Skip to content

mk3 or mk4?

Featured Replies

hi dudes and dudettes.

i have been after a 6n for a while now, the 1.4 16v one. but have been thinking, what about a mk3? i dont know much about the different models so if anyone could help me out with that one it would be awesome :)... mainly GT and G40 (power, differences, insurance etc).

i only started thinking this as a mk3 could be easier on my wallet, or would i be mistaken? :lol:

what would you guys choose given the choice?

thanking you all muchly, lee 8-)

  • Replies 41
  • Views 3.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

GT - 75 bhp, think they are about 10-11s to 60, 110 mph

G40 -113 bhp, bout 8s to 60 and 125 mph

Mk4 16v - 100 bhp, 9-10s to 60, 125 mph

Standard anyway. Both are easily modded.

Compared to a 16v... I think I'd have a 16v over a Mk3 GT, but obviously a G40 over a valver.

I can't comment on insurance, nothing seems to cost a lot for me to insure lol.

  • Author

are you old? :lol:

I'm 19 with 2 years no claims... but am still insured on my mk2 golf gti 8v so as long as its not more than that haha

cheers dude :) you're a star

are you old? :lol:

I'm 19 with 2 years no claims... but am still insured on my mk2 golf gti 8v so as long as its not more than that haha

cheers dude :) you're a star

no he lives in the sticks :lol:

  • Author

lol, dam living in swindon (N)

I'm 19 with 1 years NCB

My Coupe S is £320 to insure... at 19... :lol:

Mk4 16v - 100 bhp, 10.2s to 60, 117 mph

Why are you getting rid of your mk2 golf gti for a polo out of interest?

GT - 75 bhp, think they are about 10-11s to 60, 110 mph hmmm had a bit more then that on my runway

What dublass said :?

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

i only started thinking this as a mk3 could be easier on my wallet, or would i be mistaken?

Motoring doesn't get much cheaper then running a mk3 buddy, get a GT if your after something you can have fun with but is still cheap to use and buy parts for.

G40's are top range for the mk3, they can be reliable but can require fair bit attention.

Edited by carver

  • Author

Cheers guys :-) when i next get to computer i will reply in full but basically financial cockup so had to sell, then managed to get a job for remainder of summer before i go back to uni, meaning i can get a car. Not sure if that made sense but ill explain in detail probs tomoro night. By the way what is the mk3 like on longer journeys on motorways? Also is 75bhp enough lol, or is it sluggish feeling? Ta :-)

I went everywhere in my old mk3 GT, longest trip i did was Midlands to Newquay. No problems at all, I'm driving to France this month in my current mk3 GT.

75bhp isnt alot but the mk3 is light and the GT has a short ratio box so the revs get up quick. You can chip them and mess about with them to get them to 90 - 95bhp which is quite fun in a mk3. I wouldnt get a G40 if your at uni, all it takes it to blow the charger seals and its major outlay of the ode cash.

Edited by carver

all the quoted figures are a bit shit, a mate of mine has done proven runs in his stock gt of high 9 second 0-60 times, with half tanks of fuel in, himself only in the car.

And I'm sure a G will do more than 125 if you're pushin it to its absolute limit!

mk3 gt FTW

They wont compare to your golf gti, they all should do roughly the same MPG in honesty. You'll just be saving on tax and insurance. Unless you get a normal 1.3 or 1.4 polo which should be even lower running costs still. :-)

GT - 75 bhp, think they are about 10-11s to 60, 110 mph hmmm had a bit more then that on my runway

So did i !!!! Theres alot of us who conveniently own runways on here! lol.

And I'm sure a G will do more than 125 if you're pushin it to its absolute limit!

Yes. Nuff said.

  • Author

ok so in full... i had a job for all of the summer but then got laid off before i started. as it looked unlikley i was to get a job i sold the golf as didnt feel i could run it for long with no income (though i loved it so much :(). anyway a couple of weeks afterwards i managed to get a job and so now need another car. i was thinking a polo as it would be cheaper to run and so easier on my wallet, relieving some stress throughout the whole year, and letting me go on a better field trip in my final year.

They wont compare to your golf gti, they all should do roughly the same MPG in honesty. You'll just be saving on tax and insurance. Unless you get a normal 1.3 or 1.4 polo which should be even lower running costs still. :-)

the same MPG??

thankyou all muchly for your input, it is all very good :)

So carver and jon, you're cars are standard?

my 1.3 genesis has done around 115mph, where did 110mph come from?

james.

So carver and jon, you're cars are standard?

It was standard when i did that run, which was my old car not the 1.6 GT i half have now :lol:

i hope all these top speed readings are from a gps and not speedo!

^^^ what he said

id go for a valver, less of a ballache car

I'm at uni and have sooo much of my loan on my GT repairing it and its up for sale for 400, and a valver costs less to insure lol

that said a GT is waaaay more fun than a mk4

important point - girls think youre a tramp if u drive a mk3 ahahahahahah

they're fuckin ace though, never had so much fun in a car, nothing better than wiping the smile off a smug rich kid

nothin scarier than going way past the end of the speedo aswell lol

i've got a gt an a g40 and a mk4 1.0.

and for giving it shit round the town... mk4 1.0 is my choice..

no matter what they say a little mk4 would spand any mk3 anywhere on corners.. so for me its makes things hell of a lot more fun..

I'm starting to think mk3's are dangerous for handling, I'm slightly scared of my G anyways. gets twitchy at even sensible speeds

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.