Skip to content

Whats Better Mk3 G40 Or Mk2 Golf Gti 16v

Featured Replies

Whats better in terms of every aspect e.g. performance, reliability etc and insurance wise.

And how easy to tune?

  • Replies 32
  • Views 3.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Whole package, Golf Gti. driving it in a straight line G40.

seriously, theres a reason the Golf has the reputation that it does. the Mk1 and Mk2 paved the way for the newer cars, i doubt a Mk3 Golf with a Skoda badge on it would have sold nearly aswell without the existance of the Mk1 and Mk2 to give it the publicity and stigma surrounding the brand.

its for this exact reason i have a Polo not a Golf. gotta love the soul of a car hiding in the shadows of its successful brothers limelight.

  • Author

so golf really then

g40 all the way...if properly maintained. theres nothing like boost

first off i`m polo d and wont be changing my name :lol:

secondly the golf does everything beter and the tuning parts are commonly avalable , they dont have silly suspension and if you put in/got a G60 version would do the straight line bit as well

as for reliabilty thats not answerable as both cars are 15+ years old now and it depends on the previous owners , and both cars have different bits that go wrong

i went polo to be different and since realized how rare the g40 is compared to the golf but the golf is an iconic car and in good condition will always be worth money , same as the g40

You thinking of staying dub dude?!?! . . . . . gooooooooooooooo on you know you wanna :-p!!!

for me its a g40 but then I'm just a polo guy!!! :-D

Mk2 Golf G60.. best of both worlds :lol:

G40 all the way

golf gti :p

g40 will be more fun, but the mk2 golf gti will be better overall.

It depends what you're after. A Mk2 Golf handles better, looks better out of the box (ok, so that's opinion) and doesn't have a delicate supercharger to worry about. Parts are cheaper and easier to get hold of too.

But on the flip side, Golfs are pretty common and not that fast by modern standards. A G40 is a proper little Q-Car, faster in a straight line and much easier to tune. But, you'll have to spend more on the suspension to get the handling up to spec and there's always the chance that you'll shred your supercharger.

Reliability due to previous wear and tear isn't really an issue here. Yes, an immaculate G40 will probably give you less problems than a GTI which has been ragged silly, but the Golf is the more reliable car. Find two equivalent examples and you'll get less hassle from the Golf.

and, a vr6 will go nicely in a mk2 golf.... mmmmm vr goodness.

it wont balls the handling up if you use mk3 golf subframe and suspension, and you get the best vw engine sound...

and the 1.8t conversions are silly cheap at the moment.

If you're talking stock vs stock, I reckon the GTI wins hands down. Adding tuning into the matter opens a whole new can of worms...yes, the G40 being forced induction has more scope for tuning, but then again getting circa 175 BHP out of the GTI is quite easy to do with a 9A bottom end and an ABF cam. Handling wise, the Golf would win hands down and even if you bring subframes, coilovers, ARBs, etc into the question I think the Golf would still handle better with some mods...

Depends what you want, if you just want to go fast in a straight line the G40 may be the better option, but for I think the Golf would be a better daily and have the advantage on twisty country roads.

That's my 2p.

Ash :)

Having pasted a tuned Mk3 G40 around a track, power isn't everything. I reckon point to point you'd need a fair amount of power to hassle a Mk2 Golf on the limit, unless you've got a LSD and/or a subframe on your G40. Making a properly quick G40 means spending big bucks on the chassis, then tweaking the engine.

  • Author

maybe arron mate but I'm waying up options of supra vs golf/G40

A heavey MK2 Golf or a go kart G40?

Know which one I'd chose :nod: I'm not slating the Mk2 as I will own one, one day OEM'ed like a sexy bitch haha but don't think the MK2 would be as much fun and if you look after a G40 it's as good as anything!

A heavey MK2 Golf or a go kart G40?

Know which one I'd chose :nod: I'm not slating the Mk2 as I will own one, one day OEM'ed like a sexy bitch haha but don't think the MK2 would be as much fun and if you look after a G40 it's as good as anything!

you need a ride in a sorted mk2 golf...

makes mk3 polo handling look stone age.

altho a subframe'd g40 might proove worthy competition...

mk2 has to win on versitillity, it can take anything froma g40 lump to a v8...(those crazy canadians)

Sorry but the only mk2 golf I'd own would have an audi rs6 in the back!

Hmmmmmmmmmm...........RS6

Id go for the mk2 golf 16v its capable of more . And if you get a clean 1 you will look at it with pride . its a golf gti ffs lol

Having pasted a tuned Mk3 G40 around a track, power isn't everything. I reckon point to point you'd need a fair amount of power to hassle a Mk2 Golf on the limit, unless you've got a LSD and/or a subframe on your G40. Making a properly quick G40 means spending big bucks on the chassis, then tweaking the engine.

Decent LSD and subframe/wishbones make so much difference to the Polo. In the wet at Oulton Park Yoof stuck to the arse of a Mk2 Golf 20v conversion in the corners, and went past on the straight. The nitrous bottle was at home that day too.

  • Author
Having pasted a tuned Mk3 G40 around a track, power isn't everything. I reckon point to point you'd need a fair amount of power to hassle a Mk2 Golf on the limit, unless you've got a LSD and/or a subframe on your G40. Making a properly quick G40 means spending big bucks on the chassis, then tweaking the engine.

Decent LSD and subframe/wishbones make so much difference to the Polo. In the wet at Oulton Park Yoof stuck to the arse of a Mk2 Golf 20v conversion in the corners, and went past on the straight. The nitrous bottle was at home that day too.

dont say that i want a g40 :lol: i think il hve to have a ride in both to make up my mind

Golf GTi 16v FTW! Iused to own this one, lowered 40mm (ish), custom strut braces front and back, went like a bastard round corners.

Dry weight 985kg I believe.

DSCN3312.jpg

Thats what I'm after but an 8v, prob stick a 2.0 bottom end on it and port the head with a lairy cam.

Wouldnt mind a tornado red one.

Having pasted a tuned Mk3 G40 around a track, power isn't everything. I reckon point to point you'd need a fair amount of power to hassle a Mk2 Golf on the limit, unless you've got a LSD and/or a subframe on your G40. Making a properly quick G40 means spending big bucks on the chassis, then tweaking the engine.

Decent LSD and subframe/wishbones make so much difference to the Polo. In the wet at Oulton Park Yoof stuck to the arse of a Mk2 Golf 20v conversion in the corners, and went past on the straight. The nitrous bottle was at home that day too.

Both are must-haves, near top of my wish list as soon as I've got the cash! Mine's suffering a bit because the suspension kit is more than seven years old, and it's had a decent workout for that time too. New stuff on the way though.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.