Skip to content

Dilemma time

Featured Replies

The GT failed its MOT on friday on about 10 points which mostly consists of brakes. It also needs a spring for the rear suspension and a bit of the exhaust.

The problem is, with the brakes and everything, it's gonna cost me (worst case scenario) about £380.

Now i love this car to bits and i smile everytime i see it. But as a student, i'm not sure i'm prepared to spend all that money on something i only really drive once a week.

So as i see it, i've got 3 options (+ another i'm unsure about):

1) fix it, Mot it and keep.

2) fix it, Mot it and sell.

3) sell as is for spares/repair.

4) take it off the road and fix it at a better time (issues with storage and general rotting etc)

So the point of typing this out was to ask you polo experts what my best plan of action is. Ultimatly its my decision i know but to know some facts and figures regarding money would possibly aid my decision.

Just to let you know as well; its pretty much rust free and has never had welding on. The MOT guy even said how solid it was.

Also if anyone has any propositions regarding it, i'm all ears!

cheers for your help.

  • Replies 28
  • Views 3.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

get it fixed and keep it.

you only live once and money isnt everything :)

plus if it makes you smile its got to be worth it!!!

x

get it fixed and keep it.

you only live once and money isnt everything :)

plus if it makes you smile its got to be worth it!!!

x

Post the list up of what actually needs doing, make some new friends in Sheffield who may be able to help on the cheap.

If you only live in congelton i will buy it off you... list what needs doing Duke!

If you only live in congelton i will buy it off you... list what needs doing Duke!

:lol: ROFL

jay your like a vulture,preying on the innocent with your need for a GT!!! :lol:

£380?!? You could replacing the entire braking system for a LOT less than that, put the list of failures up. Unless you are paying a garage to do the work of course...

  • Author

cheers for the replys guys.

£380 was the worst case scenario price to fix it in the garage.

List of faliures:

001 (both) Windscreen wiper does not clear the windscreen effectively

002 Offside rear brake hose ferrule excessivly corroded

003 Offside rear (flexi to cylinder) brake pipe excessivly corroded

004 Nearside rear brake hose ferrule excessivly corroded

005 Centre Exhaust has a major lek of exhaust gases

006 Centre Exhaust has a mounting that does not fully support the exhaust system

** 007 Brake pedal creeps down while the pedal is held under pressure **

008 Offside rear coil spring fractured

009 Emissions not tested (because of exhaust leak)

010 Service brake efficiencey below requirements

number 007 (*) is the big one because they dont know whats causing it. They think it could either be the rear brake shoes or the drums. but they need to look at it first. No doubt they will charge me for looking at it.

A certain well known poster messaged me about some help last night but if anyone else can offer any help cheaply then i'd really appreciate it. I've got till next monday to get it re-MOT'd before i have to pay again. I'd rather not sell it but it still is an option.

sound like it needs rear flexis and hoses to them - and probably rear cylinders/drums/shoes - perhaps handbrake cables. And the 007 sounds like master cylinder could be shot. Either way i'd suggest spending about £100-120 on these parts and do it yourself.

oh and you need a rear spring (scrappy???)

exhaust? clamp? paste?

wiper - blades?

its doable at home if you have the tools and time!

007 could be a leaking rear cylinder too. Sounds like the rear drums need stripping down, cleaning up and any knackered parts replacing, parts are cheap though. Cylinders are about £7 each. Flexis are cheap, about £40 for a full set of braided ones, less for normal rubber ones.

looking at the fail points...

worth fixing if you ask me, not even that hard a set of jobs :thumbsup:

get the toolkit out dude and get busy :D

  • Author
007 could be a leaking rear cylinder too. Sounds like the rear drums need stripping down, cleaning up and any knackered parts replacing, parts are cheap though. Cylinders are about £7 each. Flexis are cheap, about £40 for a full set of braided ones, less for normal rubber ones.

thats pretty much what the garage said.

Unfortunatly i dont have the tools or the time or the knowhow to do these things at the moment. Apart from the wiper blades really :p.

Would anyone have a spare bit of time at some point this week or weekend?

i would if i'd not offered to help do a clutch!

I'll help you do the work for petrol and beer moneies I'm in Huddersfield. Rebuilt my brakes few months back, shitty job first time round but okay once you get into it. Parts wise the rear drums cost about £25 iirc for new cylinders, springs and shoes. You could get the parts for £120ish and do it in a few hours, the only tricky part is if some of the actual lines need replacing in which case you need a brake flaring kit.

  • Author
I'll help you do the work for petrol and beer moneies I'm in Huddersfield. Rebuilt my brakes few months back, shitty job first time round but okay once you get into it. Parts wise the rear drums cost about £25 iirc for new cylinders, springs and shoes. You could get the parts for £120ish and do it in a few hours, the only tricky part is if some of the actual lines need replacing in which case you need a brake flaring kit.

Thats brilliant mate, thanks for the offer.

I'm phoning a guy that i know at around 5.30 or so. He's a mechanic and has all of the tools needed so depending on what he says i may take you up on the offer. But i'll let you know as soon as i know.

cheers for your help everyone.

Will you sell it after you have done the work?

good luck with it!!

  • Author
Will you sell it after you have done the work?

good luck with it!!

lol you'll be the first to know mate.

Better BE!!!! ;)

have a look on cheshire dubs for some locals that may be able to help out

www.cheshiredubs.co.uk

have a look on cheshire dubs for some locals that may be able to help out

www.cheshiredubs.co.uk

good plug for the site dude! :thumbsup::lol:

  • Author

i may have a solution atm guys but still not completely certain. I'll keep you all updated.

Carver i still may call on you for help if i'm still stuck but i'll let you know.

I'll probs join cheshiredubs anyway lol. Need to get involved more really!

No worries I'm heading to Nottingham on friday so will be passing Sheffield.

i may have a solution atm guys but still not completely certain. I'll keep you all updated.

Carver i still may call on you for help if i'm still stuck but i'll let you know.

I'll probs join cheshiredubs anyway lol. Need to get involved more really!

good call :thumbsup:

got a few mechanics on board at cheshiredubs matey...might be of some use to you :D

if i had my car on the road id come over to congleton and sort the brakes out for you,I'm only in macclesfield :D

  • Author

looks like i'm sorted on this. Cheers for the offers of help guys really appreciate it.

Getting it repaired for a decent price from someone i know so looks like i'll be keeping it! Sorry Jay. Good luck with the search tho mate.

1) fix it, Mot it and keep.

:nod:

Search is over mate hehe. picked a mniter up the other night for 895... 87000 miles and 12 mnoths MOT! cheers anyway though and maybe il lsee you about when youre in congelton! :)

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.