Skip to content

Overcharging?

Featured Replies

Hi all,

I keep my car at a workshop where there is a welder guy. I know him quite well but generally don't have to use him until now.

The following needs doing to my Mk1 and he has quoted £600 (just for welding - I've bought all the new parts). I know it's hard to tell without seeing the car but what does everyone think? I'm in the opinion that he is over charging but I really don't know.

2 new sills (one is particularly bad)

Battery tray

New fuel tank

A bit of welding to the floor on front and back of car

Many thanks

Gemma

  • Replies 12
  • Views 1.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

hard to tell without actually seeing what he's got to weld. If he's doing everything properly by cutting the rusty metal completely before welding new bits in then it doesn't sound too bad to me

I agree with Yeti on this, £600 may seem a lot to pay, but you are getting the services of a professional welder. Plus I can guarantee that when the sills come off, the inner sills are highly likely to need work too, plus the rear jacking points and possibly inner/outer rear arches.

Having repaired the same areas on my own mk1 and knowing the hassle of it all, i would bite his hand off. It's a nasty job to weld the extremely thin steel on the mk1 at the best of times. Make sure you buy some really good cavity wax for the new sills, the bilt-hamber stuff is superb.

Yeti? :lol:

Really sorry about that, I saw the transit and as it was a mk1 related post immediately assumed Yeti had responded without looking at the poster's name.

that sounds about right. 250 a side for sills and then few wee spots.

my first austin had lots spent on welding, depresses me when i think about it.

but if you find a good welder there are worth every penny! mine was done by swearing jimmy, at a local classic MG specialist, quality bloke.

so depends if you are keeping the car or not.

if its a keeper shell out.

if its not go somewhere else but you get waht you pay for in welding.

cheep usually = plate over

expencive = chop the rust out, make a panel, fit it, looks invisible when finished.

Yeti? :lol:

Confused the hell out of me too :lol:

Pettsy's probably really offended now you said he drives a Transit.

Must be a T4 transit! Lol

Sounds fare TBH, It was £70 to do a small gash to the floor in one of my old cars after hitting a big stone, he cut away all the damage flattened it out did the work and then resealed the area.

have you seen his work

doesnt sound soo bad if its proper quality work to the highest standards , but dont go paying it for it shonky lash up work

As above, depends on the quality of his work. Always pays to get a couple of prices.

Whereabouts are you? Someone on here may be able to reccomend someone.

Pettsy's probably really offended now you said he drives a Transit.

:x:lol::-p

  • Author

Thanks all for your responses :)

Feel a bit more confident about this now as we had a look at the work in progress over the weekend and it looks really good :)

I would always rather pay the money for a good job but I really had no idea of prices for welding as it's not something I usually get done.

After this will mean the whole underside is sorted so we can wax and paint that black stuff on :) MOT pass here we come!

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.