Skip to content

Point Proven.

Featured Replies

for a while now i've been intrigued too how well the mk5 gti's go apposed to the mk4 16v. a few people have said that a 16v with a few choice breathing mods will see off a gti so we thought we'd test the theory when one got part exed in at my mates place. olly brought the gti home off the forecourt this weekend to our suprise on an otherwise standard car it turned out to be running a green ram air filter! on friday we had a go against my mate jason's valver which is running a bmc and catback exhaust. we tried hard (on my mates private runway of course :-D ) and jasons valver left us, not by much but there was no doubt he pulled away.

so after that i thought i'd see if anyone else has any experience of the two, also be interesting to see what sort of 1/4 mile time the two different cars run.

  • Replies 119
  • Views 12k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I have said this before soooo many times.

At last someone else who can back me up.

wheyy

Anybody know the weight difference between the two?

6n....

Fuel Delivery Injection

BHP 100.0

Torque (lbs feet) 94.0

RPM to which the Torque refers 6000

Maximum Speed 117

Acceleration (0-60) 10.5

Running Costs

Insurance Group 10

Fuel Economy: Urban 29.4

Fuel Economy: Extra Urban 52.3

Fuel Economy: Combined 40.9

Emissions Data (co2 gm/km) 170

Service Intervals 12 mths/10000 miles

Description

No of doors 3

Body Style Hatchback

Transmission Manual

Fuel type Petrol

Front Brakes DISC

Rear Brakes DRUM

Tyre type 185/55 R14H

Production Start Date 21 May 1998

Production End Date 6 January 2000

Key Dimensions

Length (mm) 3715

Width (mm) 1655

Height (mm) 1420

Unladen weight 1025

Boot Capacity (litres) 244

6n2.....

Fuel Delivery Injection

BHP 125.0

Torque (lbs feet) 112.0

RPM to which the Torque refers 3300

Maximum Speed 127

Acceleration (0-60) 8.7

Running Costs

Insurance Group 12

Fuel Economy: Urban 27.7

Fuel Economy: Extra Urban 51.4

Fuel Economy: Combined 39.2

Emissions Data (co2 gm/km) 173

Service Intervals 12 mths/10000 miles

Description

No of doors 3

Body Style Hatchback

Transmission Manual

Fuel type Petrol

Front Brakes VENT DISC

Rear Brakes DISC

Tyre type 195/45R15 V

Production Start Date 3 May 2000

Production End Date 30 April 2001

Key Dimensions

Length (mm) 3743

Width (mm) 1632

Height (mm) 1418

Unladen weight 1084

Boot Capacity (litres) 974

so 59kg more in the gti unladen

Edited by polo6n2g40

  • Author

plus this ones spec'd up with the heated leather with must add a fair bit more weight!

plus this ones spec'd up with the heated leather with must add a fair bit more weight!

Yes leather will add a bit of weight!

I know for a fact standard against standard the gti would win!

Oh boy, this one again.

You won't get an answer to this one on here I'm affraid.

All the 6n fan boys will say a 6n is faster, and visa versa.

In my experience the GTi is slightly faster low end, but quite a bit faster at top end.

Oh and if we are going for standard V standard, YES a GTi Would definately beat a 6N

EDIT: You said Us, does that mean two people where in your car? Meaning double the internal weight in the GTI?

Edited by Quantic

You can scrap that 10.5s to 60 straight off for the valver... my Escort does 0-60 in a shade over 9 seconds and kwijibo's 16v leaves me no problem above 40

Agreed 10.5 to 60 is bullshit! I've very roughly timed my car to 60 in 9 seconds and its standard!

I think for arguement sake we should just say that the GTi and 6N 1.4 16v are equally fast.

Neither are gonna set the world on fire, and as for 0-60 stats, I don't beleive them for a second. (I mean the ones posted by VW)

Edited by Quantic

I would have thought there is no doubt a GTI is quicker than a valver

Top end is obviously going to be higher, mk4 16vs run out of revs at 125 or so don't they?

I think VW's 0-60 times and top speed times are a little on the conservative side. I'm sure I heard someone on here a few days ago say that a 16v would bounce off the limiter in 5th, and that's about 120-something mph.

Edited by 6Newan

I think for arguement sake we should just say that the GTi and 6N 1.4 16v are equally fast.

from reading his post i don't think he was arguing any thing, it seems like they raced 2 cars and one lost. ok it don't sound like the most scientific of experiments, but how scientific do you have to be to line 2 cars up and drive?

i'd just like to add i have no experience what so ever of either of these cars, i'm just going off what was said in the original post :thumbsup:

Edited by modest mouse

Regardless of which is faster the AFH is the engine with the potential to do a lot more apparently...so if you were worried about performance it's the one you'd pick surely.

Well, I have raced a 1.4 16v Polo 6N along the A1 and he was miles behind me. (In a GTi)

You have to consider; passengers, driving ability, condition of both cars....

Something as small as having really heavy wheels on one car is enough to make it loose over a high speed long ish race.

how scientific do you have to be to line 2 cars up and drive? Well I've beated a 350Z in my mini and I'm guessing that had something todo with driving ability rather then power.

MK4 FTW

Not this AGAIN ffs :lol:

Mk3 GTs are better though

:lol:

travesty that VW used the GTI badge on the 6n2 though really tbh...

Anyway, I think everyone knows the AFH is the one to go for if you want to tune it, as said by Tav already

what i've notice going against cymrupolo from the meets we have on flat there is not much in it but when we go up hills his car does pull beta! but all cars r different! i think my old valver is quicker than the one i own now!!

travesty that VW used the GTI badge on the 6n2 though really tbh...

they have a history of just sticking the badge on any thing to try and sell it as sporty, i'm not saying the polo don't deserve it, but some vw's don't do the badge justice.

how scientific do you have to be to line 2 cars up and drive? Well I've beated a 350Z in my mini and I'm guessing that had something todo with driving ability rather then power.

and to add to the mix...

I've beaten a Cooper S in a polo 16v a few times :shock:

polo gti - slow

polo 16v - slow

marry the two? - nippy

didn't know nos came as standard :lol:

i've only driven a 16v once and i didnt think too much of it tbh :?

how scientific do you have to be to line 2 cars up and drive? Well I've beated a 350Z in my mini and I'm guessing that had something todo with driving ability rather then power.

and to add to the mix...

I've beaten a Cooper S in a polo 16v a few times :shock:

polo gti - slow

polo 16v - slow

marry the two? - nippy

Haha, either your just saying that to try and annoy me or your lying, or the driver had grey hair :lol: :lol: :lol:

EDIT: Actually, I can't be arsed with a my cock is bigger then your cock, cometition so ill delete this bit.

Edited by Quantic

i've beaten max's GTI in a 1.7 CDTI Corsa Combi Van! They're alright, but not awesomely quick.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.