Skip to content

Volkswagons are reliable

Featured Replies

this is the well known comment about VWs!! :-)

i have owned only 2 cars; a fiat punto 51 reg and a polo 51 reg, similar mileage. in my experience the polo lives up to the VW reputation and has had no problems with any main parts in about 18 months whereas the punto had two or three in only a year. its hard to compare fairly though because the fiat had been driven quite a bit harder by the previous owners i think. i also cant compare parts in more detail because i only started car "tinkering" since i had the polo.

i was hoping to line up a few comments from you guys with more experience of owning and working on different cars, what is your experience with VW with regard to reliability and build quality (incl. ease of taking apart and putting back together) compared with other manufacturers?

Edited by 6n2

  • Replies 24
  • Views 2.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

VW Polo 1996 1.4L 8v - flawless in 2 years!

2001 Citroen Saxo 1.6 8v VTR (CHAV CITY, I IKNOW) - both driveshafts after 1 month, full exhaust, no other probs in 10 months.

2000 Seat Cordoba 1.6 8v .cool/S - Electrics very dodgy sold after 2 months, couldnt handle the electrical probs

2002 Renault Clio 1.5 8v DCi - Flawless in 6 months of ownership

2000 Ford Focus 1.8 16v Zetec Millenium Edition - Clutch(common fault), tyres and exhaust sold after 4 months

1997 VW Polo 1.4 16v - Clutch, Gearbox, Head Gasket, Rocker Gasket, CV Boot, Exhaust and Brake Pads & Discs after 1 month.

I would say it doesnt matter what you buy because it dependsd how it has been cared for in the past and the mileage you buy it at as sometimes more miles is better as a Polo 6n 16v might have already had a new gearbox if it has higher mileage!

Id say VW's do live to there reputation for being relliable as I've had no problems with mine so far (touch wood) :p , but i have owned 2 saxos before hand VTR and a 1.1 and i never had a single problem with them either, and even now a few of my mates drive french cars and have never had a problem with them :)

Martin.

as far as mk4's go i think they are one of them cars, where you really do have to make sure you find a good one.

whereas, i had a corsa b that i bought for £200, with 107000 on the clock, no service history.

but there was nothing wrong with it at all, no rust at all, engine ran sweet as a nut, even with clogged breather pipes etc.

i bounced it off the limiter many a time, put shitty tacky induction kits on it, not to mention another 40'000 miles. it flew through 3 mot's, i had it for 2 years driving.

for a 16 year old car, it was superb, only thing i ever changed was the wheel bearings, and the discs. and the car hadnt been looked after from its previous owners at all.

as for my polo, its got fvwsh and has had 2 owners from new, it cuts out every now and then (fair enough i know its only a small problem), and is in the bodyshop having rust cut out, the corsa to this day, hasnt got a spot of rust on it.

this is probably sounding like a load of bollocks, but I'm tired, and cant be arsed to go through it.

corsas ftw...

valvers if your cool.

corsa is most reliable car so far, its all down to previous owners if your on about used cars

yea as much as i hate to admit it my bitch of an ex was right, its all about luck.

cudnt agree more, dnt be gay and buy a corsa be cool and buy a v-dub

I have owned:

1981 Mk1 Golf - Flawless, paid £160 and it passed its MOT with not even an advisery, cheapest running cost by far!

1986 Rocco GT - Even mucking around with the Carb never got it going as great as it could for long- when it did run it was great!

1998 Polo 1.0L - Very low mileage, had to replace the CAT and the rest of the exhaust system, bad alternator, rest of the time it was good.

Current motor 1991 Polo GT - Owned it for 2 years and have been replacing different things every so often - soon everything will be new practicaly.

Never touched anything non VW - that includes girls :lol:

2001 Fiesta - was totally reliable, used it with my mum before getting my GTI for about 3 years. Only problem was rust even when it was 3 years old

Mk3 Polo - 8 months of problem free motoring apart from when the head gasket went but was completely my fault

Mk2 Golf - 6 months of carb trouble but nothing else

To be fair, you cant count brake pads, disks, tyres etc as faults on a 10 year old car, they're consumables that will need replacing over time on any car.

mk3 GT, apart from the hall sender going on it and the battery wire coming off the alternator it never had any serious problems.

mk2 golf 1.3, it had just had the head gasket done before i got it and while i had it it had a new gear box, new engine and a top end rebuild and it still got scrapped with engine failure :(

mk3 golf 1.4, in the 3-4 months i had it it never missed a beat, it had the shit raged out of it on a daily basis and i never did any maintenance.

mk2 golf 16v, apart from not ticking over for the first min or so when its cold its been fine so far.

as some one mentioned above, i think a lot of it comes down to luck, the only car i had any major problems with was the 1.3 golf which was a total nightmare.

So many things have gone wrong with my mk4 1.4 8v- almost to the point of chucking it in for another vw.

I think reliability isn't what id say they're best for, - the cars can take a massive beating for what they are, strong engines - but as previously mentioned, it depends on if you get a good one or not!

I've had

mk4 polo 1.4 cl - i wore the clutch out and it used to keep cutting out, the windows stopped working and various bits of trim fell off it but i ragged it so much, but the engine was strong when i sold at 86k

corsa b 1.6 16v - nothing went wrong, only problem i had was the air con needed regassing. then it started burning monumental amounts of oil so i sold it

mk3 polo GT - I've replaced, both driveshafts, gearbox refurb [altho needs another after 1500 miles due to a SHIT garage] ignition coil, had to replace the shocks coz they were fucked. gradually getting it back to A1 though

volkswagens are reliable

pah!

mk1 clio 1.2rl, full engine rebuild over 1 and half year

mk4 polo 1.4cl, new drivers side electric window regulator and motor and now trying to find new engine because its overheated and died! thats over a couple of months

lol my clio was more reliable but maybe I'm just unlucky :lol: (both not good tbh)

94 Ford Fiesta 1.3 - No problems at all, only consumables. Engine mounts (they were 104k old) and exhaust. 1 year.

94 Fiat Punto 1.1 - Jesus shit loads. My nan bought me it and showed me the garage bill she paid to sort it out, about £600 of repairs. Then a couple months/1500 miles later, the engine had a new oil leak. - 2 months

96 Fiat Bravo 1.4 - Ran sweet for 4 months, only needing to replace brake pipes for the MOT. Then the engine died on me. Wasn't into engines then but got told that it was most likely a valve dropped through to the piston and that shot it all up. - 4 months

93 Ford Mondeo 1.8 - Rust, clutch and a wheel bearing was on it's way out, valves sounded a bit tappety, but then I only paid £70 for it to run for a month before the MOT ran out. I got about £90 back in tax and £60 for the car when I scrapped it.

95 Ford Fiesta 1.8 Diesel - Nothing wrong at all, sold a year later still going strong.

96 VW Polo 1.4 - I've had a few bills with this but all consumable. Tyres, clutch, a wheal bearing and the brake pipes for the MOT, oh and the servicing like fuel filter/spark plugs/leads etc because the car struggled with the old ones (didn't know there were that old) but that's been about it. Still going strong - had it for 11 months so far.

Edited by wizardflake

Peugeot 106 - Driveshaft fucked, wheel bearings away.

BMW 318i - Exhaust and cat fooked within 2 weeks but that could have been with the amount of use.

Punto Sporting 1.6 - Gearbox went bang, timing belt went, Starter problems, Exhaust fooked all the time, Calipers bent.

VW Polo GTI - Zilch :-D

polo 1.4cl 6n - cambelt replaced at 50k, thermostat housing replaced, linkage re-fixed on gearbox, engine mounts going

I've had most things, of late, the following spring to mind:

1989 Toyota Camry - Can't describe how much I love this car. 2.5 years and 40-odd thousand miles down the line, it's only had tyres, brakes, a pair of CV joints and a pair of drop links (replacing original ones from 1989).

1996 Vauxhall Vectra 1.8 - 158k on the clock, bought it as a stop gap. Brilliant engine, really economical and not bad on go for a 1.8 in a big car. Shame the rest of the car was dropping apart.

1993 Rover 414 - My dad's car. 72k on the clock from new, it's gutless and dying on it's arse.

hang on no one has mentioned pierburg yet

hang on no one has mentioned pierburg yet

Mk3 Polo - 8 months of problem free motoring apart from when the head gasket went but was completely my fault

Mk2 Golf - 6 months of carb trouble but nothing else

:wink:

Mk2 Golf Driver 1990 - No end of probs, had a prettyclean run over the past year... I think I got the friday afternoon car lol but its cheap coz I can fix it myself ;)

polo 1.4 cl - 104500 miles - never ever had any engine/gearbox components replaced! Not even by previous owners! Only thing i have changed is the exhaust, that was blowing, but i want a full stainless anyway. Engine and gearbox are in perfect condition still :-D

My friends father bought a Mk2 Golf Gti 8v from new.

Sold it many years later, with no mechanical glitches, with 330,000 miles on the clock.

He did look after it though.

My Corrado VR6 has never given me any jip, with 148,000 miles on the clock, and the C.O. emissions on the MOT came through as 0.03%, which was nice.

I agree it's partly due to luck, but it will always help if you service regularly and look after them generally.

Both my VW Polos have been very reliable cars which is surprising considering the age and milage of them, but as said before its all about luck.

In my car history I have owned 2 Saxo VTR's (still got one of them) the first one, bought it with 112K miles no service history ran it (rather thrashed it) to 122K miles and replaced brake discs which you cant really count. Second one, bought it on 88K with some history, it blew up at 94K and I drove it alot nicer than I did my old one!

But back to the VW's

Mk3 Coupe 1.05 CL, ran for 6 months, 115K miles, replaced brake pipes for the MOT and other shitty little things. It eventually blew up but it was my fault.

Mk4 Valver (still got it) Had it since february, on 120K miles just now, FWVSH, not one thing has gone wrong with it, still pulls like a train and feels really good and solid to drive :)

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.