Skip to content

What's more fun and better to own?

Featured Replies

Basically what would make a better purchase? I'm looking to get rid of the slowlo and get either a Gt or coupe S but still undecided.. Shed some light of your experiences with either please people

Edited by aroncmc22

  • Replies 67
  • Views 4.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

a coupe S with a GT engine. fundamentally they are the same bar the engine.

  • Author

Yeah I know.. hence the trouble deciding. Either way I wanna get a pre-cat model but just having the 'carb or ecu controlled' dilema

Never had either, but id go for the coupe s, look better imo 8-)

I vote you flip a coin if you want both the same :thumbsup:

When i raced a coupe s you could tell i had more in each gear, i reckon just get an old GT and de-cat it. MPI FTW!

play rock paper scissors by yourself?

get a early GT....still some low mileagers floating around if you look hard enuf....i pick GT just because its a tad more modern. MPI! and no problems with carbs or shizzle

My GT is decatted, does make a noticable difference at higher speed-accelerating :)

i'd go for the GT Aron.

I would go for a gt. Just because i know one that might be coming up for sale soon ;)

I've got both (well, it's a pre-S coupe, but the same bar the seats and spots). Love em both, and can't choose between them. Yeah, the GT is a bit quicker, but you're a lot closer to what's going off with the Coupe S. No servo, no steering damper and a carb engine.

To play it the other way, the only thing that would put me off a Coupe S is if it's a 4-speed (but that's easily sorted), whereas if a GT isn't right, it can be a headache to sort.

Stab yourself in the thigh!

  • Author
I've got both (well, it's a pre-S coupe, but the same bar the seats and spots). Love em both, and can't choose between them. Yeah, the GT is a bit quicker, but you're a lot closer to what's going off with the Coupe S. No servo, no steering damper and a carb engine.

To play it the other way, the only thing that would put me off a Coupe S is if it's a 4-speed (but that's easily sorted), whereas if a GT isn't right, it can be a headache to sort.

Thats what I'm thinking, would the Coupe S be a bit more reliable than the Gt.. hmm decisions, decisions

  • Author
Stab yourself in the thigh!

Hows that gonna help??

I would expect them to be just as reliable/unreliable as each other, their old cars.

  • Author
I would expect them to be just as reliable/unreliable as each other, their old cars.

Ok perhaps reliable isn't the right word.. maybe easier to diagnose/repair when faults do occur

Edit: but do the extra 20 raging german horses in the Gt outway that factor..

Edited by aroncmc22

Talk to Tractorboy he has the best of both worlds now. He's got a F reg Coupe S and Mint L reg GT what a lucky git ay!

The GT is:

> Unaffected by air temperature as it's MPI.

> Very economical.

> Very reliable.

> Quicker off the mark and can power up hills better thanks to it's gearbox.

> Not outdated in it's appearance.

But the flipside in the unlikely event that it's running wrong is that it mostly seems to be electronic faults and dodgy sensors which can sometimes be a bugger to pinpoint- just speak to Mariojoshi for example. The higher compression means that engine flow improvements will be a little more...improvey.

The Coupe S is:

> Affected by air temperature as it's carburated, this refers to carb icing in the winter which is not pleasurable if you don't have a countermeasure.

> Child's play to pinpoint problems and fix fueling problems with a screwdriver, after the pierberg is replaced by a much better weber carburettor.

> Very reliable, but more likely to fuck up until the pierberg is replaced by a much better Weber carburettor, after which it's child's play.

> Economical, but not so much as a GT.

> Better built than a Mk3, that includes the spanish Mk2's.

But the flipside when running wrong is that it mostly seems to be due to the pierberg carburettor. When replaced by a much better weber carburettor, it's actually a shitload better to drive anyway. In addition to that, when replacing the pierberg with a much better weber carburettor, if my rolling road readout is anything to go by, the resulting performance gain put mine almost on a level with a GT when considering both bhp and torque.

Sounds like the Coupe S is most likely going to be the best choice

This picture might help too

DSC00199.jpg

Edited by Roly

Which is more reliable, to be honest, I'd say the mk2. They're not as prone to head gasket failure and random annoying sensor faults.

However, it's all down to perspective. I don't naturally find electronic fault finding as easy as old school stuff like points ignition). Granted, carb fault finding isn't always either (me vs karl's mars red shed), but it's a matter of your personal bias towards either mechanical/vac systems or electronic systems.

That said, armed with a couple of the guides on here, working on a GT is pretty damn straightforward.

I'm also utterly biased because my mk2 has an HK in, which I love to bits. I'm not to struck by MH's and 2G's as they don't seem as revvy or reliable as an HK.

The GT is:

> Unaffected by air temperature as it's MPI.

> Very economical.

> Very reliable.

> Quicker off the mark and can power up hills better thanks to it's gearbox.

> Not outdated in it's appearance.

But the flipside in the unlikely event that it's running wrong is that it mostly seems to be electronic faults and dodgy sensors which can sometimes be a bugger to pinpoint- just speak to Mariojoshi for example. The higher compression means that engine flow improvements will be a little more...improvey.

The Coupe S is:

> Affected by air temperature as it's carburated, this refers to carb icing in the winter which is not pleasurable if you don't have a countermeasure.

> Child's play to pinpoint problems and fix fueling problems with a screwdriver, after the pierberg is replaced by a much better weber carburettor.

> Very reliable, but more likely to fuck up until the pierberg is replaced by a much better Weber carburettor, after which it's child's play.

> Economical, but not so much as a GT.

> Better built than a Mk3, that includes the spanish Mk2's.

But the flipside when running wrong is that it mostly seems to be due to the pierberg carburettor. When replaced by a much better weber carburettor, it's actually a shitload better to drive anyway. In addition to that, when replacing the pierberg with a much better weber carburettor, if my rolling road readout is anything to go by, the resulting performance gain put mine almost on a level with a GT when considering both bhp and torque.

Would you reccomend swapping the pierburg for a webber carb then? :-p

Would you reccomend swapping the pierburg for a webber carb then? :-p

That sounds like a capital idea! Why didn't I think of that!

Would you reccomend swapping the pierburg for a webber carb then? :-p

That sounds like a capital idea! Why didn't I think of that!

Youre just not spesh enough :paranoid:

I've got both (well, it's a pre-S coupe, but the same bar the seats and spots). Love em both, and can't choose between them. Yeah, the GT is a bit quicker, but you're a lot closer to what's going off with the Coupe S. No servo, no steering damper and a carb engine.

To play it the other way, the only thing that would put me off a Coupe S is if it's a 4-speed (but that's easily sorted), whereas if a GT isn't right, it can be a headache to sort.

Thats what I'm thinking, would the Coupe S be a bit more reliable than the Gt.. hmm decisions, decisions

I do like the mk2's but there just a bit old for me now, if i got one the first i was going to do was change the dash to a mk3 anyway :lol:

GT's are reliable, some have had really bad luck with them on here. I have had one for long enough to know if its got a good engine internally you only need to spend some money on the sensors and thats it.

Stab yourself in the thigh!

i'd be careful if i was you, you'll end up getting abusive PM's :lol:

I'd go for a Coupe S just by a tad, because they look a lot cooler

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.