Skip to content

What's more fun and better to own?

Featured Replies

  • Author

Hows about if I said I'd found a Coupe S with a years mot for less than £300 :)

  • Replies 67
  • Views 4.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

To drive, I think the GT is far better.

Not only is it a lot quicker but it is uses less fuel too. The servo'd brakes are more responsive which is a bonus. IMO they are really good drive.

However, to look at the MK3 GT ain't anywhere near as nice (IMO). I personally prefer the shape of the breadvan (no surprise there!) and I would have a GT breadvan if I could as opposed to the GT Coupe. The dashboard instruments aren't as clear as the MK2's and I really love the retro feel and look of the MK2.

The only trouble with the MK2 Coupe S is the standard 55bhp engine/transmission. They have the nice sporty looks but have the same plodding old engine as found in a normal "granny spec" Polo. The spoilers, wheel arch extentions, rev counter, wider wheels, sports seats and steering wheel are all very nice but unfortunately just cosmetics. I couldn't be arsed with that, I'd have to have a proper full GT conversion (preferably modified to circa 90+bhp) in a Coupe S or nothing at all.

So for me, in standard form I'd say the GT is more fun and better to own. But only because of its engine/transmission.

Edited by breadman

GT!

Girlfriend drives the GT

I drive the Coupe S

That kind of says it all, except the Coupe S is on Twin Webbers and some sort of Lairy Cam.

I have far more fun driving the coupe, think roly will tell you that. Id have the GT on a longer journey any day, better on fuel and its a much better ride comfort wise.

Edited by tractorboy

Other thing to bear in mind is scene tax, the rate at which it's applied seems to vary on Coupe S's and GT's, in that one month GT's are doing good money and Coupe S's go for scrap metal prices, and the next month it'll be reversed.

Styling is a matter of opinion..

UTF-8BSmF6ei5qcGc.jpg

..as is the tidy interior..

UTF-8BUG9saW50ZXJpb3IuanBn.jpg

..electronic ignition and hydraulic head from '87.. (alternative carbs shown)

UTF-8BSW1hZ2UwMDAuanBn.jpg

Is that yours mikey? That looks mint

  • Author

Does look pretty sweet, best colour for a Coupe s imo

The first pic is colour-shopped by the 'alternative colours' feature on my phone. This was to see what it'd look like in Jazz blue,but its otherwise the same. Its currently awaiting a re-spray,though i'll stick to Comet blue. Maybe..

The other two are as it is today.

  • Author

Yeah thats what I mean, comet blue being the best colour.. quite rare by all accounts right?

Well Liz and Charlie's are both Comet blue,but its been many years since i last saw one in the flesh - parked in the next estate from me,i liked it,and its fitting that i finally have one like it. I still think Tornado red suits this de-chromed sports trim best,though.

well i don't know if my post can really count as i haven't owned either, but i do own a mk2 'bready' and personally i think mk2s look much better, crackin soundin engine (IMO) for such an old and small and standard car and tho i haven't been to enthusiastic in my driving yet, mainly due to tyres, its pretty chuckable and this s standard spec.

:thumbsup:

Early spec HK Engined Coupe S stripped out with a webber DMTL and a decent exhaust is blaitently quick enougth .. Believe Charlies old Mooneys Edition Coupe S wouldnt of been far off karl's 90Bhp ish GT and that just had a DTML on it . Sounded the Nuts too the whissing noise of that Carb 8-)

Far cooler than a mk3 too :nod:

Edited by StevieDavison

I prefer the look and the more solid feel of a mk2 coupe s but a mk3 GT is miles better to drive in my opinion. I've never owned a coupe s myself but a couple of my friends have. An ideal situation would be to buy a mk2 coupe s and put a GT engine and gearbox into it.

The thing with a coupe s is that it's only a trim level really, it still has the same 55bhp engine as the normal 1.3 mk2 polos (I'm only really considering later mk2s here by the way...) and the same Pierburg carb which are all pretty knackered by now.

its very hard to say, I much prefer the look and feel of mk2's they are just better built especially the early ones. as said before the best option is a mk2 with a GT engine :-D I would personally choose an A or B plate mk2 with the HK engine and put webbers on it those engines are brilliant.

I've not had many problems with any of mine, as said before its easier to find faults and fix things on mk2's, I've never really had any carb issues either always run really nicely. I'm not a fan of electrical stuff so i prefer working on mk2s i'd get a bit stuck if i had ecu problems, give me good old mechanical stuff any day :lol:

you really need to do something with a MH or 2G engine as they are no where near as quick as GT as standard, also mine does about 100 miles to a tank less than the SPI not sure about the GT as Bluey is modified and has a really small tank so i've not compared, when i drive bluey i tend to not care all that much....

its an interesting question, I've owned both, had an early coupe s on a d reg, and a late g reg and have to say the early one was miles better, thing is i much prefer the styling both internally and externally of the mk3. i think the thing that would swing it for me is that with a coupe s slapping a set of bike carbs on wouldnt be that much trouble.

Out of all of the polos I've owned the g reg coupe s was the mostly unreliable, but this was down to it still having its original pooburg and 160k on the clock. Both gts that I've owned have been super reliable and just as well built as either of my mk2s.

guess its just down to personal choice.

I've got a HM engine in the coupe, and its miles quicker than my GT. But its not standard, much better sound too

  • Author

I thought I had this in the bag.. I thought I'd made up my mind and was gonna go with a Gt but after hearing what Liz and Tractorboy have to say I'm not so sure.. :?

If you can get a coupe s cheap id give that a go. Then you can spend a bit of money playing with it

  • Author

Have just found out that 'Coupe S' is actually a parade! :-(

think I'm gonna hold out for a Gt actually.. I have a garage full of Mk3/Gt bits and I know Mk3's fairly well so I'd be silly not to me thinks.

  • Author

I think the better mpg, more horses, steering damper, servo and compensator win for me :-)

What do you want out of the car? If you are going to keep the car standard then its really down to the looks and the difference in performance. If you are going to modify it then it really just boils down to looks, as Visually they are completely different cars mechanically they are exactly the same car.

If you prefer the looks of a Mk2 but want the power of the GT, then its simple and cheap to do a engine swap. ;)

I think the better mpg, more horses, steering damper, servo and compensator win for me :-)

Really I wouldn't choose the car because of the steering damper and compensator, I'm not sure the damper does much (can always be retro fitted if needs be) and the compensator becomes useless if you lower the car and I don't think it works well in the first place anyway :) BHP would be a factor if you were not going to modify the car as 20bhp is a noticeable difference.

Personally I prefer the looks of the mk2 so I just transplanted all the GT bits in my car. Effectively my car is now a Mk3 GT but with a Mk2 body and interior (what's left of it). :-D

I have a mk2 coupe S with a GT engine in it.

I bought it with the carbed 1.3 with only 40,000 miles on the clock and it ran beautifully and seemed pokey enough for a little bit of fun. After about 6 months of owning it i put on a brand new weber DMTR and GK inlet for some better gains. Was mildly improved performance but just much better to drive and fiddle with.

After a year or so i wanted some more power so put a GT engine in and i have to say that performance is greatly improved. A coupe s with a weber and gk will stand no chance against a GT mk2 or a mk3 GT. Sorry stevie but mooneyes would have had its arse handed to it by a GT :lol: Webers are good at what they do but they aren't really a performnace upgrade.

If its looks buy a mk2.

If its performance straight away GT.

If its both get a mk2 and put a GT engine into it.

My opinion anyways.

buy my gt and sort the problems 8-) lol

  • Author
buy my gt and sort the problems 8-) lol

You want too much for yours thou! :p

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.