver?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!????!!!!!!!

mate just sssssshhhhhhhhhhhh seriously.

this is coming from a 1.6 owner btw

mine pisses on valvers, fact! Quicker midrange and acceleration

What have you done to yours then?

Mk5 all day long fella :-)

more Mk4 owners on here so these guys are going to be bias ;)

mine pisses on valvers, fact! Quicker midrange and acceleration

Interesting. Sub-10s to 60 and cruise past 120 will it?

Are you sure you haven't been playing with GLXs/SEs?

mine pisses on valvers, fact! Quicker midrange and acceleration

I'll easy take you to a drag strip and prove you wrong buddy!

My valver will kill your 1.6 8v all day long!

My Polo GTI will eat your valvers and 1.6 8vs all day ha ha :p

I wouldnt get all gung-ho on the poor fella. I remember seeing a mini cooper rape a beemer on the M4 once :) Gladly, it made more noise than a concorde on turbo ;)

My gti will also beat you are small valvers and cls :)

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.