Skip to content

have you ever thought...

Featured Replies

dont you think its kinda funny that because of one mans/womans designs, a whole fan club has been created and yet nobody ever thanks the designer/s for these cars? do you recon they will ever visit club polo and think "wow look what i started" or maybe "yeah but what thanks do i get" lol. sorry for the random post but was just in random thought mode and came up with this theory haha :D

so who the hell designed the mk4? :p lol

  • Replies 19
  • Views 1.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most real mini owners know who Sir Alec Issigonis was.

Most BMW MINI owners haven't a clue who designed their ugly car,and the same can be said for most Polo owners.

But which Polo? I doubt the latest version was designed by the same person who designed the Audi 50,over thirty five years ago.

But yeah,when working on the car,I've often thought/noted the way its been designed.

It was probably a YTS kid who got given the plans for the Mk1 Golf and got told "draw it again a bit smaller, don't worry too much if stuff like brakes and wishbones don't fit" 8-)

Giorgetto Giugiaro, designed the audi 50 - same dude as the mk1 golf, so yeah :lol:

Walter de'Silva is responsible for the design 2005 - present... wikipedia is ace...

HERE IT IS IN FULL

i say we find this guy, polish our cars up, gather on a lawn, and name a show after him!

if he comes we pick him up on our shoulders and carry him around.

some of us will cry with joy,

others will be too scared to speak,

it will be a beautiful day

:lol:
:lol: lol @ Rin

lol, come to think of it, i think the guy will be shocked..

imagine walking into your neighbours basement, finding 50 people huddled in it, worshiping your socks.

I'm sure the guy would be like, "calm down its a car".

sell out.

imagine walking into your neighbours basement, finding 50 people huddled in it, worshiping your socks.

I think stuff like that only happens in Austria

I hate to ruin your idea but if I'm correct the guy dided a few months ago.

Most real mini owners know who Sir Alec Issigonis was.

Most BMW MINI owners haven't a clue who designed their ugly car

:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

Get a grip

No i have never thought who designed the polo.

The stupid prick(s) that designed the gearbox on the 6n need a bloody good kicking.

All the previous model Polo's had excellent tough little gearboxes. Then, especially for the 6n they made "improvements"! Mmmm.

Most important of all, who's fucking idea was it to let the Spanish "build" and "control the quality" of a VW design? Were they not shown how to point a wax injection probe or apply rust prevention for instance?

  • Author
The stupid prick(s) that designed the gearbox on the 6n need a bloody good kicking.

All the previous model Polo's had excellent tough little gearboxes. Then, especially for the 6n they made "improvements"! Mmmm.

Most important of all, who's fucking idea was it to let the Spanish "build" and "control the quality" of a VW design? Were they not shown how to point a wax injection probe or apply rust prevention for instance?

Very true, what happened to it being a german car when its manufactured in spain... its crazy thinking my polo was once in spain lol!

cars aren't designed by one sole individual. A team will be given a brief to follow and set about meeting it. yes, one individual may come up with a ground breaking design but this will still be modified, tried and tested and go through hundreds of alterations before a final design is selected....so what you would be looking for would be a team..however there could be sub divisions too....do you think one man designs everything from the indicators to the heater controls? No! another team has the task of interior and so on...hundreds of people go into the designing of cars not one. before anyone asks...i studied vehicle design for 4 years (a waste of 4 years of my life may i add, but thats another issue ha ha) and this kind of info was the kind of boring shit you were educated in......

Exactly - generally when people talk about who 'designed' a car they tend to mean who drew the artwork for the design concept - or more commonly these days, the design team leader that was responsible for the car's external appearance.

The years of graft by the engineering teams that goes into making those pretty pictures a reality is all too often overlooked.

As for the 6N gearbox - I'm still not convinced that the gearbox design is any worse than the older 085-series transmissions, the application (i.e. the combination of 6N chassis, driveshaft angle, 6N owner, silly lowering, lack of oil level checking) has more to do with it in my eyes.

The stupid prick(s) that designed the gearbox on the 6n need a bloody good kicking.

All the previous model Polo's had excellent tough little gearboxes. Then, especially for the 6n they made "improvements"! Mmmm.

Most important of all, who's fucking idea was it to let the Spanish "build" and "control the quality" of a VW design? Were they not shown how to point a wax injection probe or apply rust prevention for instance?

same box pretty much as earlier models, just made in spain from tin cans the casts in a bucket of sand with a blow torch!

A team will be given a brief to follow and set about meeting it.

In the case of the Audi 50; a team from NSU Audi under the command of Ludwig Kraus working to a brief given by the then CEO of VW, Rudolf Leiding. The brief was that it must be less than 700kg, be shorter than 11ft6in, have simple assembly and be easy to maintain with low running costs but more impressively, be ready for production in less than 2 years.

The overall results, given that VW had thus produced three new models in as many years, pretty much from scratch, was quite impressive. The only thing that they got wrong was assuming that the market, especially in the UK, didn’t want an up-market small car, hence no Audi 50. Or no other small Audi until the A2.

Most real mini owners know who Sir Alec Issigonis was.

Most BMW MINI owners haven't a clue who designed their ugly car

:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

Get a grip

mikey has a point tho, they are fugly

the new minis arent really worthy of carrying the name, a maxi would have been more appropriate. i used to laugh something chronic when people in the bmw maxis would wave at me as i drove past in my loud orange old skool rust bucket of a mini cooper sport. however it would be closely followed by a idiot sign out the window at them.

but then again i am a bastard.

as for who designed the polo and golf, i would have just said hilter was the one that started it all by making the people cars and indeed our beloved marque, beyond that I'm not really that arsed haha

and rins comments in this thread nearly had me in tears, fubarring legend you are mate

lets find out who designed the gearboxes on polos and go punch him in the head

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.