Skip to content

Maybe Time To Buy A Diesel...

Featured Replies

well as the g/f's car has been written off, and she spends alot of time driving, it would be worth her getting a diesel i reckon

now we dont want to spend more than a grand on one, so i thought about a mk4 diesel, what are they like on fuel?

what other models are worth looking into (vw ideally) and under the budget of £1000

any ideas be great as i have no idea about diesels!

thanks

  • Replies 31
  • Views 1.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

the 1.4TDI lupo's but doubfully under a grand like

infact a 1.9 polo is probably your best bet like will probably fetch 60+mpg

I have a a diesel mk4 polo. They are good on fuel usually on a full tank you should easily get 500 miles if motorway driving. Mine has been pretty reliable too bought it with 98k its on 118k now with only a few services carried out. As for price i paid 800 for mine but there is rust on both sills and door.

It may be worth looking at the mk5 1.4tdi polo there was a colour concept one for sale on here not long ago.

Edited by tomadomeit

  • Author

there are a few mk4s for sale, i seen a 42k one for sale at £750, looks nice enough...

mines a 99 1.9 tdi ibiza which is basically a mark 4 polo. and its absolutely brilliant. get one!

thats decent that 1.9TDI it pull well?

Would the engine drop straight into a mk4 polo

  • Author

I'm not a fan of the 99 ibiza, that shape just looks fat and boat like

but i will have a look into it!

TBH, as diesel prices are that much higher than petrol, it's not really worth getting one.

TBH, as diesel prices are that much higher than petrol, it's not really worth getting one.

I was thinking the same thing, the more diesels on the road the higher the price gets. Just buy a small engined petrol.

considering i have one they are great on the motorway but round town not much better that a small engined petrol. you only get really good mpg on the motorway if you sit at 70 everywhere aswell.

ibiza are based on mk3 golf, stick with the lighter smaller polo option.

TBH, as diesel prices are that much higher than petrol, it's not really worth getting one.

i was thinking this a while back, are deisels a false economy? sure enough years ago when they weren't all turbo'd you'd go everywhere at 2k.

i recently lent my girlfreind my bora 2.0 8v (which was thirsty) to move a load of stuff up the country and the week she was away i was using her golf gt tdi and this cost more to run than the bora and when she got back she said the bora was good on fuel!

not enough in it to make me run a dirty diesel - smoking, rattling and sounds like you're pulling up in a transit van!

i agree with yeti. i was considering getting a mk4 diesel a while ago. when i sat and working it out tho i was better off with my 1.4 petrol.

Petrol has cheaper tax (only 1.4 engine instead of 1.9)

Petrol is one group lower for insurance (dunno why but it is!)

Petrol costs less at the pump

Its a lot easier to get a mk4 petrol, and then to keep it going (i.e parts etc)

And dont forget- mk4 diesel isnt a turbo diesel so its flat as....

So unless you are doing a lot of miles, you are not any better off.

Edited by ben_reza

TBH you guys are probably right. I forgot about the stupid amount of tax you have to pay on a diesel mk4 its £180 a year or £90 for 6 months

Oh and for some reason everytime i service my car GSF always send the wrong bloody air filter even though i give them my VIN No.

Edited by tomadomeit

  • Author

hmmm, good to read, she currently has a 16v polo, so whats best to go for for a bit of better fuel consumption?

sticking with the mk4's!

diesel is the future Dan, i can't wait to sell mine and but some Turbo Diesel power! hehe

Edited by hollypop

What about a 1.4 8v? Should see 45mpg and cheaper tax and parts then the 1.9D

I'm not convinced by older diesels, the new ones are really good but the older ones arn't anything amazing imo, my 1.6 GT is better on fuel then my mates 1.5 106D :lol:

As said they're good on the motorways but around town they're slow and still use fair amount of fuel.

i still think the mk5 1.4tdi is your best bet.

i still think the mk5 1.4tdi is your best bet.

You will enver get a MK5 TDI for under a grand!!

  • Author

all your comments are irelivent holly as you and your lovely boyfriends history with buying cars is clear you have no idea lol

My lass has a 1.9D and it does the job. Its a bit tatty externally but it runs fine, interior is fine, mechanically its fine, drives well and the likes. Its a 2 door one with PAS and electric windows. Around town its barely at tick over and gives brilliant MPG. They aren't the quickest things, but there not slow either. I don't mind driving it, feels nippy for a non-turbo diesel and over taking on hills is no bother for it.

I would say get the 1.4cl as i wont use thaty much more then the 1.0cl and you wont struggle on motorways. I had the 1.0 and round town it was the tits! Used to get 100miles each time out of £10, it wasnt great on motorways tho - you really noticed when their was a hill :lol:

all this "petrol is almost as economical as diesel" is bollocks.

i had a passat estate, 2.0 2e lump, my record was 52mpg, that was driving like an utter saint nothing above 60 for over an hour on the motorway for my daily commut i got 32mpg.

my polo gt isnt bad on fuel but my heap 'o' junk GTD blows it away. i rag the arse off it and STILL see 40mpg. you WONT get that with a petrol, hell if i changed gear at 5k every gear in the polo i wouldnt see that mileage...

for MPG diesel rules, for drivability, petrol.

What about a 1.4 8v? Should see 45mpg and cheaper tax and parts then the 1.9D

I'm not convinced by older diesels, the new ones are really good but the older ones arn't anything amazing imo, my 1.6 GT is better on fuel then my mates 1.5 106D :lol:

that's just crap, the pre-PD engines give better MPG than the PD ones, less power but better mpg. Why are parts more expensive? Have you actually ever owned and ran a diesel car for any length of time or just repeating rumours and chinese-whispers you've heard as so many people on here seem to like to do? The 1.9 diesel (either TDI or NA) is bullet proof, they regularly go well over 200k with nothing more than oil changes and general servicing needing to be done.

Having said that, what with the extra money you'll pay to actually buy a diesel car over the equivalent petrol one, coupled with the fact that diesel is about 10p per litre more expensive at the moment means she'll have to be doing a fair bit of motorway miles to make it worthwhile. Or run it on old chip fat!

She will probably find the NA 1.9 diesel slow and unrefined after driving the valver though.

How is that crap? I gave an example that i know is true. My mates 106 1.5 diesel will do 100 miles to 10l, so will my 1.6. Sure he could get more with progressing even slower which would be ridiculous .

I get just over 200 miles from 20liters from my 1.6 my mates 106 1.5D will do 200 miles too, except its slower and boring to drive.

You dont think parts are more exspensive, are you real?

A head gasket set for my engine is half what one is for a 1.9D polo, thats the same for most service items.

And yes i have owned a 1.9D mk4 for 8 months.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.