Skip to content

Valver Or Gt?

Featured Replies

Hi guys.new here and lovin ye'r sweet array of cars.:)basicaly this summer i'm off t collage and hoping t get a new car.i've decided fiesta's,punto's and civic's just aren't going t cut it..so as a dub nut i've decided a polo maybe nice.i'm liking the style of the gts but also the power and modernity of the mk4 valvers..basically because i'l hav t pay through the nose 4 insurance i've decided i need as much bang 4 my buck as i can possibly get,hence the appeal of the 16v's..problem is though i've never driven either as being from Ireland both are pretty rare..so cmon guys and gals convince me either way,which i should choose and why..:-Dthanks in advance,Baz.

  • Replies 65
  • Views 3.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Hi guys.new here and lovin ye'r sweet array of cars.:)basicaly this summer i'm off t collage and hoping t get a new car.i've decided fiesta's,punto's and civic's just aren't going t cut it..so as a dub nut i've decided a polo maybe nice.i'm liking the style of the gts but also the power and modernity of the mk4 valvers..basically because i'l hav t pay through the nose 4 insurance i've decided i need as much bang 4 my buck as i can possibly get,hence the appeal of the 16v's..problem is though i've never driven either as being from Ireland both are pretty rare..so cmon guys and gals convince me either way,which i should choose and why..:-Dthanks in advance,Baz.

Hi dude

Well I've never driven a GT, so i cannot comment on those however I've owned a 1.4 8v and now have a valver and they are sooo fun to drive! I'm not gonna make them out to be the fastest car in the world but they are certainly not slow, and scare quite a few VTR driver if not have them all together!

insurance group 10, so prepare to pay above the odds if your a student.

GT, do a few mods and make it 100bhp and your sorted, will be doing sub 9sec 0-60s then.

Hi guys.new here and lovin ye'r sweet array of cars.:)basicaly this summer i'm off t collage and hoping t get a new car.i've decided fiesta's,punto's and civic's just aren't going t cut it..so as a dub nut i've decided a polo maybe nice.i'm liking the style of the gts but also the power and modernity of the mk4 valvers..basically because i'l hav t pay through the nose 4 insurance i've decided i need as much bang 4 my buck as i can possibly get,hence the appeal of the 16v's..problem is though i've never driven either as being from Ireland both are pretty rare..so cmon guys and gals convince me either way,which i should choose and why..:-Dthanks in advance,Baz.

Hi dude

Well I've never driven a GT, so i cannot comment on those however I've owned a 1.4 8v and now have a valver and they are sooo fun to drive! I'm not gonna make them out to be the fastest car in the world but they are certainly not slow, and scare quite a few VTR driver if not have them all together!

insurance group 10, so prepare to pay above the odds if your a student.

well it doest have more bhp then a VTR...

Aren't they the same?

vtrs have either 90bhp or 99 for the newer ones iirc valver has 100

16v do have more power than a vtr.

Get a valver and drop it on some good coilovers and tyres and you will have an awsome car. I loved mine and would get another one any day.

The 16v just loves to rev and I have a vid of mine doing a 9 sec 0 to 60 some where proving they arnt that slow.

vtr's are 90 hp but they are made out of backed bean tins. so are light as fook.

i would love a gt but personaly would go for a 16v dunno y just would, if u can afford the insurance. but as stated gt's are quick once modded.

LEE

series 2 VTRS are more then 90bhp iirc

16v in my opinion is for comfort and looks with a bit of a thrill from time to time.

GT is just fun though, whereever you drive them.

Personally I'd have a GT if its not needed for any particular reason other than having a car.

series 2 VTRS are more then 90bhp iirc

slighty off subject but your right,

mk1- 90hp 100lbs/ft top speed 116

mk2- 100hp 100lbs/ft top speed 120

but would never have a shitroen, lol. would go for a 16v out of practicality, your gonna win with eather polos thow, lol :)

LEE

Mk2 VTRs are 98 bhp

I'd have a VTR over a Mk4 16v ANY day. :D

^^^^ shhhhh

the 16v may have the same horsepower as the vtr but has more torque iirc so they can have them on occasion depending on how well looked after the vtr is.

but the VTR is an 8v so it doesnt need to be kicked in the balls to get it to go anywere :lol:

Edited by xcore

but the VTR is an 8v so it doesnt need to be kicked in the balls to get it to do anywere :lol:

fair comment dude, fair comment

Tell us what you want from the car, once we know that we can give you a better answer as to which one is going to meet your preferences best!

  • Author
Tell us what you want from the car, once we know that we can give you a better answer as to which one is going to meet your preferences best!

Fair point dude..well i was thinking a gt first for the fun factor and the looks but it doesn't really have the luxury's the valver has,wondering should i spent a lil extra for the extras the mk4 has to offer,also it seems finding a tidy gt is tricky enough...i guess i'm just basically wondering which is the better fun of the 2 at the end of the day?won't b doin serious mileage but would still like t b able t drive in relative comfort..also what are mpg figures like in the 2 cars?thanks 4 the help.Baz

  • Author

Thanks 4 all the comments dudes,shame i'm not looking t buy a vtr,ye all seem t be experts!:Pjust kidding,keep the opinions coming.Baz:)

its easy to say GT all day long

but like jay says it depends what you want from a car

my GT was great to drive, ideal weekend toy, but i live 25 miles from work..using it daily was just horrible...you start to hate the noises. rattle and ride quality that you dismiss when your on some back road enjoying the car

i did well over 15000 miles in my GT...great car, really enjoyed it, in the end i just needed a car that was comfortable as a daily. like my GTI.

owning a GT is a good experience tho...hasnt put me off...just looking for a G40 now..and that will be my summer/ weekend car

Gt is by far the more fun car to drive i think, they're pretty rev happy and take a fair bit of abuse, also its common for mk4's to rot a lot.

Having owned a mk3 and mk4 i found the mk3 GT was far more comfartable as the seats are a lot better and support you well when going round corners.

The Gt is far easier to tune with simple modifications such as putting air flow meters from golfs and chips for a small fee making you squeeze some good power out quickly from the engine.

MPG wise you are likley to see a far better return from the GT whether it be town or motorway driving, i manage 80miles to a tenner with a fuel leak at the moment with steady driving. I also get over 100 to £10 on the motorway if driving very sensibly.

Aslo i found the GT is far better for repairs and breakdowns. My mk4 was forever having problems yet the GT has ahd no major problems except the ones that i have self inflicted by putting some silly lowering kit on thats got something wrong with it.

Infact the only thing i found wasnt as good on the mk3 as the mk4 was the brakes, get these upgraded asap. they're shocking.

However the mk4 does look very good when modified but i suppose thats al ldown to personal preference. I would be tempted to go with the Gt tbh mate. It makes sense to me.

  • Author

Thanks 4 all your help peeps..some good solid advice being handed out.think i'm swaying more towards the gts now tbh..just prefer the look for some reason.:)so any 1 got any advice on some cool mods t get 1 looking and sounding sweet?baz

lower it about 60mm on any wheels from 13's to 15's lol

they sound sweet with a 4branch decat and backbox, all my old one had and it spat flames the lot.

nice rumble :)

easy tunable engines

lower it about 60mm on any wheels from 13's to 15's lol

they sound sweet with a 4branch decat and backbox, all my old one had and it spat flames the lot.

nice rumble :)

easy tunable engines

Obviously wasnt running properly.

Do sound really smooth when you add the 4-branch.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.