Skip to content

Repair Or Brake My 6n?

Featured Replies

Bit of a long one here I'm afraid!

Spent a good few weeks a few months back looking for a 1.4 6N and found my '97 one in Dragon green with 71K miles, main dealer service history, recent cambelt, recent & new tyres, ran well and was in generally good condition. Found it not long after the ad appeared and by the end of the evening or so they had 20 odd people wanting to see it! Anyway once I had it I had new front discs & pads, rear brakes adjusted, did the oil and oil filter change, fitted Bosch super 4 plugs, air filter change, another central locking pump, a new aerial, new GTI gear knob, mk.5 red rear lights, clear front indicators and have it a good clean. After that and the mileage I would do in it, it should have seen me for a couple of years without much needing doing.

It ran smooth, the engine & gearbox were great and I was pretty happy with it, then on the way to work last week, when sitting stationary a Fiesta crashed into the back of me and pushed me into the VW Sharron in front. Both bumpers have had it, as have both headlights, also the grill, the rear panels beneath the rear lights have been pushed in, the hatch is slightly dented in each corner, there is a slight crease in the drivers rear quarter panel and the boot back behind the rear bumper is pushed in. Have been to bodyshop guy and he said he could reapir it, but how much it costs depends on how long is takes to get the boot straight and also if I get the bumpers etc inthe right colour, then of course it will save me the spraying costs of doing those.

Now officially it's a cat c write-off, but I can take the money they offer and buy another one, retain the car and repair it, or reatin the car and break it. Now I've looked on the Autotrader website etc and the pirces seem to have gone up, partly because most of them seem to be for sale by dealers. I guess because they know they can sell cars like that easier than more expensive, larger engined cars. But anyway, I think for the money they will offer me, I will not be able to get a similar car, and especially with all the service work etc just been done. One like mine with similar miles, same colour, model and year on Autotrader is £995 and it needs TLC! Other 3 door CL 1.4's with similar miles and age etc are £1195-£1800 (£1800 is a joke of a price!). There's older, lower spec, higher mileage, ones without history or smaller engined ones for a lot of money than what I paid for mine. Also it's trying to get to a car first! With the one I bought, I rang them within an hour of the ad appearing, and my Dad went to look at it a few hours later. If I'd waited to see it until the evening (the first evening after the ad appeared), it would have been sold! So trying to find a good one at a cheap price is pretty hard and stressful!

The insurance company say that if I repair it, I'll need to get a vechile check, new MOT and it won't be worth as much as it's a repaired write off. If I repair it though it will be done right and look just the same, but how much less it will be worth I don't know. If I'm keeping it for a few years, then I guess it won't matter so much, but of course it will if it gets damaged again.

What would you do in my position?

Edited by Aquablue

  • Replies 4
  • Views 863
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

i'd need a quote for all work that needs doing to it before i thought about what to do next. It maybe worth repairing but if its gonna be expensive, you maybe better off just breaking it i'm afraid.

  • Author
i'd need a quote for all work that needs doing to it before i thought about what to do next. It maybe worth repairing but if its gonna be expensive, you maybe better off just breaking it i'm afraid.

Was told it would be £300-£400 I think it was with me supplying the parts, but if I get the same colour bumpers and hatch, then it would save respraying those and of course then would be cheaper. Would need the rear bumper off first give a more exact quote and to check it isn't worse than thought.

just think can you buy a car the same as yours was for the money it will cost to repair?

if it costs a little more to repair at least you will have your old car back with all the mods and servicing you have done and at least you know what its like?

anyway you choose good luck mate

yo dude sound pretty bad i do paint sprayin n body repair id just bye a knew one to be honast because the time its in there and the money u spend gettin it fixed will probly add up to more than u bought the car for but thats not for me to say because i dnt no how much the blokes chargin u and how much the cars worth

i would brake the car get a knew one any mods u have done if uv done any u can take off you polo and put on you new one

anyways good luck with it all

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.