Skip to content

OK what would you do?

Featured Replies

Recently bought some parts on clubpolo from a respected CLUB member. I wont mention his name but when i reveived the part it was completely unuseable. (Bolt welded in place and bracket snapped off)

So basicly I'm £25 out of pocket for a part i thought i could just fit and it would all be hunkdory. I hacve PM'd the member but no reply (he may be on holiday)

Mods please pm me if neccessary.

Edited by tomadomeit

  • Replies 25
  • Views 2.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

"Buyer beware"

I would wait for the person in question to respond before launching an internet witch hunt!

How long have you given him to respond?

People arn't always on here every day and have busy lives, I've seen admin say before that they have no power over this sort of thing, although I'm sure they can stop them posting in the for sale sections etc.

If someone has genuinely ripped someone off then yes they can be added to a blacklist that stops them from being able to sell, there are several people on it right now.

  • Author

The guy isnt dodgy he is totally genuine but I'm just a bit annoyed that i couldnt fit the part. Especially after removing the original one and then having to put it back in as the new one was shagged.

Don't bite me, but did he advertise it as in perfect working order?

be totally reasonable with it, show us the advert, let the members add our views, but can i state now, if anyone comes on mouthing off utter rubbish it will be deleted (yeah like i have the power to lol)

and if we think, well yeah its ok, or, well i think it isnt fair etc

we can give our views, and not slate whoever it is etc

instead of a slate thread make it a "reasoning thread"

:D

Original Post:

http://www.clubpolo.co.uk/forum/index.php?...=114153&hl=

Sold as per advert - no additional photo's provided or checks requested - I obtained the items myself from another Club Polo member.

Items sent - received the following message:

"I received the two motors you posted me. The drivers side fitted in fine and is now working. But on closer inspection to the passengers side there is a bolt that has been welded in place and the clip that holds the glass clamp in place is snapped off. So its pretty much unuseable! Sorry to be an arse but this has pissed me off a bit as i had to put my old one back in again to keep the glass up."

I replied:

"The window kit was supplied from another seller on club polo along with the switches and loom to retro fit the setup into a base spec model.

After some debate about the wiring aspects I decided not to install the windows and make them available for sale.

I simply forwarded the items onto yourself in the condition in which they were received having not attempted to fit or try and fit the setup at all i am unsure as to what is faulty and why.

Apologies that you have a faulty item, however if you had requested pictures or a check of the item prior to the sale then i could have done so to avoid such a scenario.

I hope that a repair can be completed, VW sell a repair kit or the motor could be used on the existing runners as another alternative."

This isn't Ebay, and i'm not a shop, if you buy something then ensure that it is FULLY checked or photographic evidence is supplied to avoid such situations.

Dave

The guy isnt dodgy he is totally genuine

Then wait to hear back from him.

If you click on a member you can see the last time they were logged in.

I don't quite see how he was supposed to have noticed from the pictures if you didn't notice yourself? does that mean that you didn't unpack them? becuase if you had noticed then you should have mentioned it.

I didn't notice myself, I paid for them on the basis they could be straight fitted.

They were removed, put into my boot and driven up to Coventry, then advertised and sold on CP.

At no point did i inspect / take pictures or even try and fit them myself - they were sold as supplied to me.

Edited by DaveG40

Cant really show a thread it was all sorted over PM's. I will leave it a while give him a chance to reply. I PM'd him on monday.

Hello - ? :lol::oops:

I'm with tom on this one, the old "i never checked them" it doesnt say you have never even examined them, in the original post so is misleading for sure.

You sold something that was broken

"i didnt know the goods were stolen officer"

its that same logic, its a get out clause for selling crap to be honest.

Again just my views, but he should be refunded as the buyer hasnt done anything wrong here, you have sold something that was broken, and didnt state it in the listing. Irelevant wether you were aware of it or not.

I'm with tom on this one, the old "i never checked them" it doesnt say you have never even examined them, in the original post so is misleading for sure.

You sold something that was broken

"i didnt know the goods were stolen officer"

its that same logic, its a get out clause for selling crap to be honest.

Again just my views, but he should be refunded as the buyer hasnt done anything wrong here, you have sold something that was broken, and didnt state it in the listing. Irelevant wether you were aware of it or not.

True, however if you were buying an item that was currently faulty then some simple checks could have been requested from the buyers aspect to ensure this situation does not occur whereby my items for sale would be supplied in a faulty condition.

Who is to say that the item was not damaged in transit?

Who is to say that the item was not damaged by Tom when fitting?

There are too many variable to place the ball in either person court.

I'm not a shop, I'm not a VAG parts specilaist reseller either, i'm just offering items on the same terms / basis in which they were supplied to myself.

  • Author

Sorry I didnt realise that you bought them off another member previously. Could take pictures of the damage but its not really worth it. The parts that are broken cant be replaced so i will just have to find another one. The design of these mechs is a f*cking joke anyway too many bits are plastic and can break too easily.

The good news is that the drivers side works fine so thanks for that.

Anyone need a passengers side window mech lol?

The thing that miffed me was that some1 previously had welded a bolt onto the mech as they had sheared a bolt by the looks of it. And the fact that the clamp to hold the glass was snapped (i guess that could of happened in transit but the welding?)

Edited by tomadomeit

I hope that you can combine the existing and supplied you have and get a working setup out of the pair. If not can anyone else suggest a suitable repair for the problem?

Dave

Na your logic is well wrong, it wasnt damaged in transit as it has a bolt welded on!!!

and simple checks could have been requested, that is just plain silly, to sell something you should at least check it over to make sure, and if you dont, you tell them, i aint even touched this from when i bought it.

doesnt matter if your just an individual selling parts, same "terms/basis" what terms would they be?!?!?

you sold parts that were damaged, and not as listed, you owe him a refund in my eyes

  • Author

I didnt really want this to get this heated!!

I will see what i can do in regards to swapping bits over but as i said before the design is so bad on these mechs. The metal clamps are held on with cheap plastic clips which are not replaceable.

Na your logic is well wrong, it wasnt damaged in transit as it has a bolt welded on!!!

and simple checks could have been requested, that is just plain silly, to sell something you should at least check it over to make sure, and if you dont, you tell them, i aint even touched this from when i bought it.

doesnt matter if your just an individual selling parts, same "terms/basis" what terms would they be?!?!?

you sold parts that were damaged, and not as listed, you owe him a refund in my eyes

To sell something you should check it over to make sure of what? How the fuck would I know the difference between a good one and a bad one?

Last time i looked my job title was not mk4 polo window mech specialist...

The welded bolt could have been a manufacturer weld, and the snapped plastic he mentions could very well have been done when fitting - In my opinion your logic is "well wrong" but then we already know why your bantering away at me don't we?

I didnt really want this to get this heated!!

I will see what i can do in regards to swapping bits over but as i said before the design is so bad on these mechs. The metal clamps are held on with cheap plastic clips which are not replaceable.

If the motor has died on the existing, but has a good runner / mech - try swopping the motor over.

It's not your fault some of the other members hold grudges :roll:

Edited by DaveG40

Boys Boys Boys Boys Boys!

Now Dave is responding tomadomeit, why don't you take it to pm and solve it between yourselves as I am sure you can come to some sort of agreement ;)

Well - there is no further action to take - so case closed.

I'll bet some proper scene situation will now occur - wherby something will be posted that i cannot defend against as the post will be 'conveniently' locked.

Its obviously between the two of you, and noone knows who is telling the truth appart from perhaps the person that sold it to Dave in the first place! and we can't tell you what to do or police it in any way but i would suggest that you give him at least a partial refund as a guesture of good will.

I could be sceptical and say that i don't believe you didn't know it was faulty but there is no point as it can't be proven! Either way if you are selling something then you should make sure its ok before you advertise it simple as, and if you had just brought it and not even unwrapped it then you should state that and someone can either have the option of taking that risk or ask you to check it and take photos.

You may not be a trader or dealer or anything but you must still have a conscience

Na your logic is well wrong, it wasnt damaged in transit as it has a bolt welded on!!!

and simple checks could have been requested, that is just plain silly, to sell something you should at least check it over to make sure, and if you dont, you tell them, i aint even touched this from when i bought it.

doesnt matter if your just an individual selling parts, same "terms/basis" what terms would they be?!?!?

you sold parts that were damaged, and not as listed, you owe him a refund in my eyes

To sell something you should check it over to make sure of what? How the fuck would I know the difference between a good one and a bad one?

Last time i looked my job title was not mk4 polo window mech specialist...

The welded bolt could have been a manufacturer weld, and the snapped plastic he mentions could very well have been done when fitting - In my opinion your logic is "well wrong" but then we already know why your bantering away at me don't we?

jesus tbh no, i only just realized it was you that screwed me and dougy over with £30 for a bounced cheque you said you would pay, and then decided, ah no i wont bother.

but anyway, yeah job is done, if he is happy to fix it and sort problem you are alright

but fact of the matter is, you sold a damaged broken mechanism, and the blame lies with you, not the buyer, your the seller, its your problem.

see not locked yet... but as you said its cas closed so can i lock this now please?

yeah please do lmao

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.