Skip to content

Mk2 Or Mk3 Polo? Which One As A Daily?

Featured Replies

Hey all.

I'm thinking of buying a daily as i really want to save money on petrol on my 1.6 MK4, but am looking to buy a really cheap (£200 and under) but reliable and not TOO shabby Polo, prefferably 1.0L as they supposidely good on fuel :D

Just need people in the know on older polos to give me a 'buyers guide' as it where on the mk2 and 3 , like what to look for, common faults, town driving mpg and very basic modification ideads :D

Any help would be greatly appreciated as I'm not to clued up on older ones

Thank you all

  • Replies 46
  • Views 3.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Hey

Correct me if I am wrong, but would you really be saving that much in fuel on a 1.6 to buy another car?

And before anyone starts biting my ankles, yes I drive another polo as my daily but that is so my G40 doesn't get hit with the mileage as it is on 145k, if it was lower, trust me, I wouldn't have a 2nd car.

It would be costing you more with the extra outgoing of another car, tax, mot, fuel... surely?

  • Author

yeah but soon I'm going to sell the 1.6 aswell because I'm going jap :p unless i can find a nice mk2 golf gti 16v. but yeah for now just need a really cheap runabout to save mileage on 1.6 its low at 87000 on a p plate but would like to keep it under 90 for when i sell her up :D anyone know a 'buyers guide' to both models. also i get my mots free lol

Edited by acg1990

  • Author

they seem shit :lol: but i really like them and wouldnt mind either thats in good condition

yeah but soon I'm going to sell the 1.6 aswell because I'm going jap :p unless i can find a nice mk2 golf gti 16v. but yeah for now just need a really cheap runabout to save mileage on 1.6 its low at 87000 on a p plate but would like to keep it under 90 for when i sell her up :D anyone know a 'buyers guide' to both models. also i get my mots free lol

You're the 3rd person I know who's leaving the dub scene to go jap :lol: I want a CRX as a daily :shock: I want a skyline too tbh, I was even browsing for one a few months ago on piston heads haha dreaming again! My need for a G60 rally is more important...

Ah I see, good choice

I'd say buy a MK3 :smirk:

Polo3 FTW :nod:

  • Author

yeah my dream car is a tt supra :D will pull the pants down of a skyline :lol: i think il go for either a 200sx or glanza to start with. yeah dubs are to slow lol but look good i think il mix both :D and have a old polo as a daily and still attend no rice and the jap beast for weekends and shows :D

1.0L SPIs aren't bad on fuel at all. But the carb 1.0Ls are slow and bad on fuel.

Hey

Correct me if I am wrong, but would you really be saving that much in fuel on a 1.6 to buy another car?

And before anyone starts biting my ankles, yes I drive another polo as my daily but that is so my G40 doesn't get hit with the mileage as it is on 145k, if it was lower, trust me, I wouldn't have a 2nd car.

It would be costing you more with the extra outgoing of another car, tax, mot, fuel... surely?

having owned a mk4 1.6 glx, i'd say they were poor with regards to fuel economy, main reason being that they need a bit of a thrashing to make them go! getting a 1 litre might not be such a great idea though, cos they require constant thrashing to make them attempt to go! having said that i did run a 1 litre spi, that had a few tweaks and it would happily do 240 miles on £20 of fuel, which isnt bad cosidering it was thrashed for every single one of those miles! the old mk2 formel c might be worth looking into. it'll be mega slow, but capable of big mpg

you'd be best off with a 1.3 fitted with a 5 speed box if you want something that isnt totally gutless

Edited by g40jon

a polo with 87k and one with 90k are going to be worth pretty much the same anyway. Give it a new service before you sell it and it will be fine. It is just a 1.6 at the end of the day so its not a sought after model. People dont go out hunting for a low mileage 8v 1.6.

  • Author

always gets serviced very regularly. dont see many 1.6's around now (especially 5 door) and some people preffer them to valvers like me :D. I'm not really bothered about performance in dubs which is why I'm going jap, so my car doesnt get thrashed about like most valvers and the 8v engines take alot of shit unlike the valvers :lol: also the gearbox on the AEE's are rock solid plus mines already had a biuld to be on the safe side. so a 1.0 spi would do me fine really (mk2 or mk3?) just like dubs to look good not go fast lol

^^ word.

know1 really cares about low milage 1.6s, 16vs maybe

  • Author

valvers are the most popular model yes but i like to drive not thrash lol so i bought a 1.6 its nice and laid back to drive and the power is available very easily unlike valvers that need revs and thats where the problems begin when ragging as it just wears the engine down and box down rather quickly :lol:, threads on oh dear my box or engine has blown :lol: drive nicely and treat her well and and youll be fine until age takes its toll on both :D then buy a toy to thrash about :D i looked for a low mileage 1.6 and in 5 door form

After owning a couple of mk2s and mk3s, IMO, there's not much in it between the two. I'd say if you want it to drive back and forth, get a mk3.

  • Author

mk3 it is but a 1.0spi :lol: woooow to fast :p

If i was buying a car for economy and reliablity i would probably favour a 1 Litre Mk3, as its Single Point Injection you wont be plagued by carb-icing. However I do prefer the Mk2 shape and Coupe S's are affordable, reliable once your given it a good service and should be economical for both short and long jaunts

Yeah, mines a 1.0ltr MK3 and I can't fault it tbh and I do rag the shit out of it daily :paranoid: Quite nippy for what is, but I would prefer a MK2 over looks becuse they're so much cuter - Not that a bloke looks at that :lol:

  • Author

are you a bird then :p

I was waiting for one of your funny random videos then Saf :lol:

Que walshy's post, that should be funnier :idea:

are you a bird then :p

I'm female, yes

mk3 it is but a 1.0spi :lol: woooow to fast :p

good for a over a ton when fitted with the 1300 inlet manifold and a 1800 throttlebody fitted with the polo 1300 injector. reasonably nippy for a 1 litre too.

  • Author

wont be modding it like that as i want it to be cheap on petrol lol

If your trying to get big MPG you shouldnt be ragging it anyway.

id probably side with these guys and get the 1litre SPI

or u could go old school with a 1 litre 4 speed mk2 like aaron :D

I'm rocking the Mk2 1.0 4 speed at the moment :lol:

I got 350 miles for about £30 - Town driving and general abusing haha!

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.