Skip to content

Which? Mk3 Or Mk4

Featured Replies

I'm selling my beetle and was thinking of getting a mk4 golf...but on secound thought

Why not a polo? Get a mk3/mk4 for alot cheaper why nto as modern still a nice car, but which?

I prefer the style of the mk3 and think there kinda a nicer car, but mk4 is newer and stil cheap up to the later like a 1998.

While not keen on a mk4 they look good moded, but so do mk3s and i dont want to do major mods really ,just lower,wheels.

So what you think?

  • Replies 48
  • Views 4.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

id go for a mk4 golf or mk5 polo if you can afford one, will be more reliable and wont rot away

  • Author
id go for a mk4 golf or mk5 polo if you can afford one, will be more reliable and wont rot away

be all money off selling car and bit more and christmas money going straight away. Give it 7months or so ill prob get a more modern car like a late mk4 golf once I'm in a proper contract job rather then part time employment so think that might be another reason to get a mk3 now and use it for several months then can always sell it cheap!

i've just bought a 1999 polo, 1.4 8v, will let you know what i think when i pick it up on monday!!

xx

I had a Mk3 and a Mk4, tbh i prefered the Mk3 - it was much more fun! And i didnt have any 'Rot' problems in any of them :lol:

I would get a Mk3, i reckon my GT would excite the Mk4 16v owners.

I would go for a mk3 myself. Mk4s are nice to drive but they are ugly to look at on the outside and doubley ugly on the inside. Mk3s look better and are a nicer place to sit in. There easy and cheap to work on to.

Having owned both, i prefer my Mk4 in terms of living with it, especially in the winter, its more comfortable, reliable, no rust etc..

However, speedwise about the same as my Mk3, slightly more top end, but the Mk3 is so much more fun to drive.

This time of the year i'd for something newer and a bit more practical, though it depends on your budget, for the same price, you could get a 15 year old, good condition Mk3, or a 10 year old, high mileage Mk4, i reckon the Mk4 would be more likely to have issues.

MK4s rust like hell though.

Mk3 for fun & back to basics

Mk4 for sensible motoring with creature comforts, I love mine but it bores me at times.

^^ Exactly what he said.

Thats what i mean Kam, for the same price, say £600 odd, i reckon the older Mk3 would in better condition.

  • Author

mk3 it is then, called two my dads going to look tommorow for sale (i have work otherwise would go myself) going to let me know how they are, one has 2owners from new,full service history and only 50k on clock aparntly :grin:

Mine had 50k on it as well. Was a good shell like, head gasket had gone though.

i have a mark 4 16v and to be honest, i really want something older.

just think they have a bit more character.

however, the valver is very reliable had no problems with it so far, easy to mod!

mk3 all the way

mk3s are shit

fun

but shit

mk4s are a lot nicer place to be, especially seeing as things like the heaters work

id say mk3s are defo a summer car

Mk3 all the way, a GT is comfortable enough inside. Much better than a basic spec Mk4

mk4's are bigger inside though... i don't really fit in mk2/mk3 :lol:

  • Author
mk3s are shit

fun

but shit

mk4s are a lot nicer place to be, especially seeing as things like the heaters work

id say mk3s are defo a summer car

i woudnt say a summercar, million times nicer, more comftable and warmer then several cars I've owned e.g. mini,beetle,mk2 golf

mk3s are shit

fun

but shit

mk4s are a lot nicer place to be, especially seeing as things like the heaters work

id say mk3s are defo a summer car

i woudnt say a summercar, million times nicer, more comftable and warmer then several cars I've owned e.g. mini,beetle,mk2 golf

thats what i was thinking. minis arent exactly the most comfortable cars. nout beats them though (sorry polo'ers)

but its a mk3 for me everytime, coupe or loon only tho, dont really like the look of bready's. IMO mk3's are much nicer to look at than mk4's. i decided a few days ago to save my polo virginity for a GT, so ill be getting a cheap run around until then...although i guess that could end up being a polo. or it might never happen if i get another min, all counts on which one turns up first and is the right car for me.

Mk3 for fun & back to basics

Mk4 for sensible motoring with creature comforts, I love mine but it bores me at times.

word!

mk3 is more puristic and more classical,furthermore it´s the last coupe-shape wich is available.a mk4 (compared with a mk3) is completly a different class.it´s safer,more comfortable and better for the winter.i hated my mk3 in the (german) wintertime :D

nevertheless,i love my mk3 and a km4 wouldn´t be able to replace it :)

MK3 heaters are fine. If they don't heat up in a reasonable amount of time then there is something wrong with them.

Got my MK3 last week, needs a couple of jobs doing (it was cheap :roll: ) but generaly happy with it, since buying it though i've seen tons of MK4's and MK5's driving about, parked etc but not one MK3.

MK3 heaters are fine. If they don't heat up in a reasonable amount of time then there is something wrong with them.

yeah my heaters were pretty shocking

took the matrix out, 5 min job and whacked the hose pipe onit to clear it out

as good as new now

ad say mk3, easy to work on, cheap, fun..

downside is, when you just want to plod along home...they can get abit anoying...stiffness of suspension (if you lower it) and exhaust!

av become use to it now, its my 50 mile a day daily slag..and it copes very well..will return 45 mpg from modded GT

mk3 with a mk4 engine FTW! :-D

naaah, mk2, mk4 engine AND berg cup kit

8-) :cool:

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.