Skip to content

Which Is Quicker...

Featured Replies

Which is quicker in a straight line a Mk2 golf GTI 8v or a mk4 polo 16v

both serviced regularly etc both standard

  • Replies 116
  • Views 8.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

id imagine mk2 8v mate as they have about 110bhp compared to 100bhp, and are about the same weight/slightly lighter? I'm sure their stated 0-60 time is marginally lower too.

It'll depend on the state of the car,at this age. But i'll say the Golf.

I've driven a few MK2 8v GTi's and the best by far,as a drivers car,was a totally standard silver '85 Bosch-k on its original P-slots.

I have no experience with Polo valvers.

Well reading in a haynes mk2 golf mod book in halfauds it says early mk2 gtis upto 1986 have mechanical injection system they are apparently 0-60 8.4

and i think 1986 models 8 v that is have hydro tappets so you wont need to adjust them

where as the later type more modern engine code PB is 0-60 in 9.2 says the book

or mk2 16v is 0-60 in 7.4 with 139BHP is that helpful

not sure on the mk4 polo 16v

but have had been given a 1989 late type mk2 golf GTI tired but still very fun and nippy and fairly ec on fuel if driven ok upto 40mpg if you want. driven hard i got 35mpg hope thats any use.

even stock they handle well.

Edited by jmk2g40

With both cars in equal good standard condition, the mk2 Golf GTi 8v would be quicker just about everywhere - not just the benchmark 0-60.

They're not only more powerful, but the GTi 8v is noted for having a good broad spread of torque, something the 1.4 16v Polo doesn't.

The up to '86 models run the mechanical K-jetronic injection system whereas the later ones use a proper electronic Digifant system.

Both engines are very strong and take big mileages no problem. However, they must be one of the ugliest engines ever!

i've driven a few 16v polos and find them all slightly different! the engine thats in my mk3 is really really torquey, but i've driven others that are really flat. i still say the slightly lardier mk4 would lose out to the golf tho.

Golf 8sec, Polo 10sec............................................

you thinking about getting either xcore??

  • Author

debating these two for my next car, think its going to be the golf as they are aparrently quicker, obviously cooler and cheaper.

is k-jet better then the digifant? i heard with digifant the electricals are pretty much plug and play for a vr?

cheers for all replys

Edited by xcore

You won't have to kick the Golf in the bollocks all day to get it to move either.

You won't have to kick the Golf in the bollocks all day to get it to move either.

And 8v mk2 golfs don't eat gearboxes like 16v polos do either.

You won't have to kick the Golf in the bollocks all day to get it to move either.

+1

You won't have to kick the Golf in the bollocks all day to get it to move either.

And 8v mk2 golfs don't eat gearboxes like 16v polos do either.

They aint exactly great on them though!

16v Golf boxes are much stronger in my experiance

digipantz can be alreet if looked after.

i'd say mk3 abf tho, mk2s are fetching strong money still and alot need some tlc...

is k-jet better then the digifant? i heard with digifant the electricals are pretty much plug and play for a vr?

k-jet is more responsive, you gotta play with the fueling

digi, ever heard of digi lag?? They tend to be better purely as they are in the newer mk2 golfs.

  • Author

does the digifants have a fly by wire throttle or something?

I'm planning on buying one, working on it(servising etc) untill i can afford to change over insurance

  • Author
digipantz can be alreet if looked after.

i'd say mk3 abf tho, mk2s are fetching strong money still and alot need some tlc...

i can only just insure a mk2 8v lol insurance will just laugh at me if i asked about an abf

Id say the 8v. But a valvers 0-60 time has got to be less than 10 seconds! I've done 9 in mine without a doubt!

does the digifants have a fly by wire throttle or something?

I'm planning on buying one, working on it(servising etc) untill i can afford to change over insurance

I'm sure the mk4 16v polo has digifant injection, and that's not fly by wire. Cable leads directly from the pedal to the throttle body.

No, it's not fly by wire, it's just the Digifant system has a small lag which varies car to car. K-jet is good and better for overall performance iirc, better tunability.

  • Author

hmm looks like il be looking for a early kjet with a solid engine! cheers chaps

Found a thread on some forum, can't remember exactly which, but just basically explained how to setup the digifant properly which eliminates digi-lag.

I'll try find it ina bit

aye that's the one

The Digifant system is the same as used on mk3 Polo GT.

K jetronic is crude by comparison. It can be played with to improve power, but isn't as clever because it's effectively just a mechanical system.

I would think the Digifant system was used on later models to improve emissions and economy. If the later models were actually any slower, it would only be because of an increase in kerb weight due to higher equipment levels and or gear ratios because the engines were all circa 112bhp regardless of the type of injection used.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.