Skip to content

Whats Better Mk3 G40 Or Mk2 Golf Gti 16v

Featured Replies

i think a LSD and subframe are at the top of every G40 owners list matey!

  • Replies 32
  • Views 3.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Definately the Golf, people say the G40 is better in a straight line? Not stock v stock.

I like the room in the Golf and all the lazy people toys: c/l, e/w, PAS, electric sun-roof.

And 16v's like being abused when serviced/maintained well.

Gotta love the wishbones etc

got to be the golf for me the g40 engine is to fragile but has more unusual factor , but you cant beat cubic inches for reliability

Definately the Golf, people say the G40 is better in a straight line? Not stock v stock.

I like the room in the Golf and all the lazy people toys: c/l, e/w, PAS, electric sun-roof.

And 16v's like being abused when serviced/maintained well.

Gotta love the wishbones etc

i was going to say id love a g40 but i really dont know if i could go back to pov spec like my GT again

at least with the golf you have a sorted car from the box

i think both cars look awesome! however owning a g40 i am of course slightly biased, but have also never driven a mk2.

i love having a charged engine! it is soooo fun!

I've owned a stock g40 at the same time my brother owned a late small bumper 16v. The 16v had pas, electric windows, central locking and was a practical daily car. My g40 was quick in the dry but rubbish in the wet and it handled like all standard gs do .....rubbish.

The best thing abou the g40 was motorway or highway driving as it would surprise most people but for reliability the 16v was the better car, for comfort it was the 16v and for build quality the 16v was better, however for smiles and rarity and looks the g was streets ahead.

also, lets add cost. say you spend £1700 n a really tidy, stock g40, and the same on a mk2 16v...

to get suspension, subframe, decent tyres and LSD your looking at what £1500 again without labour or fitting?

wheras all a mk2 needs is suspension and tyres, the rest could all be spent on going quicker....

The Golf, much as I love Polos, a G40 is just a badly designed shopping trolley with a supercharger. A Mk2 GTI is a far more capable car, less expensive to maintain, argueably more reliable and still weighs under a tonne.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.