Skip to content

Mk2 Or Mk3 Polo? Which One As A Daily?

Featured Replies

thats enough to tempt u over arron, go for a mk2 :D

plus they are dirt cheap and have loads of character

  • Replies 46
  • Views 3.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Erm..

Buying a second car wont save money. There's the cost of the car, buy a really cheap one and it could be very problematic and costly to fix, then you've got to insure it.. the 1.6 aren't bad on petrol, compared to sportier models like GTi's and G40's..

No-one will care if a P-reg Polo is on 90k or just under, as long as its got service history and is well maintained. And its the 6n2 GTi's that have troublesome boxes, not 6n Valvers.. and their engines dont blow up, if their power peaks at a higher RPM, the engine is gonna be designed to handle that strain, you dont see V-Tec's blowing up all over the place and they redline at over 8k.

Dubs aren't slow. Yeah, big power tuning might be more popular in the Jap scene, but with the vast majority of big-boy Golfs, and even some Polo's, running 1.8T's at 300bhp+, you can hardly call them slow.. have you seen the twin engined ones at the shows?

Oh and if you're talking about the R34, a Supra TT won't pull its pants down. Not only helped by 4 wheel drive, the R34 GTR's are so much more advanced than Supra's. Tbh even R33's would hold their own against one.

Edited by smithy_6n

depends on the insurance then, i only had to pay £78 to insure the Polo TPFT as obviously when I'm in the Polo the Golf is in the *cough cough* garage.

Yeah but how old is he?

Under 20 the insurance is gonna be circa- £500..?

ruddy 'eck, were all you are mods declared ? ;)

i want one, but going to have to try and do some sort of "multicar" insurance go so i can still run the GT when i feel like it, I'm such a mug.

Personally I much prefer the shape and feel of the mk2. When I bought mine it was a well maintained and low mileage example with full VW service history and I was surprised at just how nippy it was for a 1 litre. However, fuel economy wasn't as good as it should have been, mainly due to the Pierburg carb.

I never found the need to rag it around foot to the floor screaming the bollocks off it either, just half throttle and quick gear changes were all that was needed to make good progress. The non servo'd brakes do take some getting used to, and they lack any real bite even when correctly adjusted.

TBH, I think for ease of driving a mk3 1 litre would be a bit better for a daily driver. The power to weight ratio is slightly worse and the spi has slower throttle response so they feel slightly less sprightly than the mk2. However, anything that does away with the nasty Pierburg has got to be a big improvement, no more carb icing, stalling when cold etc.

Fuel injection brings more accurate metering of fuel, hence economy improves. The servo'd brakes are an improvement and less painted metal on show inside makes them feel a warmer place to be in the winter.

The mk3 is better, but not necessarily best!

MK2 FTW! 8-):thumbsup:

Edited by breadman

i found my 1.3 spi mk3 more ecomomical than my 1 litre

most 1.3s are 5 speeds compared to 4, and you dont have to redline it to actually get up hills which you do with the 1043.

real world economy anyway, whatever the book says

yeah but soon I'm going to sell the 1.6 aswell because I'm going jap :p unless i can find a nice mk2 golf gti 16v. but yeah for now just need a really cheap runabout to save mileage on 1.6 its low at 87000 on a p plate but would like to keep it under 90 for when i sell her up :D anyone know a 'buyers guide' to both models. also i get my mots free lol

You're the 3rd person I know who's leaving the dub scene to go jap :lol: I want a CRX as a daily :shock: I want a skyline too tbh, I was even browsing for one a few months ago on piston heads haha dreaming again!

i want a Civic EK9 type R. 1.6 180 horses...

skyline gts's are available for rallye money. 8-)

i found my 1.3 spi mk3 more ecomomical than my 1 litre

most 1.3s are 5 speeds compared to 4, and you dont have to redline it to actually get up hills which you do with the 1043.

real world economy anyway, whatever the book says

Around town I doubt there is much in it economy wise between the 1.0 and 1.3 litre spi's. Yeah, if you regularly do longer runs, particularly motorway use the 1.3 is much better - particularly in 5 speed form. Like you suggest, real world economy.

However, I don't agree with your statement about having to redline a 1 litre to get up hills. You may only be jesting but that's bullshit as they ain't that bad at all. I certainly never had to drive the bollocks off mine to get reasonable performance, uphill or down.

  • Author

damn only asked about whih one i should get lol and yes it is very well maintained my car.

ruddy 'eck, were all you are mods declared ? ;)

The Polo has no mods (yet) and considering my main car is a 150bhp Golf Mk2 they would rather I'm in the £50 Polo :lol: I'm paying a total of just over £900 for both the cars -20yr, 3NCB.

EDIT: My 25yr old bro is insured on the Polo as well.

Edited by kerrly

redline exaguration.

but to tot around and the speeds i want to do around hilly sheffield (not trashing but i dont drive like a granny)

the 1.3 accomodated with much less right foot action

Erm..

Buying a second car wont save money. There's the cost of the car, buy a really cheap one and it could be very problematic and costly to fix, then you've got to insure it.. the 1.6 aren't bad on petrol, compared to sportier models like GTi's and G40's..

have you ever owned a g40? they are far better on fuel than a mk4 1.6 so long as your not thrashing the hell out of them all day long. I had a mk4 1.6 glx and its the worst vw I've ever owned fuel economy wise and it fell into the higher tax band.

I'd say a 1.3 Mk2.

Why?

I've found the 1.3's to be better on fuel than the 1.05's, because they don't work so hard.

Assuming it's German built and in a dark colour (so it's got nice thick paint on to keep the tinworms at bay), there's nothing to go wrong with a mk2 that can't be fixed with a hammer and a trip to a scrapyard.

  • Author

whats the economy and performance like on a mk3 GT and a mk2 coupe s or whatever the best model mk2 is :D

Any 1.3 Mk2 has the same power output (on paper) - 55hp.

There's 3 engines, HK, MH, 2G. All rated at 55hp.

HK - Recognisable by 8 stud rocker cover, fitted til about 84-5 - Alrightish on fuel, high 30's, ,ow 40's. Good fun to drive, suprisingly revvy.

MH - 3 stud rocker cover - Not as much in the way of smile factor, but bloody good on fuel, low 40mpgs easily

2G - Looks virtually identical to MH, basically it was the Golf version of the same engine as I understand it and fitted to late Mk2s on a random basis (parts bin cars?). Torquier than MH, probably not so great on fuel.

Doesn't matter whether it's a Coupe S, a CL or a Ranger, or what body shape, the 1.3 engine is still one of the above, and the only thing to say which is year.

GT's are 75hp, good fun to drive, quick but don't kid yourself they're fast. Fuel consumption should be in the 40mpgs, but like anything, it depends how you drive it.

I'm rocking the Mk2 1.0 4 speed at the moment :lol:

I got 350 miles for about £30 - Town driving and general abusing haha!

Do you? Haha that's mint

I get under 400 on a full tank in my littlebeast!

Erm..

Buying a second car wont save money. There's the cost of the car, buy a really cheap one and it could be very problematic and costly to fix, then you've got to insure it.. the 1.6 aren't bad on petrol, compared to sportier models like GTi's and G40's..

have you ever owned a g40? they are far better on fuel than a mk4 1.6 so long as your not thrashing the hell out of them all day long. I had a mk4 1.6 glx and its the worst vw I've ever owned fuel economy wise and it fell into the higher tax band.

Yeah but is the slight saving on fuel and slightly cheaper tax gonna make up for the price of buying and insuring one?

at one time the mk4 was the same price at the G40, and insurance isnt much of an issue when you got a nice amount of NCB.

Erm..

Buying a second car wont save money. There's the cost of the car, buy a really cheap one and it could be very problematic and costly to fix, then you've got to insure it.. the 1.6 aren't bad on petrol, compared to sportier models like GTi's and G40's..

have you ever owned a g40? they are far better on fuel than a mk4 1.6 so long as your not thrashing the hell out of them all day long. I had a mk4 1.6 glx and its the worst vw I've ever owned fuel economy wise and it fell into the higher tax band.

Yeah but is the slight saving on fuel and slightly cheaper tax gonna make up for the price of buying and insuring one?

whats that got to do with anything? you were making out that the g40 burns fuel like theres no tommorow, i was mearly setting you straight. i can get well in excess of 30 mpg out of my g40. when i had my 1.6 glx the best mpg i had was around 35 mpg, so when compared the g40 isnt that bad. in fact my g40 is probably only a small amount thirstier than my 1 litre mk2.

at one time the mk4 was the same price at the G40, and insurance isnt much of an issue when you got a nice amount of NCB.

i sold my mk4 for more than i paid for my g40 and i only pay £230 fully comp with mods declared to insure the g40 and to be honest a 1.6 glx wouldnt be much cheaper as insurance companies will only go so low.

ruddy 'eck, were all you are mods declared ? ;)

The Polo has no mods (yet) and considering my main car is a 150bhp Golf Mk2 they would rather I'm in the £50 Polo :lol: I'm paying a total of just over £900 for both the cars -20yr, 3NCB.

EDIT: My 25yr old bro is insured on the Polo as well.

same as me :D well 3yr NCB in march i think, should be 3 years now but a bit of a cock up occured when i bought the polo and my insurer of my old mini refused to insure me on it :S so i had to ditch them and go for another policy, 3 months short of gaining another year of no claims :( bad times.

maybe ill put my dad on the mk2 insurance :smirk: I'm sure he wouldnt mind...

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.