Skip to content

Been Offered Rear Disc Conversion!

Featured Replies

Hey peeps.

Just got into work and two techies have offered me a rear disc conversion for my 1.6 its a mk5 rear conversion. I've read threads about it and get mixed statements that they fit and dont fit. I've been offered it for £150 fitted and supplied now i know thats a great deal so I'm wondering wether to go for it or am i going to run into problems :(

Thanks all

Arran

  • Replies 21
  • Views 1.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

the rear axle from mk5 does not fit a mk4, you will need to fit the mk5 stub axles on the mk4 beam also need the disc handbrake cables and adjust the load sensor.

not a worthwhile conversion if you ask me, i converted my polo gti to run drums so i could rum 13's and the brakes worked better.

also 90% of the time handbrake efficiency is rubbish on disc set up.

  • Author

so dont bother really then, just get my drums painted :D

can't think of any good reason bar it's easier to change the pads as opposed to shoes.

i sold my complete rear axle off my gti with anti roll bar, calipers (red gti spec), discs, brake lines, abs sensors and handbrake cables for £120

  • Author

i wont bother then :D cool cheers mate

dunno why you would say its not a worthwhile conversion? mine is a million times better, easier service, better braking feel. i've even got 13" wheels over mine not sure why you couldnt on a gti?

  • Author

oh so i should perhaps go for it then :s

drums work better.

Ask yourself this, Do you actually need better brakes? are you not happy with yours atm?

If you ask me its a waste of money. id rather spend it on something more worthwhile.

  • Author

nah id rather just paint the calipers and drums :lol: cheaper lol

keep your drums tbh, not worth paying laods for something you dont need IMO

drums work better.

:? why? because youve got them on your car?? drums dont work better :lol: with a disk set up on the rear the disapates heat and stops build up of dust etc.. so makes rear brakes more efficient.

no i run discs on the ibiza as standard.

i'm not getting into this whole debate again but there was a massive arguement before when i said i was binning the discs for rear drums on my polo 6n2 running tuned g40 lump, it ended in a braking engineer confirming that drums infact do work better than discs something to do with the leading edge of the shoe and progressive force or something.

the thread has since been deleted due to the abusive nature - unfortunately or i'd have a nice quote for you.

They both work as well as you could possibly need - its the back axle we're talking about here,not the front. Discs cool quicker,but that doesnt matter on the back. Shimano Deore LX would probably be enough..

But the main point here for Acg is cosmetic - how the brakes look in his open-spoke wheels.

Drums aint generally regarded as pretty,but one strength they do have over discs is the handbrake. A few manufacturers,or rather their customers,have had problems with cars rolling down hills quarter hour after being parked,because the brake loosens as it cools (though I've not heard of the 6n2 having this problem). Drums,however,tighten as they cool down - so drums are best for use as handbrakes.

My drums are not Polo drums. They're bigger. An inch bigger,at 200mm. And they're wider,so they act as spacers too. And they cost 15 quid. And are a straight fit with existing handbrake cables. And matt black is definately the coating to have,to keep the appearance focus on the wheel (but dont paint the clamp face).

Some moan about changing shoes,but they're easy enough,and you'll only need to do them once in 50k miles.

Rear discs are an unnecessary extravagance,imo,that offer no benefit over MK3 Golf drums other than appearance.

  • Author

thank you mikey so would golf mk3 drums be a straight swap onto my mk4 polo? nothing else needed?

Drums are better for handbrake turns.

well i can only go off personal experience but i ran drums on various mk3 polos and they were never great, and a shit to service.

Ran mk3 golf rear disks on the G40 and a year of using them i have had no problems, the reaction from pulling the handbrake is great, locks up straight away, and general braking just feels firmer.

those exact reasons are why i did it, so yeah I'm glad i did!

I've never had a car with rear disc brakes so cant really comment on how good or bad they are. the only thing i would say is that i'd sooner spend £150 upgrading my front brakes and maybe fitting braiding lines etc, rather than spend that money on fitting discs to the rear of my car.

Well the MK3 drums are a financial no-brainer,so its a personal choice.

But even if i was to use rear discs,i wouldn't be paying 150 quid for them - 'mates rates' it aint.

  • Author

bit confused lol as mate just told me they of a 1.4 16v 6n2 but i didnt think they had discs at the rear unless they were 100bhp and 75bhp had drums I'm confused, so is there any difference in size to 6n2 gti and 6n2 1.4 16v discs at rear? an answer from mikey mk or someone that knows for defiante would be great :D

i got offered a complete set up off a mk2 golf gti for £80 even included the master cylinder and hand brake cables

  • Author

yeah I'm only swapping the hubs and discs, pads etc not the handbrake cables

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.