Skip to content

yet more funky gearbox noises!

Featured Replies

got a mk5 gti, I'm sure it just eats gearboxes, seriously! mmmm tastey gearbox

driving home yesterday, put it into 3rd, i heard a lowish pitch wining noise, getting louder and more high pitched as i spead up, put it into 4th and it carried on, then it stoped as i put it in 5th!

I'm guessing either those gears are about to go bang or the hole thing is gonna go, not cool!

iv been trying to think of anything that could be breaking the gearboxes so much, like somthing wrong somwhere else with the engine that is causing this, maybe putting more stress on the gearbox or somthing, but I'm fresh out of thoughts.

argh!

  • Replies 19
  • Views 1.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

sounds pretty terminal to me fella!

worn or mal adjusted gear linkage can increase wear also a big factor is bigger wheels = more strain on the whole drivetrain - driveshafts and particularly the gearbox.

not sure how big your alloys are but they look large.

hard acceleration, premature downshifts and driving in the wrong gear also wear or stress the gearbox.

  • Author

yeah they are 16" wheels.

i think I'm going to get some 15" again anyway.

its been through soo many gearboxes!!

it went to the garage about a month ago, the guidence plate or somthing was fubar'd

then it was ok, now its poo again. i wish i had bought a valver! lol witht eh money it cost and the money i have spent getting it to work i could have had a really nice valver that goes like stink

thanks for the help btw! il get it checked when it goes in next week

my 4th gear pulsates when i take my foot off the gas but done about 2000 miles and still seems fine apart from the reverse wanting to grind all the time. Think my gearbox is on its way out or should be fine for now?

your gti looks nice mate. keep at it, dont lose interest lol.

feel sorry for you with all the gearbox trouble.

wont any other box fit?

  • Author

if its gone that far with the noises and stuff then it could go either way, pop any time or just keep going lol

My warranty doesn't start until September so I hope it goes bang then ha

  • Author
your gti looks nice mate. keep at it, dont lose interest lol.

feel sorry for you with all the gearbox trouble.

wont any other box fit?

I'm not sure, i remember there was a post up a few months back, a guy was saying that he knows a company that fits gearboxes from different cars in gti's or somthing, post was called.....gti owners, want a problem free gearbox or somthing like that, il have a look for it now

Nod, mine used to do that in my mk4 1.4 cl! Still does it now as the girlfriend now drives it, notheing to worry about!

Only problem i have with mine is that once the gearbox oil is warm it struggles to get into 1st and reverse without pushing it into gear pretty hard, which then results in grinding gears :thumbsdown: !

That's good to hear mate lol kind off put me at ease.

Another quick question, which gearbox oil do you lot use for your GTI's?

  • Author

no idea lol, i had it done at the garage n they didnt tell me

mine does this, my warrenty runs out in 3 months so if its guna go pop it better do then!

i'd be interested in seeing which polo boxes work, i'm aware that on the whole 90% will bolt on but mounts, ratio's, linkages and clutch fitments differ.

i worked as a gearbox mechanic/fitter 3 years ago but at the time there was no call for polo boxes. we used to fit pre 88 (geman) mk2 golf gti boxes on mark 3 golf gti's as they were far stronger!

Mine is whining away quietly ever since the beginning of March, it seems only a tiny bit louder and I'm having no problems changing gear. Maybe I'm being paranoid (I say that then it will probably go tomorrow!)

  • Author
Mine is whining away quietly ever since the beginning of March, it seems only a tiny bit louder and I'm having no problems changing gear. Maybe I'm being paranoid (I say that then it will probably go tomorrow!)

yeah, changing gear is ok, but it just makes noises....that dont sound good, kind of like somthing is going wrong inside the engine somwhere.

we shall see i guess

mate i feel your pain, my car gets thru gearboxes like no other, i just collected the car from the garage yesterday after having the 4th gearbox fitted! the mechanic completely blamed the ride height....dont know whether thats bullshit or what but thats what he said, he said running the car that low puts constant stress on the gearbox

There has to be 'give' somewhere,else it all hammers straight into the box. The clutch springs only give a little. Softer suspension gives cushion,both in geometry movement and bush compression,as does less grippy tyres,even a little sidewall. Remove all these cushioning factors,and the box gets full force. I used to break them regularly,when i had a very hi-torque engine at slow twist - leverage.

Sounds like Chris's whine is the diff - if its with the revs in third,and then continues to rise in progress in fourth. And i always say this - if you keep taking the same fault back to the same person to be repaired,they're clearly not proving to be the best person for the job. Its certainly not entirely their fault in this case,but still,try elsewhere.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.